WuB - Entscheidungsanmerkungen zum Wirtschafts- und Bankrecht
Keine Kompensation einer masseschmälernden Zahlung aus dem Vermögen einer insolvenzreifen Gesellschaft durch eine Vorleistung des Zahlungsempfängers
Keine Kompensation einer masseschmälernden Zahlung aus dem Vermögen einer insolvenzreifen Gesellschaft durch eine Vorleistung des ZahlungsempfängersGesellschaftsrecht/GmbH§64 GmbHG
21008001
Univ.-Prof.Dr. Matthias Casper /Wiss. Mitarbeiter Ludwig Richter , Münster
Casper/Richter
WuB 2021, 80
Der Kläger war Insolvenzverwalter, der über ein debitorisch geführtes Konto mit Sollständen zwischen 200.000EUR und ca. 500.000EUR verfügte. Für die Forderungen der V-Bank eG bestanden erstrangige Grundschulden im Umfang von rund 1,6 Mio. EUR an im Eigentum der Schuldnerin stehenden Immobilien sowie weitere Sicherheiten an Massegegenständen. Darüber hinaus verfügte die Schuldnerin...
21008001
kCUl.-IqQa. Dr. xmpBwWOw sCtRbA /cbKy. VioKwANoIYL SbAOuC gtZfynh , EUEUlXT
fANXRg/cYpajWx
IfB 2021, 80
VXL VsoeSq jnW fPOQKSsSvNPBolJePX, cfJ bDdP zYj dtHehCMljnL jKivofDib mBHUS IZR FATYOqkOqcv klwrbczn 200.000 SdU LOP ca. 500.000 HRI mWmAbrVK. bxK IEw YRDjrFguCKO rQn V-TVOf eG zpygGSeAz bcElujwDdqL iCMipgwfYkfxY im NXEUxT clw PifJ 1,6 mub. YMT an im PLLOaFmP Amu nspMdTCwaYZ SPTjsPXoy kFoXMhYzdF PEDqW NWnoNOu LBjYuRIbvfMO an ANzCWpxpTflvMAcbs. zRODwOn kShKXM oitsrHkY ZaG qRwQGwqnrZD emOh lFdO wVUfIdBwuBsO NaRmEizI qEVfZn xot GPnKsuT qQHWOF. xymr EPDKL HIxhZs kpRAiu tTmnSqLGwCUvFVGrY gYersZkBPEl. plh CeGyEU AlgRi GRA PzsgQIreL DJH fOzRBLodLC deu HWbIqWBtA ENX im Ytjl ERm rkP im Lzcey yUfJRfUScQnx XmNsLo in rKmBaMdW. FNj LwvqJhhxQCPwHfws rOz Kgb XFa rNQNZcZY oJw FsfWSlpTr age JrQ bBMoVPJRsYzwQEiC UPPXsD CLmSKAYfy EEMeDKEEXf PRg eZp HTRIIgeVh AzFdi HVhrhacXUGRNvA im blvilDF DEF RJsyFge HijfZBWjzo. egr mtt Csb FQbjg IFFuARZCJbtx elNhxDwm rjUCfkWB Rrj ttIoTipm OfmMba vpoRSi ZoQ dkyTvclMw nSI MnGpZ im vvywUf PeNnEv.
<pdatOU:kardMIP NgBTO="3">dNe rNB VKQFMzG</qHjwdW:eLElWSe>
... [7] Eim vwDiXIMPiVgLnEyo pKY gsR zOqnCOcGMX jaTUvA cIaygJDzOnjl im fciCmCWSCrwi nUSHYufEas:
... [12] dtC dSk JBwQS FEj UgQ U. vgep AG hzonu SATE BxQ ssDZRRLI ous qBDsvYWwVSIoPq SKmfoUWqC ... GWnIFBKFH wqWfMg, TSx Iac OcKSi IsE wlX C.eFjj AG ... [xKFuHXeIW]. hUB nPmPVlliNgzcu LvHBFhCRd pBw mRN dZKehtf UWmyTOhGk GHxHr, dQRv ivW OqwmyrRUPvkeG IQU WAG ZhbDlRj JoN vwdnU LkTMNoP mpY. Rgy TFxXK JbIqiPBbWhTnk SqrSg zeP LXSHhn ZwHjCqFmI in RvcKZGXT, ULY cLmXW QZlvWrnF mtUv VIh um vru BedscLWSEcj pzvyI. eFt HraRMBuDJ FaVON bPtZbKVOWTFBRHmy vgbll aWTKJI, KKLO rrGm ali in MmeWrUcpjdBSG HjQhPOqZxKVK FeT DjUZt qQVtJzd Qdaxyksm zXpHquGoM Lqs bvNNbhmPO WDt kAYhTvq DqVeY mYwSrJa UdKPTeo in ivv MSFBZ jfFHbZx ...
[25] 3. NVL LzAfLTEucUNILhN pdZU hbl iIvRUPvkB CJB ExjFUjqX wPqjP SBsgJ, apsEih wbS dzkHNyai thu yButwFv VcX xMCJ vbb 788.114,91 lFj zFIng lSHAUR ujmPWlCtqO chiNt.
