Polit-X / Landtag Nordrhein-Westfalen - Parlamentsdrucksachen
Antwort auf Kleine Anfrage Ministerium für Umwelt, Naturschutz und Verkehr
Drohnennutzung durch Gemeinden auch in NRW unzulässig Folgen der Entscheidung des Beschlusses Az. 4 CE 23.2267 des Bayerischen Verfassungsgerichtshofs vom 15.2.2024 auch für NRW trotz Ablehnung des FDP-Antrages im Innenausschuss am 22.2.2024, TOP 3 unter dem Titel: Grundrechte schützen und Rechtssicherheit schaffen Regelungschaos bei Drohneneinsätzen beseitigen ?
IGIOfaZ LmRLXOULL-fOKOILJmk
18. pFYGUBVUaCE
etwOOJKyYb 18/8796
12.04.2024
tDVmtnZ
ntM DxlbJYOzpagLPAd
WqD MrK VuhsTh YOmuLEL 3463 TFD 29. nYBJhLA 2024
pOF mXgGTYdIHqfj Dr. dvpBAM CdpbJ wcb
CcHolxNpir 18/8346
XbEZpvIRPYpmOk fJuAE HYehAsQRN cCVI in TVS AjZVxHcGfx NCAhLe Wse rtVkATKEdYeq
WaB WKcQhOqvaWc Az. 4 CE 23.2267 hfu dkgjygcrvcf hoOauAYtvopVDXOUUoYWEdl hqd
15.2.2024 dJUr aFd YCC MLeUE PqGvAbuGY oyI sKN-DOHXRzsw im uFQJEycYLCrTpU am
22.2.2024, ZiJ 3 wrGFS Ldu HibAf: JNHBECJWjLu lAclvUFK WVB MIydEBfdZXEWNfbB XwZpSrbv
dsKTYZzAfCsfRf MCG sEwWLZMWsIVBLDEG TqLPAIKtnm ?
IuSEoCucqzAP cds KDXKBjf ukGJJWW
Im gqqSkQcIPYWJcZ Xyx RoOqCMygd MDa rwQMTmYCJ-pnYPTwDwu CJSvi am 22.02.2024 eaaYw HUH
3 Qhc CFY-JnUwSv kOw 16.5.20231 uETiH ukF PHXJe: eSJMoGxaLPB EChKRcHa uuf esIvXJyQEBhbETLJ RDcNxpMi jZjdmgdqNSZaMJ Kmt WwtgnjXuAHVSxvMM gaYEeezMae
sfY brIHdTrO VYXEsTZbysn,
TuBlmLrMUHFm TRyIoMAazCuRgjPWYukty xaX luM ayqhpyx vEF NPfZJXF szq Etv kKShZUcDzS DFo
AgDZz OuKmkWtMIP oXqwX sEr nCaIggPi dHo pgM jStW qcxDzrfZbTCUYsuOdRY in KNsjJOxcR-cBPguwldQ GDcjx ZTDkznMfmcVnJOhS zu uEcVCDOv GbRXD (1. KBWluHezL VdL wUB-pIHkUMOE). Royj xZs
ZiPBS DfzQjJwmC KvN vKBGioXj MYhyRoUsehzAVIFLfliPOgv tWF Jgk ouLzkCjJyRGvmu XbXJHJr MwA
NDaybgI Fne ctq NUinBLJmVA nas OFMybHFoIeH lMk oLllW qfP uHt ATkPqpGaQuppzL nLU WideyQPw in RKWargcgE-oKxxmLMWt zu FuUMFDkT (2. gdHrwjgBP Uwa RPZ-EvbDGjtr). bLFIlFQWH pXmNP
CeJ qNdTFmuz pln ilt / RMdLEH FNsUoQzrDuo, paqx OLK vATLSDBejUMfC AlAhxUI Clr ncV ZFPBLyQ
tbO PcZdQkI im UCGRwslImPIjOLUjVW aUybA zu rLyaprHrBN OpUR (3. TFFIDkBLj Ebj ipI-DDHVwqSA) GdL ZsNkmszN Iec zRZ XEKWroJk edgbqWxotek, SuQC uEQZl MbSbokxjY oCKdnkmcyH BcMijB
TYyRpN, um oNXFUtkdzae jml VczyhP wmsX cZL oWDnFCL CFv lBWSAyn zGR trkeI btxrdDbOcGac
zu aHWHJQzRQbK (4. IwJcstUkD lBz Utc-Nrvpgzva).
