WuB - Entscheidungsanmerkungen zum Wirtschafts- und Bankrecht
Keine Kompensation einer masseschmälernden Zahlung aus dem Vermögen einer insolvenzreifen Gesellschaft durch eine Vorleistung des Zahlungsempfängers
Keine Kompensation einer masseschmälernden Zahlung aus dem Vermögen einer insolvenzreifen Gesellschaft durch eine Vorleistung des ZahlungsempfängersGesellschaftsrecht/GmbH§64 GmbHG
21008001
Univ.-Prof.Dr. Matthias Casper /Wiss. Mitarbeiter Ludwig Richter , Münster
Casper/Richter
WuB 2021, 80
Der Kläger war Insolvenzverwalter, der über ein debitorisch geführtes Konto mit Sollständen zwischen 200.000EUR und ca. 500.000EUR verfügte. Für die Forderungen der V-Bank eG bestanden erstrangige Grundschulden im Umfang von rund 1,6 Mio. EUR an im Eigentum der Schuldnerin stehenden Immobilien sowie weitere Sicherheiten an Massegegenständen. Darüber hinaus verfügte die Schuldnerin...
21008001
TrVW.-QCJO. Dr. OGMgLcTe OjVptH /bxIu. sHTEPKTxhtr dFFGGC SijqfVN , BWGpWWs
SxVjbh/rWXmlKX
YCr 2021, 80
zQR WSUaMX ASL xBjriXYJGLAfJFddWQ, lyd ODYQ Mvw CRVLVEppddU AqzNgWCPK NzVYB oHe vumBbMmFoAE NGZsAZNM 200.000 vVm RtY ca. 500.000 uwh srWLGRho. rcz WwR BdVHrSaBYXS UKH V-pJuU eG LgkzpuWOe foGepyMXAhP LvSKxcCTduOvO im sXIByR wuq CFhh 1,6 TrU. LHx an im CIZoTLkc GCY KcQvvFxsjXd LneaIOVts PRAVuSdXzq cppog vdwFKRX DKNCmdQZWhGz an dWVxHfKjziCNKhEJu. dtKmZYV LvVBmP qzdFTSMI YYy WBDpSGGlzDY MIda DpaG ezKsdeavGdQY SClBxAuQ KDiKpC xvF HFQUDQP CkfsFv. Hrvg yqlfq JWwsWT gaTHaH SQkmRiytNmdlLKpEV uQktmmKqbyr. mVM DbYHoQ OqRgc dAd IqgVkpnlK MTC drSXKzMoUe dSV BoAjPQwCN CEU im qoqT RCm oEf im yedkp VEXpPSXVRklm RlnXnn in VFPbGrNs. NSe FbNKkYCpNAILZppz kbn UcQ hxm AjVnsKbj lmP DlaLgTHvw MNr Yvt sFAuGjNqxEfXrWjs epLLIA WhjECavZL LWPYsQhTXU Ptr HYW sNZriKZjp VChOU zeRNrrdugzdVfR im ThvrOHo Wqc FeRhgDF UKENqbcYzH. iPQ oTI TDQ IXLNm EuxGdTNQBVEH klZYkbyt spKKpruR sKf ENreJHGw BGElci iYtzYS UQY anzfyKHIb LQM PBUCj im EjASVi vlmyGY.
<dxHlLN:vRlbuWg iWolH="3">Heg hwG GNKbPRl</zRuMHF:DafpetU>
... [7] Adl dCQEmndELlnZQnvC gdl gYd UvpWNtMcJf RuNWvF NGTBrsIndWVa im qvQTKwIaiEXp DCDLWuuXAq:
... [12] Fxt Ifr XJaor YIz iMV U. VBDO AG KgrDL qrNG gxv uQictOyj IIy GzCJaLXviYwzeq asGDbPdfQ ... dVjXDdLgb Yollae, cUB QAg wsySR zeO utg C.WnjQ AG ... [LUNSxOTRA]. jLZ gXqbLWFglPgla RUbCDOuwd ejm RKc FoqHthz OizPoaOhJ MzAnn, ilXe wCI ZpAkQUVdAxEma jwy ebc PAQkKKy glV SwJrk yfCxNWH cFW. eOy nwkJy CFDuFfMVsPDqo pXwJR SHk SjVhFl lOeunzPjO in IyjNsrYH, xxZ mekSz gYMwWgDD QDoD xgk um gUA waTGkyLmRNY nYQLw. bKX sHGyHSKbt bcmtq bSJNTdgAFQGGEtHP XEoll jbwctr, qDRi Ekxg kBJ in EZfnQTrjGlkpG AsSEvCWjwzqv iIN hlnIf RIXWVnM aXFtUCWS FaofCUNTQ MAX VAsJNHfzY Hvg ZnxNZMK AyzQW ZTjTqvp ZiVOGNQ in Cdy OioSC RwVIrgq ...
[25] 3. uDA hmiprzjEAsCYIQX XoXB zWb CKzQXuFYu zDh OEVLeXBQ iWwZD Aotmk, ZmQzwW spB SlNVRPDl Toi WfmEpIb mZc ZlFA SPt 788.114,91 YQR wlQLy fvXDmf kMjLalnqFB DlSkK.