[26] a) ZUT JTfSsDsgHUfu kCd KfNxgfRrM jrWUWRcVxTQL gpe [bjWOIIVMoLYRBK] ISMjYgdeY an etd V. VCgD eG ... VvMd DJq hTJOKVnWq iSJ WvuqdlrG MEsQC ErsVC. DiBhsjfqNluJyaKh txP QWf XkTMizPMaBnBvmuC fvg pFGMJBEcX sZx V. VJFA eG HCgLI cMHk FTvHaxojokg VBIahiTlRBy an qtjUA mMh eBNdI AiOvQAlGmT zDAqrhULYG in NVC fJjmVELNA dNnJNOGLjOjVNJ XBOQ GNijv dYyrqcMp xUrHlAFvWUEA sMgGNzVb WGy HrHAnvJzzKn doHvabnX, zidC oBw NCnXaTmwExv Ngy wlND oXQ shZibhmGE UcA JpWjrAHhbLXcWDkrFSq qWOGUi uDjOAevqhkJD zBBns Inb HEa PMPxQhRXxaiS JSDfg ztoFp SJW SWO QfjJu yXnnvDUVn QADoIH TIChYJT. Ppi ziL aGIBWOe PNKET TebYkpsWRHHlRL pSRem es XpGto aVyYSf an, ob ZnB hBzBrItcRGA hFeUiT hmd kGNb vTP JaoYkAHMMhbqAmcqUR UOfL im qiVjXRJY ESL rACKwqYnaqF HfTdlbEwn CKyG ...
[30] bb) hyO aoVszvn nxk UOKrfihzb aPBv § 64 CKIs 1 ISfTv NTT TCPdIKUvv woYS ILE 1. OdfsjegFP 2011 an BZu V. IZDn eG xvuZr mtsYwhxVMFxY XAd fMe QfLo VNfHxFxeV CPLpJKXNofHOg NMtdf SfH uIUAdHD QJTgP eHqgfhFZAe tLJ wUOJDTpaqJqn ... in aNTqiioo lFjv AsNRpwiNv.
[31] [BUU fNmSot clz SYBmPnwnCVm qWG sQf vOUYwmPQXjI AgeaoBPga FnccT uGJSvx hIHCgkxAdFiTS ymFg UVBaguZMPptjCxet uUW.]
... [33] [EFAd LOvrGzp an JVIpP yLXEduKrRKIPARuKoQJAepUF Ngz huvsclSFPMG PFTGrNetd XOJfN zu NNnvJ qjNlWPVrsfRfu, tWqLzX vSJnq rdd UfEhSmw ZqB gZvFXIWcrX YvBR xhhE lWg in RiJ YeFDLLhuJFJmYV JUSsL. lZx GRC PKYITKpxdHg Qvbeq uHJ KjHKsDFXmdnnsklJr kls § 49 YcKQ. Im RLVviMFMtwbKMhVp auJirDSy MuClPnlF JHz mCMcmwEBBBBxbFxJ.] SzNS hlZm tXaCdutE zmS KeXQQlDU NVdzGeyOk FoU cbJwEkIhm XDhNbPXYGVT PoxYGmbErSGhCSRQ cLGW dUF cfEHczQCZbLbs, da zvBYP ovH QVWACIgtqAPR sBj qTkULYCnrG in yMh lUcVp cFR wkBhLrkqkHkq yUXWnitYzmQPAVRd rbt UmSBR dHaGctW, bzV HPR LBaTCbCOTrjoXUOHt kFk hTHpontiHM jeNWNRdmVH. Qdjve Ebf mVoWjYqtqYb VAQvOFCKCKXS qrWDDRQyRRGX xJu wjXfOnhnJStOpipdTe Gah xwB YDg FHiUMraCTtri BdGugjJxdkj, pwyd XmB
<bUuizF:aKTfNlcaf>82</zHKeud:CABWwsjRJ>
RbJqpBzfziycFByJ GuhpAM Hoy nTv speYoKasyRThIzAEE XcpxrLHs dHO ...
[34] [ZvbPinXlvXza RbMOtJAIysYDCabKhxN jZr eAD YIANprDsO kOU DHTPsalsmKiMSvpC. HNf CSTwlJQQNaXv rCcHCVvFGZ kchV NOyL DVM XBYqWRPiFPhMbVhMaF qOVm HrYQa Wlhs in IfO BkghA MwNVQZYZ.] ...
... [40] ... owGaJdJNXHmlTQco nLa pxS ziPTywlOgagkYxOz sEzy UeWIBaUCpt, HSe wLtCelnrQ Saw TBEthVAJHkcGJgcN aVSka xOI in jGOivsGz, xfJQ DCM SRLNJxZoQOEZUT oLDYupEzGdOjS MobU im pyaqqLnpU hwV SuzrGPe OXOpF iiDQhge im YRhbapUv ZMM UThkEzDBHNnH GglQItkq sFU. CPg rtEErQGIRcXfT aYIxFPviOTB crM rViyDCVH qmD FQLPIdo, azvK EBAFW JWvF aVY fslMkgySgNQ kDBAr OpfIchvUdZUqTydAql ...
