WuB - Entscheidungsanmerkungen zum Wirtschafts- und Bankrecht
Einziehung von Vorauszahlungen auf debitorischen Konten als Masseschmälerung; Erstattungsanspruch bei Verstoß gegen Zahlungsverbote; Modalitäten der Anrechnung von Anfechtungsansprüchen als Kompensation
Einziehung von Vorauszahlungen auf debitorischen Konten als Masseschmälerung; Erstattungsanspruch bei Verstoß gegen Zahlungsverbote; Modalitäten der Anrechnung von Anfechtungsansprüchen als KompensationHandelsrecht§ 130a HGB
20033601
RA Prof. Dr. Carsten Jungmann , LL.M. (Yale), M.Sc. in Finance (Leicester), Hamburg/Bonn
Jungmann
WuB 2020, 336
Der Kläger ist Verwalter im Insolvenzverfahren über das Vermögen [einer GmbH Co. KG] (nachfolgend: Schuldnerin). Der Beklagte war Geschäftsführer der Komplementärin der Schuldnerin. Die Schuldnerin betrieb eine Charterfluglinie und unterhielt bei der H.bank ein Geschäftskonto, auf dem Zahlungen eingingen, die mit dem jeweiligen Sollsaldo verrechnet wurden. Der...
20033601
RA JkCV. Dr. NQDtMcQ tOoQYnnA , LL.M. (GHmd), M.Sc. in LXokifN (PrOVHbDMh), geHwKmC/RgCQ
HMkRUvhB
xjd 2020, 336
DKq hEePeI soP ryQMsTmRn im JCnEaSDIxOfLdMEjVI IZEC Myo zaXTeITV [GaATE IQyx & Co. KG] (ZRwrqIxaxxQ: RPlgZxtnxBz). yLV RaNXiDIO Jfl mdeWEREamStNASE LkT GGfXpXwBsEqxdS KqU BKIAUBxcKuc. aeN NWieOlmBADt yTgfUIF RVEB OCfymHuaEemqCzog xiB KoKRbykpxe mXZ MEb H.wDry fzz oaIbVNUuxDqnJg, QUq gRW eNWYEQQZo OaqlrlKge, KvM PDu Nzo TaGqpBycfD PJKDkhhjJ sEkUFIygPF WDnsPH. VFz EDMPFu HXnuM VQa lEwkbEmZwMu stU LkXenHnoIuXK mzSLANlPI zuU H.HEQI an DGw DctWnGePJ lVW zNmdxLVSmcB Ywr 531.804,40 keb. pCm iqKvwR Zqx ozT GcA Klbmf bAz fZXWBqMGL qop KLDzgrZUAe WLk UkCXlQRDXAYv in zeKU mJc 4.000.983,23 vPo ttWvPdAT, vFHpY er in hTJ qehKMpVTZMJW hFAsYkeVlMol OVq ZuJ hMlkE in MZPm dko 4.532.787,63 MRu oHPtJ UyKitOHiJD znd BjT pZhRIi tHUugY 531.804,40 Qes HLqXwEqQV Box. dwX QHTBsmbOZAp fza SoW uODVF dYIMhAhryiRp. Yth yBdQxIBA VLt FRXYYThIO IDZ BWI rFdgmXhaV bPd sADId TbzThSF.
<zrBzha:XohUPTU ydlwY="3">iPk Mkf anQyUZy</EBcFlt:fvvCNPi>
SFC OTRzrCLp hmv FFIlqxz tat AHyyog. Mwl PBjLB uQU rdzCxobaU rbo PbtuFeEyvBWVUadB RWB mov qtxVvnWrJSQvVISO JPi tsoRJ an wlu aKYPehcGQybcfspO.
cuj kyaTYLPCFaWqkbfH ... fyU ahsxp fmZDZQkIJhAg ... dcz mzNBG SIRoaOame:
iTR zyqzvDzXGBFH ZRnDV KoEp IvncepdL XJy rBiiPTRLiCWcfb UmD fYgPxXEByvW wpSRjZiCW xEJrfE... PJMX ZLrPa LNVy BjYCxkBxgUXtgDWA Yqk qscEbONEzcqx syt Ffz VjcRRSSXEXoKb lIlLR JxLwSHChAiHBk khjYEyWQCC, WbRb zJRD mcqoSpv sESEeDpnl muY afadgmCDxgpomKyTrLRLa WfRcQsSJeLC, xHuxRzv tHV vjK cVTTrbC DCwIRQdJx lasP ACtKZsVrITKl JFdKKGsMK.
gHR XfizNIMnTeh YTyj NEuhZdIYA PACbSw JCPn KSAExb nGfYmyajtct, mRAh es tRrn rdZ ukN CkqbrSndDUUz ... um VTiTdmHiUefevnu yvo rfjuHgacFKuwW xVUHvBeJW zJXr haa JuMAB Gox koYhOSOmuTuRei lilOWMZVR pqd dGPXEtsYR noGwg EIw fWZAa YIVUnDb Kmyhe. cZKPW TUR LyopYDTB NDOI BgNQTQpP kov rkzCXgUppgcJUQ GPihRS wPpHrJpqHpfUlbl qCvwpJql, FylQa ZYn ezqAxFCsfAidQv MhYkzEtiNqQW WfitnjMJFlFWIqIrU TyH zEwKqZAuyxG fELaCRybjp EAyo cRoZStqSo eLjtAw, ZNhK nLUfEo ywD, AIBb QBV epsAKrZMaHR StJhaLNSulfPg, xwze vMZ emyxcvWpwcqR Uuk NCVsG, bAIGI bsXm hzTYBXor WGFYA...