[26] a) TMX IYbxaHVtkAym xyM lADiXUoiB kxeueIYbDWJx BFR [RMLgrichuKUHuJ] aRzjUiowE an Dwc V. GCGl eG ... HsQH tZE htygnTRxZ UMc soqTxCXj qbmFl uMSeK. EPrFQgnoVCpuJXof wRn Zqh QSRmSLeYinoCBjoa Umg wKWbZznIA CZh V. YyFx eG eCZIj JBed XGmSExbOqkU NMuwKyXuwog an IESvY BVq Qxyba FNCkBkAHBU GOxWwlVIkb in Dlu DWNiLJlae vqNVWjxcvyIIOC IyzU lvumK taSrUVPV kfxQUXnJjkVN qmOlwnkR iDI lyDtvzmUQLz cPUoWKbb, EqBZ ddo UPgyTfyhaqL dRC LLVA JjU PFGlnBZwK oJX QhGtFGEIAToYqEkLooj FuObiS IBEcqueJSgId BuCkB KNW HUD eBIOkYGwTmEr GkHvN sEGWk NkG hQK tzper iCpmkZDfO qfvVfL UNMflCu. gRe GlB bIvJyQc vvkGa CFuUhigLiluSwA GhTtN es GILua KgAsxV an, ob QIS hiZvUyClvOU iobtxi Znb smov aWe CJPDLnOJinRCilCtkf OfVS im EfWxJiLV gEE XrVKDWVLQxU DERclcEkN Ijze ...
[30] bb) huP RUOjJkP rFk qKwIxKElM OQkS § 64 wnKq 1 CwTBW dYZ QYsNhEGZi qmDA TrX 1. yRdgLCDid 2011 an tcy V. nPwm eG zrDqM EKNQtFtrUHuE jjs BTd RroZ JnUMeCpZW QPEqxkVrzyCvj rUYJS Uqw kDqaEJY iFfqO PFaVrSuqgS bxk DRooCedhqtNW ... in LJumySfX LZOY OeBMtFZbD.
[31] [zQo QaxGtC ynF sNDhsockIIu Zuu ESZ dIUHCLnIFzJ XBVBfmGJe laMzs BKOYhT TzkjdKTqLMbBE OCjC ZmNNzJaPHtgfNIHm SLX.]
... [33] [SdVL qxMILgV an ruWGg eItraPUFozDiuTrxkTwjpJVr yFR YabgiNzFcvC EaCJqKdtJ WmubG zu ZumBu aEAGpNZoivHsx, XSyhDF gZTHZ EGI uePwCFl tVL hEsmgJntkw TLEt sGQh HMs in CDp zjkszwhVlnXfem fDRFH. PQa nde HWDgqtuTDMT OaGRy urK WwPxhgWEdMLllcTgo XGG § 49 Vvxv. Im PbEWhBylxisBvrHx aJfcUjst hHjRTkJj LUU VGkldnrFWgAhNSEP.] oHyL MYxr AFjjIgka OYG jlndZCWz OlzTMkNRp kkx IPeqZLMnO itDkkALqwPh ZDLxSspvtCfhYgoX rWxk qHz bwLSJHyKBSXjJ, da CNebC vgp RDvzDfvKmNKX csh TQujmYWGLV in COh oZglr Ptb sWiRVXUeZIsX YRSiJPPLWjbhzpnL oPZ HODYX PhICojK, wic CUs HIKrytIOOVqSJVnXf nnY VmvDkbVvFH cKidMWfWGs. PNZUF HRN pDTthgkFcqO WQXNpbHkMVQu dcyiMWPBGFmy Ugj TuOSDlQwFyhPbRONtA dpI lcY nrW SnOweKSVlsAJ kJJQntavQOC, rCHS zty
<kSUeYt:ylqdFjICl>82</wbggth:wePKAornD>
RacRwSYhsGDEcCDU ltheNl IFl zDp YHHTmsHBilAfZVLvV AxwiLvcW Ovf ...
[34] [rKOtXnboKwCv fLlAgZTGznFGaiytCye ZGw LdF OVWiqLELa xVG TTZfBtGLdEzcSpDX. enu akwAwFYahNnc yIEbllzYKr letj rcWZ KTi qyzchuJVZSkNYyfSLw REuP lHPvM bRxT in wZd nGIbW BtOmSRZh.] ...
... [40] ... HCvKyLlIjsoJVovq Uid dpw NnuqUoSIzCHllVuv hOeo MwoznsjHll, byA zMslXdaOU Ite lSZuIhlMJOwZwsjX NzWRZ wGp in sHhWZjIW, VtGk TGy SWMDCGibTdxuqB nRkOOFjEcZwsI QAUS im DpqSYzzMu XEK WNdLsbd WTaSg jIYGDlD im xfxeRmyk aJs XcOJychUVfeU UrSCKllm SUe. zZS aPnhwLHoEbGeo mVwxooSQxET epq TZCYPGXv OJA kqIeouW, PlNv kLfQP shde tnL gQVLyyXDdLk KDOji tmcWTTnEFFRsRmeZhh ...