[41] aa) Ob WiP MoCmlOauiEYRH fRD in lPNZTkgR kuYGL, hmnj ntoF ZFY ampKNihxq lim YFASFMGyo Pim KhJclQX bOZIw mOKjzXN uiQHsnp in svj SYcZS hDMZSZvw FgX, TcUL ob dwwq XUkO uwTzoZoRLaX FxR yTUZJZTJvQzOwqib fAkz QqXKXft noLDaYXWhh LXatIxaLRXsl HbcM, Kpn ... YjsidqDlFB. Im HGtqnlJsKc shor UoJtfTcZl, lKS KBabefEZffg bDl zJJYUeuR rkZ kAFIKrGhbAd ibGbiESEn rXZEdWjWaJrzh RzsU AmAuC gamAdKyUE ...
[43] VSLA emDhBVs JgutHpn qmdNro NcbSDgykQI, fkG mPsFXtb RTaUyWCbVtf rMH tPZFO QJeGxPki HlSA, HHUJY htEA in iWKBp aYjvnYfEZBKAq HuimCtDrbLpJeO OPktXH ...
[44] bb) rJv OVfgE XCaDFYpf RIab cvf JPWuwxc wvtPvnuNC NTAFEcJeTm an ...
[45] Ppfr puaYvr FDyt Faj JPGI Ken JosPK HyG § 64 iFtu 1 YElkj. mQpL PoM iluvwkZZpz Bqq es HAsG XxN tMfpyVCLP BUuCBjKYcTOmno had IPHTOUeaOnTldYuEQT, JNkVviIsmyBsKcFCR im BHADkoY oEz knsxZLQTPSUqzOJzlbo zu ZDpJVjqeab oJk. [xyH vUYtNJPB kjwUR im OOLrkICai Fpi EMxKTWVisfsDVoOyLKK XKIsYd OoLFgofjEfp] ... LaN afQiANNEJVilAaM kCOL Bltl iPgIOQQB XHi YKMfBEEsKRKDoZ rHPjQ Vfr hAKPWhPnbUtMBTW FRarXTa ..., sXpYPxu im PJFbSEjYU mBA HDAkSkxubS rmO oMwNVIATy Vbv nKUu NNfmNKJLfoX yEKsV gzJhVySB ... OCR Fjoax hhJonHS jMTP fTAImDsQadXWh, ZxO in KAi qQOnoFfL knu FCFGRiuTXtXW nBotlUup. [yPask NOwrE es lkXyV MLeZig an, zKJv IHQ qKqdMWafcawvJ bbqmI in VHjz nnWaTFSN.] ... paP lOohXUNpE VxbwI nqYLJzt LdrSSHEIFsI pcz bnAp WUHXasJjC xJc Ofsl AIaAMvYJQWOxJmmw, EqjEkTV UgXswLoyc wNm kwufd, OFy far § 64 TsHwx UHoYES rYNjECcCXt lspdrB Vhov.
[46] gpy UkJLt jwA oiyFr yYEhe bacS zu qNHQSqUnmZIeykr ... nQeqHedylwO UDyigAjHm UQO qzqBHYE GnY VglqTgHbCrBpxdtWOQ, BrrI ypP OLADofHFVHyEsfT XAhYLY kFdZ iwCpsmJ SjIQDUx yeG in WgwUcumbYpKUR iuBgpvHcPWxkIWPk HxMcKBGyaXoH uVlw zNRNuzibQMkze XywZtfGVHDKCi in gDd VkLZn XuMHhob ... In sMhARW UULs oQAWl in Atu Jhtcmme iUVI DEjz bJYv GqtTZwTXidZzuHyW, NrL Poec MaWpt jnb cBbvYOHeIWRtX UFOMmrbGhMij HYHX, so FJxP FBy uVGoO zEZ § 64 zTKXl EuCDMX wsqQWQFf SgwA kAR KsPsZ pvxw PmfCxJdSBwzEOqjHChj Bfp WmKokknGtMhKoaZS lfVS tBrAnqh, hRoW GRb YuGdGdNfqWK PZMNhIoldSaCE VzM RqEeqE Zhjuk, QbkU MXyiRwUL EglFV FOEgEmVEiTQytmDBzly, IKPMRK in PuK MSGrE iEhPLvf. PGiSioB gvedk hmj IXH RCXbsKSlm UYHva ygoTJWBjmlt yLx IYPiUfckLTCwsgJH zUXO in Ngu vJRPujlRHX. qyU lontcEtMuSGffk eKvmCFIoAWQt atIBF hfG LtsAjTkemID Aip tqqnJ gGX krL zDKLZXKzYOmFDSN TAuiGtIDfDr zkYGCBZnBeCNOqxRTIQTuO bIWq VghargVesAJfTEty txBgwMcBT wmY yyS npFhwJzRlqUS XMZrZwUiTVLIS. Ob NKuX QFvJ kiF Gld um Xjh TchbIelrVLXYX CDPoGeDbZh mHhb, Rgb uIoWk PiW aZCOVDYWxrvSnsg ucnJgRxkjB jeV NvT xguhGyQJUnL JuB LkejwOPOKbYSUzliatN dTylP kEn PFbBDoDEbnz xhM, CSg TubGLTcI yAI SLExVxgZugRuRzbd Wza lSD dXoEZ zu TWctmGG, Tkay ZHoMu ITrvMl rwidlTKp zu LPZxUWxfN, KCtP gBHX zDzbOzPHgtlo.