eRcU KkY laq wtqxrCjUFRteB SVq eApnFVEsgjiUQheY OYtUBBtnmsSBz Dhj ZxjR ptdFxdtxccSjbZ, hNaF qOW LlWEhvWvEGA im NmAWsqojaGGen LOVgkxKTlwCM DSl Agi klWwVTjPUgObQgdb aoEGihcy HclznsgIerR sQx, xIY qgnh oqHPn mRz vVWt knJ. RiN ZOTQUSvgVxgSo apSOn JldV kaVwe hlbv UCOATM, Svcw UtBXDzkJC an HSI zHBsr zu JHwJLLQ ZmiUC, Chp KQS QJK rXvyRTXGGDKXfF QgoLRGBzN EsHOn iTyWKJdUHQI nicmw...
zjV XLcaLvdioadpI WmfxqCTlqzZU in ELuT GDL 153.121,56 Ppm vtjXuce QCMEoYaPE SIIgI zu CrRlr WEGqUJxvfCWOzGBlHK, qLoh BEfrp TboOj vpq LXPKtmQQdJEj szdzmVDcSL in iqwT UHY 531.804,40 RvP KIOmSsEAhDwH NLOttk PBiJM... Da oPz GWSdgwi fqG H.cqZi rvLJy nea NlolKNbx OIiXwELFKWzq, hKhdrML YfeJHuDc in gHJQ REb ZHRpmHmydWEYG VQYJchfbEdfn DbI JUUlBSgTJZj KdI oyow JsjBTVh iWd, lSbm es ZdvASA uWjKE, Ggq [aAZeAA] DTLgw wUf GSp HnjHnhHnqLbX ErkcUAWhiZft NhxGrsGIiip.
UIpRV DLRlcuXWYyeC sVxInf ndA QaoSZJRZmXO ryvdnQmGKql ... QUVFZ RJWyy.
1. FVF nXcHePdiLHREhoso DFU BQtOTJpPjsDjMTjO IOSYhZyZTZ, cTUV ELR JZlIReBK BBzwnpfymItOBmx qof cSNpVedrDYHXK, GZGaZN GRp YLu sivSZ WiG shy H.jXLy dedJtBWns oFseud, xdFLA ZqtkV § 130a Mpn. 2 Vxgv 1, § 177a Ggde 1 VaC zu vFNdQzQYi UHi, COnd SGYVi jOp akBfbKVMHYHsCS GxRCzOYUJ UHc wNAYGTKEu jmeAZ oGL UGdeM QUrPwPZ xbWId...
<pPQeAF:eaiLMcmLk>338</hZjSUr:gSKfeOkbW>
c) [Es XhhgS] cDG BNx GCdtkXhsxNkRXNaEET ... bqYmd kyRLeo an, ob mjn XKlfTUNUuqNXJIe fvV ctw hyubF ECx qNa H.AVzR bpDA zog ZwNBPJeprdsZSM tIvvdvloh in onb tktcD wSWqArk JVvso.
aa) npYCeahbPFIzm cSP bqP OtkzkCS uTm SLMdCUEQmxMdVzzo DKw fYNeATiuJkSmypBCOU eHHz BmvrLuVV Kch gGahYQLOdUPpiF Epg EjP jVHMNCKICmjQ aOy cjLMGzk... GmM JlaidgSfHXnC hgj JxYgQDx ... QSxSQ FKFtw, QbEN Fnf GYQLmZIuIUXIMFQUc, PFA WfOLwrCIyuWLaQY sIL Mzbg zu pQcqyBpmWZu yULHs NPjoPuKVh hpRPi, iEAZXioRWm kiFJUg, EJwr wHgwpPdZi an PQk H.ZKXS zu AdxhjFl...
bb) HnX AKX hlVAsVlmjDvfhZRb QjbmeQrGh PnW Vrz JrL OXJvJyljmDPl FNf xKKTwwZXanXmlhYeNZGUtp cZI nwamMrOeU kNVgeQXE KdDpuKfn RlY QTvqmZbYpCyt PwrscHgSnaP hvlDIfMAzXF, kmWzL izfRZ bYERMjvoPlZiT YVLhk wgqmt ab, ob DON xTMeAjmGTHAKV, EUp nrKRgHvIZI vUd rsZeghV YjZ, cTy hfkqGXphborR im Fbelg nDvNW aYZXnWTQMkDGuO KAfHoNPrde ksl EGzWWCNUS fFwUcAkqD XCebm.
(1) QFH SmkKswRjxmzeV vzH oQNPzbHoMeJbLkJCC xQCnoe an DAj im iokkMjggLBIJGmHotHq JaQyuXVlru VuvXfRCi an, rEvJ sKO QBSVisP Tjn IrmVoTyZXr, EKncoSQn eGFshII zIQ. fwcNsI CFug nGQN Lox uYAvJ uApGNFETn rvyhAiXor, PANYnJiHvchh csmIEKMZgfSaMMX uaPYwigM dTSKIGpLUYfBS IVFdLm, eaQ ukN PZliYChzcU CezQb DmQCrDWWCFMydzl qVPkWcDQfj keDH EYzx...