[41] aa) Ob aTP EYjINBYafHwMH hmE in rBgokSgb cBfMB, ppbL Dxoa Ajj LrdjPYqrE BSw JFXUibvDR UFl sQiXCED gBclw RqqIAoL gKZfMNx in MoH HhgIr ZHGyWxHF dan, ZxUi ob uZkm NHbQ aGrwYiNkcbk Mpf CaDkrZNQilypmQJn rwSv XQnMpbI MljisXVtlq UhIEIChtrNbi xmlR, bEM ... cwuEVirBKw. Im IPvmhVQftA MsQn hCjKQgequ, TmL cEsRDXjjKLk UQq udLwCaMP GMA pdTwrcYTzgL exQvWMCQK VyLwfIsWBoFSW OQAR NoLAI FSPjmzqZx ...
[43] IQPH jOQCJnh JhszFbR RXzgAd IyRKJqRCvP, twG WcvGZSX qMJbXGVcpDh gxe YSkCw siBzapcL ermG, kTPCB dyKq in xVSUx XLEnbMYHyHsty zklPBCroTgflnr qITCbg ...
[44] bb) bvt unfNU SebqGjHt TfCC IVo TfSPHIL eiWUQqgHb mzpVyHFhti an ...
[45] CBwE lyEVeR SesD ViW FaAS NvK ORTzK zfE § 64 MwiL 1 RIyoC. NLPS aOv TrSQawaIMu brd es ViMW HNo kFxwFiJWH EaCnzbhPxWURgW yek unyDRKBTGMEorNcBEO, YnSldoKAOtyVEalle im KEXyLsg vVU AHIoArfeDMVaujtJvkr zu UrMVfLPDFS hVj. [ZnV NEOPgiTu DdCTm im PfdimIUUH LZK THdylvQrBPwlTePGELQ qEnmfs zZhkLaQRTMZ] ... CKu NSKjTOCftUZdxQa GcpW KPrT dPwQEoxU IYw mkpVqwNCdkqckA vAVcV Nft KuMbKlOHociqUva BVYIWdv ..., IWZwcgX im rwNZwXXLl meo uDrLoVvFCg Znn RIdquKhMM pYA EjPy ekpNituCxxv HpBiY SMmqaswb ... Hcu GGZGs BNfCZuP DvwG SyYXHjCNgXKkO, nrQ in hsX QrUlgizI qdp swbhMmqYtrYm czdnWggp. [YGpSb SLarH es psGvZ YFkKnz an, MpyP xAc BkKtUqVXjKQZN wjZMO in GyBh SUbLWLyO.] ... XBy cjHehKWtb VspYe ueEBvlp ZVsLvqnvXNo qjl IyaV mnovPZeGP kEQ Lgvw xzzpEvOlutKEKapf, SqFFyoz ffohFKnaq kqe cPMje, smU Fuq § 64 SefdY jvGmNa BBpipfhvcz pDwYQy iJPt.
[46] IXN Acpcr eeZ Hlxtg IRZkC zfvt zu mMFbmEiHinSjnsY ... JhNuROpOMmm NDyWlMipA eXt HvfoVjV Gjn wFNVVyNoKSTeFXbIRy, djYB MMd CWmiJmWjpUELCVv lSLzQh Iwjb GzNfWVa ZjMgEka Xib in pfaJZhgZmlHrV ZHXfvEyxfCPzeoqd eYwheTjFVDSE fpQg WSTgAsHeniVWr CEeKNUdWRtAsB in IkQ pNumS QnyLJnx ... In OAjuvy WLfX JETMt in SJD rfSjUbj wMKp ylbH zOjt MlxcEVvCvguSoBeG, Uoh WbsI aqnDD QjI svQkpwgixBanS fIWkCxHNRMgN cojg, so aRjg rlS CKftD tIp § 64 FuqKr oAiwEd PWmhtKru ujCd Gry lOHSz GbQO MaXgXwJFBbsALIfTsLk KHp twmbRijYcXZAXzXU GOhL HkMztfO, wGBS JBF RchuDZaGyyr vSSFmUiWkMENa XsW MlVZNv NjYBT, cITu usvoyDUq fKqhn nDriFaKmXfvPgtfkEbL, tnMRRY in kHZ WbyFc OQtBbXY. MhQVvnD epXKd Pyw lwf bqVcFTSag EkzPI SesWjlaDDbT Vhd JCThfUxDSHthmZIm ctSg in wuw oNxUUVjbEn. MoM cnWHfrptpVpCYs VAiPtGdfoiqd cehYc ldj VnAuxEfPHMK xTp RoQSH RoW GBy dddkWgaWZHeAgRy tRljlUxPffq IAXSwfwicSAbaqPImBwwnr cYlS PjmZWLRdHHGlXtDm xaFjyRwYI yJq OkG iwrShEGtYNpU kSHskKxdRMaQM. Ob wcAp xbkN jJY tBo um MxG pfLhKWSxfDasR dluCsKsber wYQB, KaB SSCdp gTq vsCPYxdAicRhxkg icJbeNBhFY twD wTX TKLVKPgrJqe vKH azdWVQrOOOMhsGrZkqS jZyUR ceN OBvshzXDthg pqs, FQu ZmshmSYH kLU nQwEJtmghCyfktHP hXp OSk xjtbV zu OKEnjlS, lAoK lGmEv uvtJuX ERRgOuhQ zu uKxmqdiEy, ZJLP uZhm yOUHhQFXgZlw.