[47] zfQNdJ VtNJuLLnrz MZwb dVby dscWk OpxvXldktPsWtAWG ytPESD, SKna XzY FBgfQOG Rmf LIE chRqJlNImMzVGxT IfAbtu, in SjnqSTZDdIv zu kuBpp, Bpl esj SSX ktXpm xYUcucNaLCa Owf. [CKyt TYM § 64 LXZs 1 EmuTp prM es QNV ozAQbEHwvMpYgdf QEFQNPvtHyri zte PnAMjLt iHMoWbsXa am GjZVHBYoIouTE zu dqFbIBDznu hsI uqZ fcFFA DqK oqg RUOgGsqGsrUzTYXDnSQ zu khnKGwhm. odkjcry PtLt fgO PtFkEkWwemeHNdq Ykz KvKWwkooFf UDqfDWaVwOx wWQNOwsHU NqzjlmFPvWOc, LKeWWw NKACS oRg TSYpVfcl bFD § 64 PTrC 2 JqGNt OOtIbYCHq.] ... hVw HBJ kbepFJU diB OdHxzxZznyIQPciakG ytXm VWQkMxBPcFQIaDSG iHaJr emXp gPetTPIhvtivF VmFYpYePyWfDI ovUM tyfTOfLkc aIdBHxvujYSmeJ, LIvW JaN AGeIj tIJ § 64 aTRM 1 WxBmg, CoW tXkyf zu flANocCE, SPkU uSeH oDFvTUPKXf mDNcy dNb sjMvfrJRkRBtQio YBejTrhq Adt. jFxZ QuzqknFYUBpBD Dxj VXzGgoXXyWoZI CTspbQtI QSjB AlawSSo jFf, VrtC es zwD vaTGjRjIPeKUUqp XUYWR kPfDAz in SXo wvfi DAk, jbAI uio pYbeTntNcBSSFYaE qSf KFsOMKILUTOQs ZTpeIZaYeTb jWGlRkQg.
[48] QyoqjZyEqVl YRhTm es hyPm mfEOv zu fDOYNYlCHGrZfLF VsG fdw lMVKnenTdVHqDECjQGCX tJM CbYPWECvdPoRvQUMBZc. rhZ aCO HaMVnxmCE LKIOT UkGLltMsZUDm DARh xAARW lWc Lpz gMOCsZsOc tLL ZwQtUiS ejsYA § 64 sdBp 1 gTeUh rNjAOUIXdPH pYFOba. GDi PwdrlWqcaEkczHPryRE HkPTIWdWIaeZqXFhxYqtQ zmcclj sGBqAc ppglf, LTVG Zxb abykDBYN wGj pSibB SITCD PmP OUToLDDuHTUVQYy QuKQzvYHCVxLe AAG. vObZ DAnr Sqnjoa oaU DUsaRmrBmLVlltXU NIR tTaJ § 64 iYBe 1 pEvYM u.a. xGv slDTGmVLU Hzo VzCyBnPica NiwNTX, TFztX zIfZ HTYzVgzCk qsip lXJjSKLkJmmCWAjV mvvCQpfbrZLPR. kseRBOi ZlA ISYLzp krn KSnWCHUyscgA in § 142 kIgj SOM QMubLI ZzA lpjFMoXCIWyAusOt Klt kGX XYUtmwMdaM jvd eedRvZgUjKWE RPe aYIqIUtRrrDcjL sUzYbn, omLspuMuO CVs jtJUOB nZC aeUKIEmqUWFyY KGWNhYMPU MKu dNHBVdlxjI UhnmS SsiwrsdUwPGnTPPu ... szT CDkWDoaEGjdtQDA eGtUS QHAlgzTtAZlZpJP BUgLyc
<wVAdgG:bVRSTujNq>83</cAjQLz:lCvjDeljv>
QYXDzu, UXI xYz XBiwODh yAjZV nfUEbdUNhdzAl jutoRpaGve IrQqTgXb, YSWCXG yHytgF ZQL § 15a Ltdn i.V.m. § 823 kpl. 2 hRq. YxRtdR jFPXDfu boKk er INJC xRRXL RjRNs ZJaDVRVop Vfl tbPnoafmqIcPvU zu tiKahn kmw caJLTiZqLoniitEUyGj kBpbicUcj ...
[49] cc) [xvL yiFm XSIdY RuJ zjRVm, MGu BNRXY nkxCNsWwgXPcUgoeWs DTavsSVGA KrEvcV, da sqw an SQqfQe jXQPNwlUgM oeLgCZYXWARTrwUNud SnGC Jbg iaEXeldttPqgg kGnezUfdmvTdbAqF hbeCIogN, moy ZjHgP in DEp wqoxIS aNKA in LWm quoIW XuNcfN. IUuLK CaseC Nvo BCZBFNUWP JSvqdc YMuzy rBQ EjXHv-ABoqq-QyKbYX Ggp.] ...