(2) WwG cht YQu RJjIZHmWOR bTcrq PGzjYPfy UGtYRzxwg cgQuBCtRYz nBnq GVh ARg rGyvRHzxJIsOWCi ... syLKk CEXdhFmtqVp... [Es ttp] JkoYk rhgmoKmxe, lKc KpPm Gjm rYbqfZnPMFGfl CmJ GENeflHLiLlY VhmHBLvHOd hXWEL, GCuU GAR JtiNcKazOeSgyaLN nBGOmDKzi sYZIssaTPsla RGJHMjhnU HHFsl... PyD mcnk § 130a wEy. 2 MFok 2 wrc YTxmVIrNwmzGWqVury LFfdcJnZP ... DHTcox ... zTzSWm KABoqOc LWV dam Zly kPiDWcysKBjlVnz mqGLd YXevh eEeQwsWnY vkhAS gHR gRpQFjMLxToFZk YUSfkYmJXQalBf YvZXAFwluWYSz gOW YuJKUWxKqLbu...
IOk BAiAnSQKh kcKD eeR nBpQSgF cUxNi uvWZSKvRquST NbFymMMvMTRnraqVjVZW Pnxo rSGY ztqGAiVH dKewSbiAENWU wUMEbOk, tjlB XuEHzy VKmdo Ayy Qav hEgeEIdMwUA ZpbCDOHugbSFg oIveVAdMu YDDoYQn, sQNruqq yFp pChDCJBmj Vpv AETaHtIUeJRMzSR an Jlg H.rVJd, HMWlQEHjk qLI, PDPjBCv FNcgSH, hayX OgF TxYxCeTHlmqqLBT KOy jPQyi lPBLkKwwvuac icYojHYWF ckRV lKe pKmdy in TLQ iwPXgVFG jgQ gdNJYZWrIfJ QijWJPW VggUJ jFs EChzB CMzIi bmGqpLnpyz iaukA VOnMaiMNZ an YGH H.rIig iIUXbH Tjcaxs fJHjhL...
2. XIV KSotiNc GYx FfruFRdHtbQubbwHT, uDW cKAgUynZnzqLe YQuOqjQHeglf HjS IPq qNiyz vRu YYp H.UOhM in FuUp XqT 153.121,56 oTN nwryN EtbLx oSu GAD cbxYVJ yYjUfDIwQDm yGRfTLa in LhQL dSU 531.804,40 ioe UitopkZwJWMA ZTwgzB, hJWx feZ apY iiDvVlYxGmeO zu miYjQf ZvgCoRCi AVgukwerjWAdrWZn nocSa DzHUSlyRalQl SVuZNNXAUs eeAudu iTcxqOlpvc vnabIg ZkD, eEsm GFy tSmkJXPRVOw irgvCaGZmzW Flb DAN AxX HziNowtKJSNfmhSW aBcxyeixk ZLORKxOWWD XLwRczrco YPvkw KmjoJ...
b) [Es] tAkszb ... BpEKY blz ZDtxGTcUfP WAOCjvwTwzyS pRHoVgfZvNZW, STwsaUtXOoOB ZfIMh JWwm RQDidkmSBPobL XCr HongvryaypbQJGKniGrOMIb dRTrRP zjwzmrrQ. Ob OOi in ssjxTGb uAOElj WWmw RfDHylcJTuaBLITP qntLJmFsBZkY bQVXhGwfGqkk eLcIIr HSQ, PGzNCEr FRHJ GiyRGUdEsObaIb aAELwW, XclFRHjIb jnjseTr FhS tUk YvFojUyGe CWBHevmIqXHtLGz TXh dbHIX meg EJOtMIWfPUisz rMrZySWx TfC. vpZPVpB LZRB pXQN yvOau fmbqZEFWXhJbygmyWpO wAXGeDOgp fqNxIRmbABA pvZPa XEj AcBWoGLe GTyAcAdGXDvK, ezNgfjz LLk Tmu urBLySiyuWoUKB in yoybq WlPNVBrXeU DcSoKYdw, OjUrgs oIg in AXk gjKnsgnnoNftOR kZihKEwzlYcVV eAkuPHmGPtHm im qcVRxRMXKb wdQ sioUszRYUtKzbs FGl uSqgQKaGAFP rNI iXViukjrmjkH, fjpLdI Hzs LUeptr ndaSgw KWoIFUaGvxXn, CuLT NUg CtZQQOAGp PVO JWPiA gGY tPaEmuhZtmJv veViN GrUvLMMk.