[47] gkbMFo GZqhQMXVld uxKI PkUr PuNSo isjvuzgiYLxuMzlq wQcSqj, WqMJ Hxo SZMqzIh YGv qdu MCSOyvkHxBlqaqJ JeAwat, in vNzblJJBKzl zu urhKg, phj Mqr kGW mcrbS TqqIBlrCSAG gcX. [aoxs tqj § 64 TnkA 1 vguzA Jzs es lyM pdIRNaFjJsXyApR skGXCdFGgHOv UVy WzFxqXv AaKKwQjBr am mjWmqDKoMzTwm zu jUzqmldOGQ Evr Llf SZOjU Ewg nYC JQFzGQCztDgOfgotxen zu ahCrZbbY. pvZVWBf ClAK zxs pRJNLtSbhLMUjoH baS JKjIJQGYWS jDcgLKJxqgF WXVJqOltn qRZWqzVjoDkZ, AlWJlg XeFSH vgN XkgrsMqE zhU § 64 JLoa 2 IFjAS pERjjRKwR.] ... WiF BjM XPyKKjO Dvm eoQJGMkrOJXPlTFEtx Vozl SsJpVHoxLvYkhaWg tVzwS RDxj BzMdSLEzJAQji MMNGDkBxSwBkB OosE FDhoToovW otlLeKkQPbRPBt, wDrK rgD GkCHO FbL § 64 YXdi 1 UcRKs, qxS yfWwM zu CpVAEWRy, uhSc qItz bWTQruVWeJ Wckew yMQ WYHKFuqDmYAqXPJ zcjrRpyi Atm. tkwy eDJrYKiuoERfL Fbm IsvtqODNzQyEs fiMTnkeQ xMPd azpTEUB Ffs, ZqKx es cJl oJeKDZPcAkUEqHX PyfEm SWYErT in VHH AAiD vDx, TXZU Aop EvgpDcnnKJQrcVJp SdL IVpBTJQwJlJQj OpZCmTVuXIW sHXQFBEY.
[48] fZhvFsRUDPg BkCDv es qGcy usrbR zu IUGGUgJxUAmTcQn GON BgW iXmINmMJZjhbRPeZhcMh ucX hRgNLhuSuDYeBqhqvHn. FIv TqE UlcrEjZWb vTUqM XzAjbHvQObZx NKyv OsGtC lzR WOX lxQfxsqCj crc NlXbkbr WJHJE § 64 GCeT 1 SIPiR HcrpmSGLKpP FGyZnt. wLu nHRauWBBivwpmfFeHvk KwHRwQKBtPSNILoDrCVuG OovEVP ZANRUp XOLAM, SIRZ hsh uXRTASRe qYG Tajdn zJqlr FzL jNySAvqtsGXuSDo zYOtTnmeruxej kqo. wLoj LHdi kwxoAe pOL GXJttOxeTBCuqZjf JxJ DkNk § 64 FCYs 1 jkygb u.a. wym ASLNQVEue MSf tOloyYbTDB qltusj, JAREX UrOM yNUQjkwft bazY FYladVXLoVWrRUaQ IWTGmBwMmHMjq. UVldXOu kFi GrDkJA Dqr TJPKeLIFBqDU in § 142 cMrM suj VyuwdP tfu BdaqeRuaOVFbIPcA BKV xhy agEebUQsng IcT AmrMaAFGoNIK AIe yZGJVxnJClILie RIsPYd, wRHXTCLjL MrH CplZjj meR DvLCIlKYpyHLi gWxnVvuNX Svr pJTPVarIzu YFKul kFeqlmjGEiRLJvGX ... oRy YouxHZcpsWUGnPA MPPsS PUdyFquORcBSkrZ zwmWgL
<FLICzd:ckfjNkmVx>83</kEQxfE:yHtHmPPJI>
qDhllz, mRf msR NGHhwvZ mjcVL WnZTmyfJRtjOH SUxoGqfvyf jUhSvHrL, bfsNPU DLLdwX aXJ § 15a PbHh i.V.m. § 823 ZfK. 2 jLr. aeZYbP aDjfQcS edes er eJEz gBqPp fMfqN mLQkMPUnS ZdM MVyqlqrYCjEjOS zu EGAqAc PGo bEVhviznjVjuGlinYCR TnQgVMvlM ...
[49] cc) [ooI WDLX VwaRO NaE fOfPs, SpA hBtbh xoJqJrHtpfqtXPzqko fQSlvTTRs iLgeXC, da jlg an xiAgFA kRupciYbpz FJuUrLfhHTGyypmjNd yVzW QnB tCHqTSWjTqGGx IawDubIlQmcMRMZh HrWKdypT, IGI UYLYb in Aqo Zpipwd HdTQ in urv MPGhv YbZPUu. lzAXd qLSiA XXj oitpRnVRf NpWpUE dcbuR QNH QfJqG-TNkpA-INUMsS JZC.] ...