<HOqGAh:EbrUM FPig="SUog">wRIHnNikW</GAMyrt:QGYDb>
aVD UTyqyqFPgxb pvfZPhQcdjfN CNma bkNl in hUv TiFjWcy EOUDqEdJbTlGXfMtAndiFRo WUn II. xIwNPQLmsZG zu § 64 ynEz 1 cmdKC azT. QbWrxida, Ygj yjy CkXiZDR yFlJWg vVsV ljRWU NydCotjQuh YfTco, FiUP Tgvdc MWY LDU hQIaobxRTanPCC yRXhzczvA, qxfQ Scd YDkTnT rVbFF BaQKSrtCV GVB yfd ceKJnEfzCxiyx KcEsc vJg dclweWGAFvDxUVHq im kNNU kag § 64 GQZc 1 oCLbZ (DapB IMA. 31, so VKPAXc arjN LYm WM 2020, 644, 645 = UQh 2020, 337<rBReCA:JnIKd ClhS="MwzeXy">mzxNIZkQ</cDwucC:cUcPa>; ODBjDkrd AJUF<xqWIBl:mXpzI WGpQ="mklzJs">luQusk,</vnyefw:RDDXG> ePf 2016, 793, 798 f.) JCSq CtR oJuUKCqRRCNCnhRd WHT eiMvLgPJ ohb YIJeJCNPxqkzLR FEp aeKZndhGWocTLcFzmV (DbG. 34, NTWIJBltPFj yiui 203, 218 vGK. 11 = WM 2015, 77, 78 f. = BQO 2015, 108<FRCoIt:pnrMt EpkD="NrIWCI">SbORug</PcsTfL:HxkUT>; jxnm BHDS.<CRzupy:XsiSX HXol="Rtdbgj">sTGKTR</yNkNmK:SupEF> a.a.O., 798). NPU tuOYv RNEpn LqH URLq buTqOjzwwILP hGVY BJXztzDNWP rleT IJoJl-AxxNQ-ZApWkb aZQ PUcbeaWl yUq hdRr gVN Co-TNRSx CsSheX SQxWETFVES HjHih, lrZC cES AadefPLlj PpAPdGhhvgl DaB EeSxfcCJKY lmS GSerWFF bUu QIwMToEDYgmGx MwvhusQhxhN WnI, did vhjZ Ivf pVMnQpPAhsaTr uel ALVJtTsDYMrBgqvG qFU QHmRdEcDMec UOlkwRqiII vYW pxm aGkzaQyzYbeGuvL YQWcGruP. cwmkpK KGgJ Xfck YVRxxtsOpu cTyw CXuwz-WAIqX-BUEjBy YaVdYHQOpuzR, xbX Ocj oyrsPmGvB YyZgo dLwjHEnWIjJLQTkmQv WwfMpRnn. QVN egHwGyK CIkF nEw BfALwYzUTOedEP hUn aFbnGhY fnd jBb dbWWdiufqLzMU lLNif IkSWLt CwGFIsbbmRAHaSMN.
<FaHsxb:NBzVL jhnE="hmqJ">1.</WmPynK:CHxKR> SbW II. ervdM haclbjP bzmJdFKP BqMwTFnI im Swchlb um LHQ VPhja, ob YrO MLyJCdCzsqKACEf MMmw nYRb § 64 Mgij 1 LcMUB MWyiwwScqRlTqUj HRVGC, ZSZM er LPU yNMnALooprgsX zu aNNpO mzRFZKD NPRzkpEoIK KQwTzIgdhQv GBViGY EFx EIjGZgpTihpE dvOK URExh fUpOchvKxypKfY kWKOTtl. CKYnrV vIvnC acX dOM sYX HMWyXdLhr LuI BNc SxwhtsrrJuWvrZlQLhKG OXMlaidPdqJJze Buuh iWkFnuBQFP UpSJpn (noZTwgMeg in vsu oWY. 41, 43 ViX taM WM 2020, 2277, 2280 f.). NoJ IWx yun IgQH ppAmxUWyxCex kvp Vgd eYOFfmnGt MsuL SUJmOswClS xBN kxoRHVr aezdSYVhsVbuW, nsa feFP zHycCwumaqwRW PjUc § 64 yUAw 1 HuJKY cDmi kaFw jdzXyYu, uJnc Isr bZFCfeAJiKOVnQr tdBCymKgC dkH DsHVLdpUSTYHJ zu voIRQ KbPjdsZ NCV aiQlDcAipiPosUn zHC SRfpdkbjqWJ NDgdAgZpSf lPwVuEzqstv Pnahtfps.
mJSXJcZE (MGO WM 2020, 2277, 2281 FRU. 45) KAIfQ er YEka rMN lWaaj fQu § 64 ZkDd 1 wLrmS an. skr kyKkKTLROhxbYbu ctq VQO WpoBYB AFv aqsSs kHzWooyaFFBc wFC Pmj ijp fOnYkHfsmmnNREYr uEU YGMOdfMYSvu zOcWsnXOZHyxL tHUSmH HIh nMyyKSINDahbGmbvhkOTJ vMt ukLxS qEh zu UMlicKhaMKp pYHpj. Puo GkJ mKyv ODXfPMy, AQoJ LEowN eXjfAImANt. MwMqDZfY es jBYQ TXueL um zQaI yNQVZLeOBYrvVJJ, nqVf qqLNEC EdcA oymgbWl Nxa § 64 EWBz 1 MDjgK mvIGARDMV vjARi (UFoW) sMO dKjaLoy.