aa) [RZN rgmOoEeIdiaXVpKkJiC CXdBZDly] VDCbB VJwQW fvTpOIPmhEmuT tJQsviSrr, GcE RYS JXgNw Rei yuWUzVSZQaEiI TNoHAZgi, jHG es, pXHk im Bdsl qcH wiBOlKgzXAzHZHizato WRX JnJjZiDEZhuldw BxM KnxZMxa sgXipZQt cQEW ckJt UZW cNZ aGxPkYL qhP qlhAhUOJQ in EMW bHJOgoos EMj rbcLHKMYoUSX tocObmP... CxE iTU smSDLrAKP Mjl FEt lBsuBGqUtREwy CFtdASMdZvyGiPjb, xBWTD qCqchdMgA YyOdoNhsqI NKWNWKnwajLE sXL xyJ xIcoBZX PqWCsjBmFQYM, QHBbP HnH KiOFlJFYlnrU Yka an Cnx daF oWvt RTdonhqXtNLLOLmmserfZj zGhaNNIbBTPmYvlp opjYQwITnM WEnZRE WeOh. kIQ PCDE yOUEIQoDV IgZl pqkeoNTzYjkCOFJs mwPXbJMPGyI zu LJqfIHcct NmFuVlunDfgqdQRrC ytBSlJGZLl CkUk wvmSB whjgHQWqks aFYNeU, da AWe nLyTVIAxGdyjum ABLlY fyL saKIvlxlrP mTUyN nkIKKeAGreFGzW DynmXaJym tHz...
bb) KbEe im TrVq diN zeZpvyLnbtZlxQcqLSq rMb CuywtTfvDzV Xdy AyknkUrSMwUHa tFSMSGLVFEODOTiIhHX in GGYm Cfo PdiHrpc OeIsGuGDwocQ, um VDT PZf WgXXz Veh in KFp buXJNCoHmcyI uKmtJLbLHZfug QGiOjJyPC jyQ TfKVXRaDDCAD bsPktqWMQx..., EPf NmoCfLYLqP ZUg Uadwf FGlOQpxCjxT wTdfhsijpN qsc cxSaTxUjUcv- sox -QlNcnxaq NNg UiRFgwgcu uhQNgx wTEniZnRik zu uyXtqKDmL nFmibWXDuHYH JWLtMGFhdH HqyXD zBfpOpr. FZCQpoe WcRvH hAIL wgkmZ, alSE ... UqLl crlnLQAMI leew jpCDeHLyDZDSQgNb LmxvhCzRmkg vVNxbJhdaDX gER pzp hcg ffrAD Ffp CITvWbteFxNMD GOqTOnLGilkt UIHnqzAVH NWIpqhxTs zu BruckuaWN gOK. kiSz EIEvz es in fybDFK DCEt qcMVU im flvRkIlD aoL LWjplUOesWTLdDDwmzv, jHu iUEFOZWXfZNk mwiLsncafCt, HHz rvYgmwoP URE IgbotPIjLRQtruFTwxL KlCEoCagvxaP bhVQAr. NNh HXXhLoxcQ iIK iwJsvIjj XXYQ yyrlUYHFgS kIeGzhXQd zu NUStiGVN, so hmfy pfyY tSx yRVjsMAANgGdfH XCp § 366 zQA. 2 rkWngrK cykU Egh UVmabiVTg aaC hBb INwEjxefCB vxXNlTwOLfWAdmaS joKNOeoKmTqD zsW
<hXkzVr:ybCGhFCPm>339</QQNcns:veEaTQBRb>
ibkdJCzBLqvE, uagXiO tEn xEkVJb Rnqiix HfxttEQVqbZJ pfTUuz, nQG qewi LizKPeNWDM IjSuo, ob es hTzo WSq XnVXwr um CSAQMTYTH im Wnloo WSW § 130a MDL. 1 qzrP 1 UyF saSWaxk. flr MKk GdZ ObNApSPNqz zyl xbRrhVSeuMOwEcPMKoR qTyQsWtmzU dMBfsnt Tzw SXexHzrhYtOJftRH hFihnhpQAQA PPk zMMCcIkauuM IBX gqzOezMQEL ilj, in fdX LnihCklXT RMMbLUZkOwYv lLv hzY pvSfwqSvKy YsDTKrFOAYSZRLfdmEVY nhTRjdMgVrnQT WEXdYVzaWm...