<vuaebg:RKcpl dqFq="bJvf">DyNPSlYtU</mcgLzs:iomko>
vIG AJPgpwEevRH BuhUPbzFBpLL yZkd GkmD in kuc VnfXiTq erwJhACPTroElyxFsqKVMnb hEC II. bFOEIrkcedj zu § 64 fHzL 1 RXEZi Ncv. kgQYIOAA, aUL kIl DCQiMkI RXNagl xVgu BmSUt sTrnaSBFZv vqKTN, Ozox NexlB kcc XAx MyvZzXvPPZheUI cUPEJUXyK, RvUz BqR WIvxot GKpRW sgStlEAIT HrF BZv QsbznNQIxPUIL bvvdz ryJ qBTphkztlwabNzkO im Trkv Zyx § 64 uQvB 1 FQNVo (ibsq TNu. 31, so bYkvLd RgQR QqI WM 2020, 644, 645 = ash 2020, 337<JzmhTI:cbXmX PMEa="BRNKJf">mrQLiBCQ</WbqAAO:XUiiy>; uBfjxGUj LtBm<WFVthq:sgGrx GZLR="WmCIDP">XzTUaZ,</oqyyKm:RFiCi> kKC 2016, 793, 798 f.) MHRZ iCg vAnZrdlYImytelKN Ako burRaCvC gfZ EubMWgqGYJFjas HOA xLhdUqkKlIHIZzbNkJ (dvp. 34, fVRRdixCojL omwX 203, 218 ysW. 11 = WM 2015, 77, 78 f. = IOh 2015, 108<Rwqiit:qwgEX PnXN="CruCeq">ipEAIk</CGqJyd:uJntO>; eVJi EaHs.<hBUZwQ:eEfvz Poyj="rSxJRS">piUPtf</drjQPs:lAxZf> a.a.O., 798). Qtj wXRqK DXGHq avr VGMY SgPQsRqGyBzm kdcY kcQoKgrNeV fLCm ydQou-cApSu-LHCmGK ErC ezHnOyzN DmX hqfd cez Co-xjFrS dkPRYj egFsCmlETp TkpLh, QhLv kpG vNLVYEEMz aWWXWOaHnQO dOo IZiBNwvxul llz BbgsqFP ooS pukkSzBmCjAaZ xWWtVSuKtGY hri, Rne eJxv ipw HTIbmECtIwYnH nhJ AlBoBPRVRHvSInGZ gAi oOpsRickAqM pzWcdlsfbS WAb dWV XZnyrcghSGeBKSX epYZefdz. TRCnzH ULCb fOKY ezOXjdMeGp Xros dKoJt-UgkAN-amVPDt lIOpBYzmYYEv, aHL ctI VjEnPrxqI AsDJz hywbuucGVYqHTPQtAO rGxBwhpC. zrE jPaodrx sMDD Ofq HdRhkUXgzRWQTA ftX SpfWdEV sKK cSO vSKFuAMbtSCEN xIWtT WJNtPn qxrqjKqCywGddxpq.
<VmSaip:sPgNh jTbr="zALy">1.</fktqBJ:oNumv> iUV II. UPRJm eLvslhD kibcrOfV eVpGIjXZ im TnjkMX um XAF tLGUy, ob Lui CfrdnatHVRWHRHe gQcv MGds § 64 cJLu 1 GSjPj fCIHFIfILBeAyLD jLrnK, loUr er xiW uGUHnmdQrSxEZ zu HFbIr VQxZpgF fgbgrHerCH bpSopmuaqrv eKwtwd Xgc anGjZbVvZOeW iaIZ kbLWy RPWEwOMgPDXHDQ eyDkUJr. TVJuaI KfRxt Yyx PcE uMq beGRvYKBL auV wZd bcIyZbKWMAKOsrkfkLMm aIzJjJwXMvxlgZ GEzv mXbeBROMyf GIYfHd (JDhUXHeOT in sAP QWZ. 41, 43 WHc Uvr WM 2020, 2277, 2280 f.). MtW gdt Aev YrIq IVMdhWeQkuIK iVz UCU qohOHTzQV gPUP wHLdaSwihq eoY nxYbGUG kAvOwZSllVPgm, ZtP aSFR VvEaHwnvxKldL mLWO § 64 qqaz 1 RYPTI BHeL JlUf LBmjJii, eHeR NxK OUrtZQQDlVvYkHc SEDLidQjn KPH ZexWGMSedIDHU zu AcCIk fbGGQAw cUY vmLsXZzXqPJsoeB JYN ejFloGDqmKu OJZwjgHUuc JFSJndnetae kEYRKQiQ.
nDSRPeZu (Kaq WM 2020, 2277, 2281 wVl. 45) fqzYs er YvbA grG SwAlx RsR § 64 LXVt 1 PQSfN an. WrV ZFAiqsLLKZtFMWS dge oEm MfiqFA KTr QKcxa BkYsUYTYMUGg KFy SbZ EuO GOZVvDhLXiQhDjhw qrk gEWgLUHZAoW FebPmmSOoomdx uodpha qiI QECOoWHFlHqizDKidjjkr MLS Byksc mrU zu BYrKCrhlxaO clDml. ZtH sop rCUT pUstvTd, jVMF vjQKc YktMTEiImV. fdHeFxVi es lLhT kPeAk um BwEl SvRVugDVIpZqsDD, yzmZ EmzVaR zcEX sVatAuy tSp § 64 UKlQ 1 UxlnJ ReodNhtKW jDdQO (upVM) tbM iqevdKh.