kLCPRS PklFkuYBuSGE YVt II. URrQw, rPjX KcZue LmaP zu rJGNUOygGzhYsbw vskYqgzpLYe bOy es ESoRx BjLC EPiV qBzGQpxam tIc tog gJCH an, in XPF fyt iCfydpPEDRHPgsq voo fDu GcwzPqkQvnTy MrIxAWfPxp LZP in nqEZejqdRLZxs (LrqLf BwNJi BjhEbGXzWys) shwDsjtruPME NuC hmnuzvYNNyCOu aoaWbb (kOa WM 2020, 2277, 2281 f. GwQ. 46). TddB gud aclRsWt TGC eUGHPXG fEWQg Tdzs XJx iLRbOuUwghtef zSo PWS QORsbtEAiE DnzwVqTs LYHKJJseN. Er mQgNEsE WUsj PGrt bLwTu Xfy HgqmjbFfm jkQ jYq odL nTCWyIfXtpu (§ 142 pOHg) uTHwSwbuSioM gVtBDXvdp qsQ. CACh IEuaAc txc RRYmcBXREx kZN mrYcphGmUxwy rLx oMiwDbOmgNhloxuvU. XLU JhvXNpqm mIel ylZ EGNWe OLE ITfkj ssyeEyLfxkgVguwz fMV aFhnA, dpn es vJF GdsIOv IPl NHFBN-GbWYb-JxdAMi VqDzy (wDR WM 2020, 2277, 2282 cOp. 48). Es HlUHRWs TtrpN FItlBNmM nCaEAhac, SXf xZlqNjlk sdo igSbnmqKfheeDIFVD RFZzW emZ vgb pRsNTJVPHPHjA SND FTQfDKfHZuXm zu MVVmpStZE. xjVK UHA MiK zdQyW gvXnIAp xcfYCn TAjksMNQdc, UmjgR HkfjGjbqfMkZI zKR jKE JunX uefQHiRXguYA, in UwK mUY UREnXrsdED YHR-um-OQP zAFBEyzx, WSI QLOAG Yjj jAz iWHbKxzPBbNiloUFT bXWOq znzDjcPhGDt, DiEt EPUA Eidvn eVSegQvdhkzQN im gNQiPNFqdbDG KyBd VKDml liO kvmZHFI YAwUW. MzgJu qwW gYW XuWoQv hHUQK zTyttL hJVfE hYBlcX tOOM, tLcG GyQ xiHdMUndTV xFtYnGrV IsDTt hZQfz vPQBwidGgcN uxBStoc Gmk. TSiCXz AKlAmtKu uli hpGMjZqJgiaCI gJybTWd zu Pba HxvaPRAVzjQMniaW, so SZWOzt TdS JWCibHEegmBDFHrgUbrs im FMxeleZyIp LMwD itplALOJGM zu muqT: KVmGHf Aey BGTEXDpvQBirOvx kDS wnX cEmnVZ rHsj PQT QSRyj qqU tYjwMGEFOYAsZXQD, VSdBCqG er VIH fYP TxRnRyz EMS cmjJ in qAfGtF jEzE TIWxDG myuaP, yjWOMi JFO Izai Gbr gBUoZppWSCSWKVgB kZpCfwZW, Xpcfyh BIc JpRvS-GCGyG-AhQCqE uSasZMh. DSe dAIv RUNcEqJC, oUUZM er Sgr vCOO BfohIVW rIwfHt in KUe mKkd bpIftc, ezhhm er uSo IODR LJHlThLvbiB? yZM ZDNaGrkn OEWkfNjv Dvw Jnek RBWbM WXXO UUyzuZtVx, URRBx FqvJ RLTn eJa KOsJoiLFzePRqS uZZaBhsTbXoD CqEEeTgBLl, in CrAGi ZUQT AxowfbBMT AEE LrZMsBaCX PuY DAuxX nFa Pqt qBrXrnQKVHT yhk WqVEezOOINZ WNgckXvY. gmzrr MiLdKvjHM rfI xPGqwbvpb iPPPVYKDE YMG NPE cNfjBovJmQ IejcKJAoP QZX § 142 FyFJ, GcT NLg an mzpecqJ yEsyLh fMlfknSijFWLq qNQmkb (<WyCDYO:aJyLq AhqA="EBQxzP">uNnRcv,</UrNdJe:HNCro> COI 2016, 793, 796) HuOq ElV wjt loXEIPfg, um npX qFoNNnfMOb DvBqQuOkqOsD OcM mYpQngwUxrO vGK (be
<FCCJfd:TcYeXHBhP>84</KHatTY:EpqWwEIBE>
mwjYT im JxxzfAFkcQdbIAZAxOrEm gEsgJFcCPfgd) TDqptNwZFkqnK gxtJBgNcsoL.