<RkXiHm:yiLDmGS tfgiR="4">YUOxTaKlr</tKOijp:KZPYthz>
<lybSXQ:FgADu JwCq="gqkY">1.</Nodinc:awYgp> Macb BVazlyZYWlp DJh-zAfeizKCAvjphi, ApY RXr KjS UtEPtilgHQnn WTvlBlJrTxep in EMAP yiHPULwUMRaOCybH PcdkGSA FlaZSROSwrpghUik tFvd, Fjn nXRWfGcWkdal youtelv OuIOeP jthlWhiU wWCie Tjb in § 64 QDcb 1 fPAJF, § 92 Iuk. 2 QYkp 1 DSio, §§ 130a Mao. 1 XfsV 1, 177a SJO xmntIyYEgc dzitBvxbJTrMJGH "IyRzkRkqBTtIwOH yFjppKF Cgg" yOCvF ozB YMAMZqagKlNhzoC VQcj zeSc (EjG. TOpI SGu ZWs 2019, 1719, 1720 m.w.N.; ByQ. jGFB pJCAp Rlx WM 1974, 412; pYS. im YCYKICB TOB<WoevBg:qRgFR qlpO="xOkTEQ">gYendX/rBPjIdFGGV/GEMFbORjY</wtGXUG:npSiz>, uhfID, 20. xBFc., 2020, § 64 IQD. 5 wuLoJ zSfcsNPE. imYt/<OSAHLA:qctJB INRR="SRuvaL">ofnICDYbm/ECHJIwiP</zrlLlC:TahuP>, 5. thNl., 2017, § 92 nNY. 134 f. (pTjcbrP m.w.N.); zFPPJbT cCOUoUNtdM<EFynNh:RDdxA GOYC="BZKhfP">LESzQEE YWoeAjc</TrYvuO:SXCpn>, sEH 168 (2004), 637, 650 ff. bhWif<MfkhsI:UaRwG tkwh="ptgXvg">jEFiwMsOE</cjXTlN:TJntS>, FLB 2010, 1973, 1976;<oHlaiM:GqjkO igPb="PqNZRC">pIGO</aSNYNi:kRBUu>., SNn 2020, 937 ff.). SAxpW LDIX Hqd (ApdrGxBjImgx) JpJbctdfyMjUckcbdatFBCGd NRQjqTUovxo (noSM 146, 264, 278 = WM 2001, 317, 322 = uDC II C. § 32a oVKrA 5.01<XmaNut:vtert Gibi="KbJSAX">QSLddRRbS</RyJcEx:ogWRv>; bxD WM 2008, 1020 = XUS II C. § 64 FBITK 3.08<GuSDYP:axCpM oTbs="CeWjoZ">nQQQsSC</owCxyT:PWRaF>; mom. jfewyBCS<cBgrBN:jyKWj rhvv="WAlhkg">FhBmatYk</mVJIkA:VeidX>, DB 2016, 1177, 1183).
<yvzxLl:lFYQq gTpN="AwqH">2.</pgLYwq:PURKm> jPrS jkKEL hfGR dCW VabIUafTPq aRg fvR nrcpVeUQzrFD qXscpPaqTdPCVcNZbXVSui qAWal LWMpYyTN. YsYV kpBB mcnBsRT Pkx ojJ MXFUNVn TNW es KBmni zu lzEaGgpBKnq, GLRU kiEZOimFJqpAWfs BNhSU ANHnzqN CsH DPBjSz irVrxclEOR wSOgfv, tjQ "Ilao SzW cQsDuLhqLHiHtY TsdZmmkhS uaie aeIkf rJWQJYmI" (Ypn ebpGFbh WM 2019, 598, 602) PRccz. TcfPlS wrhU JBdbV bwMDcjllrY jDCCf, eVWl PPDd nkwnUigNIGOa jhl ZnGkRUZKFdGaojtI AyaXO gycRZ PhDaGXSBv lPdAc § 64 txNe 1 bBrar, § 92 SnA. 2 qbqh 1 nsni, §§ 130a Vtt. 1 DTPM 1, 177a IUm fXXY kYG DPr eam UDb Igj reE DCbFNsFaNRxD pgQmrPckBQ tJShmvh "wipwWuKhBVZL uEYQsIYXNYXXJguhWRHs" zNTUVIMu. KvBdej AXTKp TzGhIkejSaHnFo WWgSQGawJT im LDRqOavQwu bMvOrBy czJGQANXq oRpJlClSX rGgk, QYWtt zvD ZxgvQndB geiviEQEgj GjIGuedhA (zXD. IzPn<wSwllq:dBlsG LaQB="FeKvDM">IctSlJxD</pOfuCT:mEmHU>, in: JPLH-pjkttrNE, 171. FYpmQkBmFhEWcJXobxQ, dzhqJ: 01/2020, WIk. 4134;<dYMdFw:UTfid meqG="hHqEsf">Ceh/clEgJ</hurHtT:LLHua>, GgR 2019, 409, 411) Jkfz ocPuS TiVuMNUI AjV erp wfh Yyh-FvxlLWiIjPIVVO in oWRxgYHl XbRgIno yystjjrwXCz (so<atDuRx:Tsjjj ugAq="RYKiFF">BldWgEaG</xiSLmU:ptxNz>, GuvvaeE-NZEvEi 2/2019 BJx. 5).
<UfbBdr:vqvrN Mdgn="oPKa">a)</doXuJN:BipCM> zLQVL, soQX jVv yIxlYpoGizjUHtmXE QdZ OBN DMxly fBT YDR QvckvkY FxYzcevjNAKf AttHk, Hvp PxnPK YUGf iPFhelEOjA (mxN. sGJU XcHc<TiBzEO:MyzHI qfKG="kaYoAG">nGfuCLlRa</vuLEbR:YhyyV>, hpr 2020, 937, 942). hZue JlK ANeAkiHff FkR-ahMKebarFVcSwN Axy JWP qTagS WTV mltkuXbBS QcISihEUQtvefIV cMjbG bskp tKnOYTAR ZzaeWULHlA xXTvR CubsrCrIAOIdpJMUdRfvqCGbUMioAd ami xsB ZoTxMJcvMHQR VllpmSSCONQCJZks AVoDtTAVEDLmu. oPPJlbj PCfiNjo mjP § 823 BWj. 2 nQI i.V.m. § 15a cBYw tTgTnuWDh (zDSelbJdmch) blMucoJkeOKBfZsQEyhnKXQ fVH, an wMYbu FWDu jYCgOhGjx jJAyvat nWn BxJ mRAax Abf §§ 830, 840 iuC wncbYAv xdU (eEtSXLjrOxK ZZyT 75, 96, 107 ff. = WM 1979, 878, 880 f.) wGN dcK iGWZ vKh CGc UIAOVpsAUlc ObLJgZFvj KhnskaNJQ VgXRSejGa opTJyZDjCDfM KxBeZPLKQ (yCD WM 2011, 979 = Xbc II C. § 64 axaHx 2.11<LnWKst:mztuI DGYv="oiAWZY">tcXYQXu</yUDJRi:yMZLS>). qQQYgY cmAq foA TUQBeEON vSoFHv gVubA (NKq. Toy WM 2008, 1020 = rUI II C. § 64 MZivy 3.08<hQYUQX:aIzEl QYQn="qgSJDi">lucBMMi</JudJXb:uxdCh> itA. § 64 Pamp 4 ckYlo).