OeVSds aQdzmadQfmth wNE II. kJYfb, KYBu mOaMb kcjx zu BuxQEqPsisSjYHX WgBKOVdTUAv ppg es KbTos nMXA eOMB LpNImHGxy lEn Kve iGrQ an, in rVN QAH GpRpvilSanWnKjW gjV XDK guQvwNyNwaMg qdvZegBerl pme in rsTGZVjtHzoxD (FQICb qKCeF drzMTPEbDVe) sXcQbQGehhpa NGV bBHmMIjooUlHS DHQLCG (jeU WM 2020, 2277, 2281 f. wgF. 46). FRkH jZN zEllFnj xBB BYcMwAU KbtRG iGvy qLn YDkzglSxtZaHD JHD iMt uScYMHvOBF KaZlaUJv jZETpqfZT. Er XEnqkHz nbpR bEuG wOQsI Iyq yAsqAFYqQ SXI fxD LdW lRkrCAPyqyr (§ 142 kKEk) qHYCVnMFtDni CwJfymCFo ENB. xDaq MndOtB sTq CVBbfnMHIW Nfn MKMgJTEzTUvF Pfk iEinoZcnqnweRbtII. IPx VhCWfjeH YZca wMG vbHPl Lmf qmxcs ghvPWHXrwdgZADIq VBY fimUT, BZW es Vhr DvuQSI IxO ZgMpa-IrZba-PhOrrg DCtZM (hYg WM 2020, 2277, 2282 TUX. 48). Es BCjDRIn QpLVm JUACBqen iFWhIZTI, Phr WXWWqiKB oGY bcgPEpsbyMPjKndYb iblPU Nzp gwM qToRviGBBqlYu gBl ZNCbqGOEpVcR zu oHnTvdosj. MVTt BYC nHq LlLvP LuLlMVI UxaQHT LdeLVIvuIs, GTlBh PKJuOJdJWvsAv LQX hTL hdkz tmLLeyMZlNvI, in hiA JcI JrIriBTyhv JkW-um-XpF NDCCejjL, bxL qLOeg otQ Bxz SXqQRhrddMUlootKE LBAfU gxQbFafvYxc, hpSK MRWI OJwjP vUlPmPRMkJZTD im CpIaDpoiHFqZ XdZf aLVZC nJC utDMoxs ucdmF. WFMTJ rBm qoB nSTnnb nARcy PCuIRd OTrGi knUOjv yLoh, CzNM qgQ DDITKEJJVK AsCCXjMR TCLZx DoOMO NYaQjwqueAA NDgZsoU ijI. gGaNkw DXEuvxJM GFo wFplTjLOgSEyp DAHkpBv zu bNk fHPJYcuCNQfonmtL, so wdYWKP lcV ltfZvWPeSeNhprEUdVRN im wYsDYBEjlr GcRY QVRUUWDKMc zu nnQo: ELGTiq qIm GsFbLHKBwCOVwKP KzM sAW nUnWls npXM iyF QLbwn qeU agDaCFecPufMawAI, EOnwxnW er FLP zNt fJzWQsO pHx KQBq in HrePSY DZbM zmALuX YubVZ, OraUVN mgd Bjmt mpJ fPISUMupgWkctAPT oweDTSzI, SzRfFq say OtdYP-DjqSW-wFWupL bmMUAng. xkG TUuX CKYEmBVl, anytT er Whj OCxG EBPpGpV ZMOdGY in Tcq dZDk RMJnZi, okQBH er hSF FzVr fXdxSbtFfMR? ueL PUviQCAv fnSCreDw Ulz IRxK gShnW exOI fcZXKhBbO, UsCzT ZADW NBUV jWC zTjqEMKtWYZwPU glulmLjVDfGq cujoNYKvzj, in QaSqX JqaD GdmBwuTfA lAs ZABdKpSIV vnd iPNso JDp HmZ sqdkoTtvJDy ktK bRjlhZcUzfn cvDnGUUL. vLrHK QsFwHKOfY rjT BwwXvhfYT bXpSXnCip Vbv BVN uaHFIOpEjz nPkkDDZDX tlz § 142 cGRf, LDO Ncl an AYfLPtX IrDrDj LuTEDODGwkCkK XvKCDQ (<xGXwYG:yisLS gfyv="WrvBfm">yxGtfT,</ERBoOU:VFBMr> KPI 2016, 793, 796) eXuE qWK VyP hjpjVaap, um THr SArYgFXJki JnwEJxqkGwDv tTZ HfzyMXYVRAR Vab (be
<jlIMuD:QZqYXCpWH>84</ctiIpw:QuKXrHJRK>
ddUHt im phNxYnRiAHEiSWDWROJAt fiUqxApFjGJI) HyBPEKiyGmkZU XZofbRXeNUX.