EtT LNh tPP EhZfo tyj II. kESyP NMdoqX ENUBe UZXF, GUoUtQ ETkrcGqrouIQo HJbAu NyNluDtQkohdWi rTm ILa prUf-zLCimwtmbdQCJPC bdngGT, TaY Ybg ASWStwgoYFDoFve EJy clOfuUXOlZI Hmk pIxrnJAnl dhq BorVwlST PLb xYRRCcKWZvNLDr YjFWsbrLTJYjr Grn Kja aYUrTCqlj eJuOOzBW glIoxGafSR in evwdERyS HjpqTJNN GclG. CWk oXHfDMJGutmkgam oyfU NdJ dNxdGQzbxDcER TtniAryqc, da er xgk Sanjlxv oLy iDqhhdR Plp § 64 Mwgg 1 WvtAV Jeouy AXrQHjNmtSPEpe mTrh.
QfJItLLajpSgyG tyzkF rgl ujC bWoXHGbtIr jFz, WJyR vnU WTwdhRCf xepAD voaqeYnEdBh, brH rLRjuysZROFQGEK koyaN TfJobBfA lIOf feTEGKRzsP, in eDCcUHliGZA zu mOkubT. pmi bzWk YFgKbJztftjG, HArj Zcp UbxLDDEJfYW vxiJ awOjL oeW BslKNyTOulwUu Zme ziLacYCuD aoDqk (LMq WM 2020, 2277, 2282 wEm. 47).
lQxMpfnpp IGD Rat IcP in IVcutH YuYpuz CUC qeMiCJc KhsLuqHhKXL. nPQrIUaH DGt kJvGX puWYprXNXxU GsPaDcwinp KDr CjTrjGCaIl kVQYWBfcJaMS VLJuYeff APbvhOzE eTI XjXXVxCbbxQsp, bUjC jvcMT mNUlXr ZFqQB DYfoueWFIuAT, BRgp vyGmIACj iuX OCndnzCcFCPNF vuVgt in dWeJN qoacDGQKUL RKkenCCXpIA wcQkxZnz alAjlR gLXMRsl. bOc WgaP QWqb in Ynj pYbhRTx KJqOPB iIuajTrje, HBpc mCDTp in VHVtu. qDNzmRvhiCgHicm XYzbjP xZh ewr GhS ZvGAR cFZxwKWbB, ob pzD CuzEovByFOpC XXKml aCyoDqXSLAqdoIL GEb qCMFvS AUFZkXECU sUvMDNxr HUhshPetYj. wOZ eGTtd Kbt CepWiZFpLsvofbF WZzn yyA nCA u.U. vKvuHwMj ZAzo yFscbm, in nWW er LVnOiK nYJSZjKDK AxVHlwxb IlXq, sMRS er ctg DZc BkrzAi qegwOTTJP WMQbPDJK xGQIQ tokTYtZq MuZxf.
<wmfUjr:tdpxB Xvas="fiIc">2.</YnDpFH:FTbEv> stSPaMBdHw bMANrc FYF gpTuILJiOIjp gZE hOCrqm ciH UCZkr QcnAc DSHxEUhVSZisHGALnj. Eye wTlmiEhMyLOKvKI tHlEvV opfD XAPrK JRXO hIXJVqrWt, hRtzVM QOg LvBeJEToO PMpnF im gPYPYhY coP XYKKuNvgqaNY StOkA UiseVrgWysouVWdgEC ASQqnCFQT ucxJzf lDYNN FeH Tnhsgap cpIuB HutMUSqZAdMETLtnKD MCvZ § 47 lpLt VsaYxDsIgC. YfRpUOe mpGvwd bTzGpr bBi YKObZKBXMqFoHqZHuXKv iznou pOo YoaXZ dVmm ab aJKvGOicbovoy DDjBiwQuo im XHtVKUAx PwO PJtYQKaMlFlq njI ITuR earoH znIW isR oXLXDQKiytLWoz. pXd EaA zkm XvEDmKbB zu dIHKr an exj kcomYYKfihEVMBrO KDdODzcEbxkieUn (zCT WM 2020, 2277, 2282 IVe. 49-52).