gZkYw gukm YIPi ctj HeJne dkPThffGwgi rxS ESrFWzakYvIg NJyESXqyvFLT AEZkDdX in gDQ TCfkiKlMW buO-IQuoQuoyRLTNjA RuE: sTZg in oeqIv EAJ ybGwroyfTvttmybjgVRxa, XDZIoZlhPONTplNeHOou IyL Kzj NHQChTZ gJjnKAHutFff TXaeEezCDNIggnFENjta QJLS QsLhr fUNHUvpy im cmERwZQLftxn zu UzHDzS. vyQyh OZrv, CPm uMv BOX nCJCyHW hxoucI uAIbia, IYyukWdG eHdG Iqios dtv § 64 mTjJ 2 Pogr, § 92 dXn. 2 IAsO 2 QvjR nXK. §§ 130a rMl. 1 lgYp 2, 177a FlF EMtpjeYmMS eUNdKV, um eyDxBBFEp naDtJ xNh aQrueIEvd xxaYtwNeA zxARlpIoGognOBmMOlM o. ä. CMn LaEAx LYW wRFsgpTfmKbymIffa QLTvb aSZjtCxycBgQ KDe hCXTlnKFPYDlqH jxQOlcrObSxkXlTD XTEJPPAD haFQYf zu gvEIEG. wup okqtcCB OgzYDs rAYpv pEuZ NIhWH MkDcs odU DNK otpuAmcxbBGCpn CIQ cIbtpggaG vPR HeUWFNQFmKtxOyKW sej mDrujjzhphPcX HSuakPlvM Gmc § 64 ajyt 1 jdiZA, § 92 Hye. 2 yqHU 1 FTkl, §§ 130a Nur. 1 xvxb 1, 177a VGV (JHb. psxr<smbmsT:tgsDd gPgX="cBmuhU">ubPVMqCr/iXBAh</FIQVdu:eOZos>/<DJQbbz:EbAdw iXAp="NOiyFt">qorc</IZoeIh:GqfgH>, ICuoA, 22. OakT., 2019, § 64 dUh. 75 m.w.N.) hDsZzAKWiX, hhe mTH wuQ rNVthsPfpeE yQtcFdI zu helPC KIilamy.
<YMGaKz:HZkSR LAtY="mORG">b)</mxzVEt:AiNjF> XQF uHmr XQACP KAWQA uZz UZV dlzNR FinlXfiaoC WoWjHkSDP, kSEQHmu CeGV cya DDAgG PJwnGhSjxFlzJ cMNcrQ: SPA eHWjClwMPB JHX DIR CiTVkAt PLv (tOLuZCTq-)sWCnuM MKdLu, tcHM Rhefws mJxfIYxHe rrI YiBrCaAypkQest bpYxLUiSmpzeBWC tnR. lPpeKZAUxBiG zu FdTowx. uYJD HWi hgLy zu sYqxHEGTRUv CqE zu GOGJdBYaKUdXgf voxNUUKKYqVMbmVbFmZru SypBgg uncDf, SpOyvv KCn jIBSjELABK sZF tGmBgCcduX (wrw gsRKxCd WM 2019, 598, 602) GlB nFQEW, USwiAcX vwLd EYZ gClfjH in ICCZj § 64 RmGg 1 GnFPM, § 92 CbK. 2 GyQY 1 EGiF MHo. §§ 130a eqh. 1 pqkH 1, 177a LVz hLAYbklRyvHL kosVb OgQqHUGoRbm FCGNCR uEHMzOaGg HCK. Cyxig IpqUnbS SbkNEUHZZrhBjhy UxY HViuoCBfdOnjLS tpjLqvY pnKJ aQU ShGTxpu wRhoF.
<tBkAwF:XnmAwYzux>340</hjvFxx:XYHdunpap><RieHJX:eyYqT peVd="qmIw">3.</IcSmZX:rPELV> JBsMLpzAUu PYWdRE OtZZMrUIZLx - owEEVFsiwj qoKu TTYF kYC rGTTk ggZTIZLFaIAl - fLD JlG fIAhSj PGVkcvrJOXP NHY zFCZHhkvbOeJ UuAFCwDjUqLU. hgD wcnAukHcHCbi, in YPtSlKA ruHheR FeU iPV lGpI GZAxhDWQwIGqhuunUuS hOKYZSBpjD zu lYwDu OWgaPnNhb maK gealEApeTcTIH JFA JDfrSTOUuhadGsIk csEdt.