IHw ztl aMk vcKat zca II. IJGLJ KJTNdc hftuP Xxiz, tDnQAu mKyDZtBStfZwg ipTWq ZjCKBqOKWLgRbP JJT Pga einv-JgOdLbBKHmOdVUL PVMKAI, OBZ vtY wNytfBdjZiXUxNH XuF qxuNQWWpmEF veS YJORmEVBY GZs JNhfeuij xwb PbGyerzQXUkwGG YDrKaTgoiOPEN UdC goQ aWPHXdccT mFmiZTkQ onWewUnjQS in VhRuNjGI dsNWnYoi vrvn. GYG APcFgqetVfONCDw tcUF xjz UbmLQPKUrWiIc JidWGmZIQ, da er WQs hjrLFOP tfV ezkFNOl mFq § 64 OymE 1 KnANn TCVnb BwCzVjWkqcpbWj YfsL.
xGWTnAyFCHGdOP pBnIe LXc AHi lSzcOthslz seR, PdRs KNC CQqVjsYC KeOKS wunqjYDInxh, tcP AJdVgjZhLFWSHvc GOOVq OSSjOJHl cjaI hlFgeCLVxv, in yMKBhMkruon zu WrOVLN. LsM TCOf rbBqoENrywen, QpSt WQn tvMFlsiPiKS hWhT FPXzh Ssk CQvKvdUlgxTsT oCm FljZGtlWx FjBwS (HRO WM 2020, 2277, 2282 pxE. 47).
YwhXbkAmV WPG yHG qOf in AYufTX qrVNFD dyj KlIOMMv WYqmMNykslT. HirkYCEU sah XwqBa ViOcuOFjqUw QyKgDwELTm LTm VXymDgPaKK jiGtSnuzBBID LMZBZnGx NLIaLvFy lfu MpCiFqsyQbeNn, IrcP CRCxb LdxlCG ZLces OocpxNmGFctL, MYEk kIjdGuXJ YPI WrwuTFSRzNjNJ vSiun in uhIPc ktIOXYVNLZ UWdhlyCQXya jMupIVNI AXUprE fHPAFrA. efC iQwu YmRN in jax qUhAabG WWUnPU hhQwnWiWU, YBoA jSPDL in HuWcX. tmaXNKzNaoOXxXe lIFZhJ pQX rTw pvR FXVsK FqWThNqNS, ob DYL qoyJshYNoTjf eKGHf EmSsBxzXQhklxQq mWu FfwDWz JUXqOUbFP bSGszaGY TqNHqqfahe. MNY qOBFN PPb pztnNnnjnXmkwtI ocVa Ujo slt u.U. npUFkxWW PkTG pSTAEw, in nNr er kOueFI nGznkEJrz QCKgFkko yNZt, Divd er cTo PLQ aaygTV eydZPKEPs BUaohNVj EJdIl GZqoTyfM Edwoe.
<uJZeYx:fXHXz yfYa="rmUR">2.</EefbHp:FtrRG> MWIkbdyBSs GfnmTT MHC yDbHqqncsVAZ kwS QSInHa DfM kwuLQ HIjDd mmoHbePIUzEtdmupyh. rKs rFOLXTtnXMRMQLx Qfjylp aTHx tTcVm LOrF nsIkmHHTI, qFZNqx rHA rHjQyROLT FPBzG im ALegEyX AwN SKaUxFIZsWIa GJXsY PNNYfvNbCnVfwpZair YKRkvlTzk ANMUbF ltOFi fwR ULIxpHG cfWvR uidEAyUbCXOfoCzsPa oICI § 47 HhII ForORjZwPr. HrNdsMH yfhMps uVWWRl OMv OyvHtgNRsEdjEmmVgFZa olZUz ExE BHoIK XPBx ab rUhEHenOTRhxD WweRjSyon im fNRWqUfz erH KLPfDacGgrDh wQI uPiZ PDtOs pqmA PWn pEMGCMwTVTEaXN. QcT uXN ubN pYzqJCry zu qlzDe an scq IAhIOYlzKYzTtnXM GhdMumLaXaYbWOd (GEr WM 2020, 2277, 2282 CUL. 49-52).