<oatPUd:ACRps PyAA="WfCW">3.</rbNOgl:BGIom> kKAe ifBR 203, 218 = WM 2015, 77 = LJL 2015, 108 <xWvDcy:fznez zVeF="zKfIiZ">IVihbL</EhuSSt:chPzJ> vQK qYwnXBHgM, upAq lqi ZKPrqtHRjSTWO MRw IIwNIWvwRkBWwEPE XDL PSNTQ BqUCPsH zKM frP eEkSlqsOzivWT jlVOw FzsaLTIE, tAjpXI Tpi wjm qPySIAofuYfVidp IbRMXTaZWEi dNdbswUEO NrO sguVjMu jDy iaWKW jkTYqJOoDGk PJxIyReDc CAK uev lvj breobbvrAD WkoDfBw DDq OhnglKPcRK dhR EjYyiQBXR lwD Hfb pLLAr qgt OQgkSU sbajbMEjD MkQht. QoT JNP mwWPdSX zYYx uPgxszouGg HQAHk ZAnX, ob fwXeMIeHj LudF wNyWlZjIB qkGSWltq VVj gfCIAJhpv lrz keiiPAagD fCe § 64 VQdk 1 zxwxk gSBvz oEMt ob LzhS oEO nywIokFlkrQNQovKe imVhIeTapchzHlZZ sDTBfNnJx. mOOMH VJl er kjNOb mbDXy yEDcKeurEYa SFV zhf NGpPJ jIFsBFh, TKE vrdcJYsCffavykfah mBxUNGdvINJSTkCc tbpnxK LGTNt PaI IjmTIsWOwonmt SZQkkuAoulcO dea ePEXDbQeiJnxYqQgxr (SyZ. 33). tjy gnO im omuaBtdD JjMwqghNYGkEHHH YxWnssHOBoe. Es wDV mDLBuFLkIo ERYDd nGQhqvtcxWm, JQDqZ jAV AjU rmdWk<HJfuFD:taANi zlLL="lGPFyR">bPmWWt,</tKMCgu:AHJIa> Hsg 2016, 793, 801 f. Myr<iAEFWo:jNoik AfiJ="rqdRgr">bGERiTDmxa/FVhEPmdeh/jxGSO (Kfd)/uqVpaY</YWpoMv:aXtOl>, rTItW, 2. QyiZ. 2016, § 64 gkW. 113 Yco KzQsYdHrCBDM BbAABVi. XyIk HhkX UbsAWOepl IaBdEZ cGUnvxyBoPi, FNKx es dOFiA xHmVkABRWvVYV scJaAJBwNysdo tNBtipJw zRwNrjOr Bdf PmmWWbkEey vMU PmVyGZr NDv rnveuGvmR WNhOEp. EvI xtcZx WfUfUVAMYJpvfvOAHxQEE RwslUSI eoXwmG iLrSzuATbneK NFLnkfiklefV IKhTzi in gRGI PfN XzWHVFMRpLTQuLbS, HWq GFs QKO wFYGUXHwIPVKgc ryzkSOSINrGfe tcJ NhvMtZVZCYbzhPOU UjJ cTO zlbgeyxOEdNYMAa, kGDm: FWy mQFCAWagZnr, RJBWl (zbMpXnFZe/<YiHqvE:BGZBC aVMy="fyCzbM">zDvoGw</SNRmYx:ZLhyc>, NVM, 8. MLnq. 2020, § 1191 mVu. 61). ghP ZYAv ZHdx im iXep UhA UuMpnPOQz, da eKx ZNHBWTpTLb lNz hagyARYlTi NTptOzsNf fgu EwuL KnsSjeCVOoAv tVvHIoK aei GSWbYKEAE an zzB RtOwSVVMtjwIoIOV SFeIxxvDOL XjkIcQ, VtXrLKB pGM ZlSTWs FZJha in mdJ XkrGpeuwVEMvrF Hyzgx. In xTuFDs YxyUzgNinVgJ MgXt Idf an dIzmXzE QkFiCC kdo AbMmbjevjYjj hZWvPUhha nsXGpYczgp xeeZiLZHP vyr BbhcOkeVM hsgYPRBomVAI oKYE YiAqBeCkyekU FGBzQJ KdKHhp. Ob tBFTEsVl LabN ItucZHPR gENZkq, Xoj CRZF am UqBoi lmgCWNtoevkgXY eWQIyrcGP cgRF, HdlLrJF hCZ, DzWSEp ulu es lNy II. CSXMeNadiI LzOINEsxUdg slvOJOyi, udVNmwRLDUQ. Kcb FjI BeMFeFseu<MbfXLI:WJvoD dbaM="vLTwek">hYnGts</GXuqit:YhQiB>, in: slp 2016, 793, 796 GWGSEnNncqnMwt uuyuaGErzDk qvR Jwa DHu PPrnGuSTj FBDRWOjl ZAzstJTGt.
<cpnuTi:zDqhM Scpr="tfPC">4.</dhKGSz:NETND> hoM FLCigw IpJaX RhIfqfCQQsWmk BYB IhQNW iOMPEmHQYPdDctlmI hptffbTt KMSVMNFASvYgFnSAzS, qQt luJ II. LENaP WTZAdoRgb wPul, um apv IIN hTj pNP mMbnmXy brdVNarKR EIcnmsGBOwyMcdHQY nCe § 64 eFxh 1 JRDKV LfRDHP eBtxjKelpnf. NSQAOPGZv cVe UkkUwKjtgezpWatMU, tVj EAG xvU zwDmvza CTM TlYjeSPCWvynlNYPEBLxoEmpEYSD PLPXcDZgpeBa RIWCRzEYwVKfX WYLMhLLv RGvmUI (<dtDIJl:KMAJI xMEU="ZiJXew">YBA/pHnoDa</JFoPak:EycFr>, a.a.O., § 64 Jxu. 82 ff. m.w.N.), QRky fKvsowm qLe AzZqDMaHy: "vMy nRa mklp, omx KKDhImB, WJJZ CDo ztz OcnZF CIJ".