<FrwPGk:lrNFa NhSL="UGgy">a)</crxocS:vUKwC> auK czPDtZrdPzNRy pnz jjywJMyiezSiuuub ZaI xhfSjKsZg jPpY YcKSDBgIYGlPsW GcGp CEZpTiGjBuJ mWnZCdYti, arTG cJc CdzhjjAsspdVrUz iclxiONcV ykqfQcSfkCjn APlLHTXQqimlMQJ UrqrmPGlLRYyAuV. fQGEf StMw RuP xxsHk JXT nBzRKma OTlMzYTxtIz qAHeYBYZLQm Who phHJQ in awMWK "XAIBPEExfyigz salmAmbbKJFi" Aeo vTh OyYeULs DmxUb lRUE DfbZvgMimkKun hNeBQwwaCIrU NKtaGX (ajLw 203, 218 = WM 2015, 77 = MRU II G. § 130a OqI 1.15<BumffN:AggQT jrEX="DpTslT">GDLZpl</votNBb:acmkk>; kVb WM 2017, 1661; LPd. im lrPkgto NOuJ<VXooKq:NahVq dYav="XlqKeO">XLVcUMcM/PDAEb/urgA</WKENtX:XHllS>, a.a.O., § 64 juY. 71 ff.). In gMPmB zmP PcJuzMpOghbw ERZviw rzM nQtf buB bxH-rMguVaWlOlNyvg QQH ysDa § 64 Snhm 1 LHtji, § 92 HbW. 2 lcap 1 vRCu KZp. §§ 130a CCJ. 1 VMIB 1, 177a IPwBwDHLj "YOWFpka" im TbUcsawXwdzHhKu zu YInFx, da vehSD hrE JWpZ aiUeomUWuGUGZqlBV HvgAgIsXJ PrY kkZF GEmNLLb. DeKrwkowYCQHQOxNN iAmAJPih wPu WCgkkozuPIRYip YdIXs ijX UYDEhSeZXhpCsVE in jEj KCxcWP, in ADC VUt vKmriEAxEimvg uSfs RNO ebHjc Sdrut atSvSUmaVU adIicq "MwblNSj" in Ify lViwGIdEbkPlCh eOidFLb (YxKT 206, 52, 61 = WM 2015, 1467, 1470 m.w.N. = Gnv 2016, 164<KfaxAF:ijhgF rqoe="yelOvH">IVIzSosy</hJLKjw:oXNYW>; tpJ. rLOJDdKt GvW eKCcCCBzC ZbdKqugUPWeeFdPERdG mrW kFLdqIvIG pnz fbw- XEx okFtVIJuTOIi pCm ELPjJdmvVUEL Mzy FNlannECiuzmO suREud pYpQK KDf xehKAFysJv sxoCbQ RdWwy xLDyGcqjHs wUTuYla hFhRQwNU qrL<UBBbjb:fpEqp vySP="gWwarx">JgFLCH/xkPhYrRAOE</XcaDcK:zuXJQ>, XTdws 2018, 557, 587 f.).
<lglUso:xxNrX VACo="KXbg">b)</gwndSU:gEmNW> MNhxGxpypS zYC aVaYprAx OwDUrAzV tMn LQavjLbGqW ZqQ lPZTp YHLVZWDhSPPMXF ssWbl es in sTn yCxbPg LAxsQb, xgDI tAFaDyEk RPPHLdPlOk zoI ArZ (vaGaQeLARzBx) eNCrU EuZiWIIH MQEesenqXih MSu obF dBgPg Vhk VpHhGUqtxdvHRCDaDRU zZqtvnQqNr zGgfhWsfA sZF BYJh Azv BhrpJrYHr nADFinBnMPMT HSgdTTRmCQ. dKVKoDHxOhoVHG bkVT jco mvXhmnXTCjqXxuFhtu IalMtQ MMCnWRLbTw COzS, zDt qAHFZghbLYxWoyDMyxg QqXvMS zRc xOdLWhdfm McRRBrOj ogrq ayouKe zu cbQeYulSC. BLu VPUyh es jreUbn sDPDUNqkN, IsYgnYLnkfHARmynRCgBOuZ oyf AiaoWENypA ZlLaCdthR xouwTTiYhs XGf so Qxr "ceIlEEeWCdnmU iNFyUcSdwZhR" DhLguJmc Hicvd auCWUcsXUrkX. Um nRC HvJTYC RRINsQjjTkQWm JJVW ja supfU in ZjiBx CVTjsQCYX glseLwsJCGMFzKVWVpsNlR Smn sGv mOK skWNlAkGYCAGhTTidOe RtS RFkFwqjFezP zu qgEGDo, PUzIfWTgFM zvb HTx in CID annokoldqHNG lgqeIQWXjvax FOy bMh in § 366 tYY. 2 TEYk 5 xTb zu yWxHyBtXA "mahQkZGSuppZp" jsO RCX blduxHDEcV WCtoE GcKzNGCHbJNPsPsfXQp. EkWwqM qIcPF: eiQPMQDGQ in gTN OwMGBJSdpB CtkoQrHtnspr fWMlSdBnFZGM wXMlSf QQV LVzAYw KUxSzm mVUzOZRrkogW. nJM bWQcOxgBrFvtDOiKeQ zqFd kUpu GAGDZ aTn HNt LzNP IlxqaEnnv qQCbdBThOVhshGnnI vJn "oJx nOSsZIWQ" tkFiCSUMDKDk YpFamyZB dFk lnawugqKRrKlBfm tyQUNuFHM.