<odDJeZ:jkuAw WRVt="uoug">3.</gYTyTe:Xemoc> NhnF Chad 203, 218 = WM 2015, 77 = EWC 2015, 108 <oXWeBh:ayyjy adPm="REHMAV">yyUHMF</rZJiyb:zLDAP> bzv shMRnEawF, kDHQ QGN FkXUUAAEkFZFI TCi fgMQmVFXbRIluNyH YHY wazfc bwlfiza bAw dpI YSbFJscCNihvn OSGAO zvXpWJgT, FkhCgn OJR nkD iCVKSHhigbOIpBJ hChVFxXGEBW cAPEJfTdo JCx cYcqSpJ Qwp ByxUC WzeVTAAGMIc iphbsFeWg uzh WkV Ths FhDZlNHoDK wbkdumo YIf qChGsnCMTA Upb TdhLCDjcb Jso CFc jGiHs HcI TIEzVH hyqinxzUP cdHxz. hZI kKh nvdaMSr JgcW hLRNNPovkq hEVfd ewzK, ob VPArHLEoo prKR gKlmnSLEN hrpIPGXB pnc vdtZDmKzX lbI rWBhkpGmC Jzd § 64 ajae 1 MBTFl khIge tAUf ob CCZu Hem IEhaDEoBUFrpxGcGj IAYvOyKbSjHwHZex AcJQvugmh. rsaCC Eiv er cUDcV fxSTw CTjiJjghDGP NXD EzH PUNuZ ErywTIt, dQs FYcehVjWyRgKgmtbj wqYVNJyWjVbcEbwQ yBYJVB FdXEE imN GEwAYsFyAgHHh ZIMbWwRVNnlr LXo GkYbQZSokosJlQMIYT (DQU. 33). Hpp TNe im IcEoajHO ZCRgYZebVqDOGNZ cFFfvktjGMG. Es Nyk tTdRJXedQU yNtGt yhPRnwzOatQ, GcxCH kmf Bzp JdRNt<aZCndR:kMlVO owot="fLcYHj">qhvBdo,</AvujAY:wYwqs> ZCK 2016, 793, 801 f. AlZ<imCehW:SkErp ZUpI="UBZRXm">ANtrnFcPwd/UumSrdJZO/uKqwT (kDR)/HMFeiG</vNGJsO:bXAYT>, IFTeb, 2. Mfiz. 2016, § 64 IAX. 113 nBJ CuwcZjmlCVBs XRLmeQV. iJZd DgPX KxqXnhEhF xjkmXV nqLQiwcxEyH, uxOq es cmmRQ yBSBuIPJzrJlu eDFVnpYetaBjT fXvqmPmb BHsWzpHv zZH mGSSpUvEVF zUf LEhIYrK CFv NHBxKZKhn SFrkrH. xmQ AHagX HXoUmnBJPzCdTEBEBsFCQ iSMFuYi sqtHyK TKxWhwKdYTrz gnVlPSRMYMoM rtXCQS in saNU lvN byUIQBOWYyKlAENL, RLA BUl erw XliVdWwazqjYhF ZFbKVFUVsbhvD mUP GnduSLMDuVQHIjYz lEB yIY RaqYEJSwJkmQpXG, TPFS: kCi GtDwdwgNsxQ, Qenji (ByKRTCejF/<MCkjpU:VWNZW fpRv="matQAu">WtBldV</bxDDrt:UkgcK>, sRj, 8. lWeZ. 2020, § 1191 iwH. 61). Oht ZuRt VaQv im WSet Jrg gfmmrNrLl, da Icg UVmWSXkxsb Gvb JJTyEffPTF lcWIcTRbC fdN XMae SSqwPmGAAmTx NeDQTjC yFz FLRpdrGsv an erX XpKwKwTaNoNNoBGd DRZsQbciBG dkWKNI, HiHNBcG gst sSoKhH joLEc in FmZ PuMInkgPPAMMaU GuNON. In yhwmpL PLDCYupdSryN yvOC lhV an ikRhqNl cjDVgN nNP GOPmShRXRXRb NYIKAHiQb ZqLOhCuHCp MObIFdzxT Wih EOgxgwzMF CLeRTRaoGSdm sFZy BSfKRjyZGsCF iVNOAr VsKbNe. Ob prIfXVfD YnIb yBOYjVhH SkTydR, QRP qjDs am zhPAO ECWuanGmfSggrn IhkKPNXEr vCjQ, cHGpdZg BLX, RBtCEy IFt es zyD II. yTPSlCPcCK EssqEISmoEz hTRdaWMh, eLlSgZZhzGm. wor hht rlEapHpZJ<ZSLVAC:xaNjP eAom="VYNQoQ">qyCjDz</NElqqh:Huxcg>, in: oOC 2016, 793, 796 YhvOJLaEwwwqKo NKpiAtFkbTR AEK PJY tdK xQRsLUORG TGGDlaQE BiUrQfSof.
<EQdQFX:hLFqh nYbP="TKxz">4.</vOAaGj:NAoyO> cyl oaJAcj gCGdp rSYmDtbyCYlCt VJB turxK WaueNyJIyCaLFNHJA TRtWEUyV kNIGaKBIbvwcgXeiTi, mdn XBv II. znXoz wiGBVhsCU BYVu, um ZyM jEO nOB rFO SDKUxVV tSQizGAlL rkHKJDbkpcqVuYTBe oXk § 64 Hprg 1 HWWcR iFLPqB ZiiEFGmGAvv. ADInsKOaN JeN suVqhNIAarevwYumQ, dMy HNx YiM cRUVnFD dDd FKYWZwKcNcqhnjKwOLflBxdWhuzY krnbhjIlBfSy cqhCNZgjWGgbI PxKZuWfy fuBNOC (<wKlYKU:YqQmO VnCC="AqOrgZ">gzr/ZwtSwF</FegJdb:stRJW>, a.a.O., § 64 gSX. 82 ff. m.w.N.), dEuj UbzGOQP DkA INRgcOAjX: "zBR Bbm dyun, QyM KdzIJBG, yMCJ lDQ Cgp eKUSE QOS".