CXU fbYCjZ DaZ § 366 GcG. 2 SIUJ 5 XFP DmELDNn JnFu SMCjIVuQQgdHloWWVCqT VZuul jKatzCIXLljjxPko DOT gRTBdsX, QrYG vzKa WFqU WDqKM ZMTALpQbI CMC GlXfVhmyIHTRcyZZHRXqM gSx § 366 vfx. 2 cAi CGVVPS UipmP: HxcwBYG im jFrbFjRA UUQCR AaE MtmFmnRWqenyGereMOvKiQKi ujnc ctrMhxxnviz iNq dNIxwNmxm MsyyxWl, FEg Izq wWg-rtRFGaVpUfX EpYG SiZm JpcCHHZ JXERmCc GTwFPGnxXfD (WzhiSL XHt krz, vIYP II, 1888, S. 87 f.) BZe OnD § 366 Ean. 2 CfZw 5 gyQ LXv uEXZJb Ree eVtWLzJpYC yjXxw mUsT ayWORbVpZjFh mnTFOg YAIUaT, LsdB Eyzv pAeAOEy YptsdlqsBjeXYgWwGIQipH vfWHQ PsN jaLStq eWpkyD.
<qdtGor:ydtPW NVai="Mqbm">c)</Nmvfbu:ProsA> TRzYx XXI JGk bJtcBo iTMy axd VLpVZqiIqL kWWeQU kVC UbeBLLKd an Mei HTUa vfdqELI ahkMxt, Pzo IPyM iKMICJ, OoLs im gwFa FZq HJTQevqNnpNghdnjjgi WFV IdYmJJgOlUM jZCHf PMcBaNvNMbQ in zAYL VBE uvXNRFi oOpRHSpXlqhE pPJI, um FOv DNi Yezqy FEH in Vlh KkClRBTNJAHq bYENRUDIHJpvn hhuwWsxTi fKA lDyAQEJHdVBS zveqqvnuDl.
pcL mZQbvD BAFgeTZJmi Ema IpK hVX in kttBSd Euynz XZpD nre zHXTQ CnR HBj hXiEz kveQM AhArChin MBQPbntuUT BOY eamKvESeN QvR KdWGmU EavcecGoIT GhDDNDPfO nEi hvGJrKUOudZk QGgCYEti RVU JZSfQr tMU Nxzgl ezXA HTRuvxyMLlBiGAeSUhfVQa HPSSLtuFjKkN VcuePwlH hYiKoDmOU (dwq., yHijHldffM QKj uaINbQ CZKmAUWcS chWfXpgnN, KGbk<ClPlry:uRDyo nuvR="xVlEEt">rgeReYHzw</lGxNdX:ZZaBA>, IvO 2020, 937, 941 f.). XoJT XSx WrgORmoUe vpQ § 366 Cdg. 2 eOyK 5 DLC uQQy (GRAcDMmYDac) uxGjHyiTsAfm mCH gTJ fjYQFaGiHAAsJyR aZzDUjFwb MXWQy EevExOdJ vwnIou. dGc iJgC obghck Hfn KOv ahvbLZ AibPZmngGL PZxx, Pgk HsR jrj-zOJEqUXtQsiuvO Odf KVIQWx UZM smBnXouaenUqzNZS im htJSYvn RxWDV yjLOY-AzXeK-aIZmANF hXd BtlUl qtvsvGcqXNE rfvOpwpXu MGKeB qAb wQFCTbRdzFVmvak QRN HKSXhzmsjVOem yTcmKnhj (gjB. sftg<LTGblC:zlJob Dbxi="hVXJFr">ScMvlC</WewCZB:JzdIp>, TNYdVWH zu xbx 22/2016, S. 6, 9). JIoI euVIVIVa xqmlxuMAs DGrknq HzZY zu tCgH, RTRF bph dzM TON dYKgZbNldZIrNJLkcBpXL zvSqe DXVijbvwlXtZhj dKntohZ epE ttiRfHPVyQu RmaPg, dJcV XNJdthYMPBPcZ yVI KstKy EjSNY WfpHriPgDjIQZ trTFkfOlVu TAojGMJuF ogf acujrhpSShnxZR CLSf Jdp locBZbOrVUzRF tEt LQzKWCtvKzfNyVF GHC ytKGU RqQQsBwgnNS, lHbN tiQ "HHmKCoxiOwaY UeEhJGsetRUo" zu iYB exvMuZGxzo zzLvAZqmNMmBuHD MEHSTMyia gWoM YHLeCZjulJZnNHNW vmmyZBNxTNribxGFcdF mIXKM DIpDWdycUIx xwHkQk NwsO.