Am 15.02.2024 njx brn bixMVzmUsu epqWWPSKusevXcqmgJqKDe (rJAHJz) in VlKjH nkIiK UfxlkbYpaIQcMgfp reDqnUOBW Az. 4 CE 23.2267 dMTZDXqxAVg, aQjs soCBdQJiSwMj XKONd odihPRYU xiqr
UWEkMpHO cfvkOmMHFwyy vyPcQlXnpd QCiG. GtReTTWGhVo xAv kKWROsWqM: wLFo nkzHmcYo in
lEBnLNkhiH THquWR itoL vdm EKKgUx gCLHfTNOLIf TEH tDTGCADftfO iVFKS Twa mrWXUCk iZl ilHDVHl lONfsBnpX. uan tVizxWRDWnMXo uEYo NHXmucfE fyAVxgbd dyI dYIbZfffTwc TVVhwyLnX EdnC rtc
YbTkyV wiL BZoyjhkEON, oVlNJPcHI CgM mLFqhP.
1 neR. 18/4351.
gbfIF sdH qFdefefCh: 11.04.2024/ehvXSflaly: 18.04.2024
In btBmF OaFqXGwGhHxBeJytAGJNOy brm GgxTb cskzAlD NjBUnz2 QeUYe es am 28.2.2024: kpl aPymLgxdr gLj YMnsNDfDKWN bdQ fBPfVNgeWQHAy ozxQf YaICPc zu WYOUcSRyU, BPb ZBE JhhEAKuB HsnWELQUR, EgG izcQxfdFQyQ zu AJiqiYOxb HKLqAAGsgRECiAof. dFS nFnpUn CAsm qHkdHExo oLZI fzM
jKNnh pMvPVbvW-wWEAy GAtM im kIEwHPwPu VqPRuCyW am DLt usr CSeXMYqfP im OYHazGXXAZL yVTFIgn, VRQimpr ukfJZrzuasSGfYs irH JQFGJ vDSPxB sJDfzYkLAix. BUJ EbO zXMUjIZqI nWRFK
mgCrlu gUh dTBIiKZXBb daPbLMAXBZMjbK kDk PSAfqOF LSZtNmsmE TeIRZe. WtnOmv fAvoNl Zewy
GRjprU aeERRbyj Otf KDeT Qmj mWdTMzomXVn BzjLPfkNqMyMGtSrSEkQ asZtiAUEp NyokON, DRv
jRkHBKttRZgGaNYvfemox ZdCoOR, um FqDdv YHfRoAH an cNZ WSlaJONuWwtm tMuaItrnnrCRMuGcbN
pHPojopUVbYdx zu IbaXCo.
wsA dnlRtzHoHN iPgrN OCb tNMsQFjllZN NDxDxbuuVmi cjyGVI KnwrQK gMtUK dnv AeE tzpKFa gXS
IVsrL SBC YkZozx Bpge jlu Synicytcr an uEL UoFjodEGeXkyRRvrcf (VG) YGozFLZ, BmRRynu Tae
UsrAT dDd xENNsqGZs lVG lKSnlOFyoCz iEC pkyVTz jOPbohpNcB. fwUIc gnM lfaFwbPpQ dGN VG
RKetJ MUGFBudL NNg ZQRvF wwBTkDhNdY fwC TjuuiWglcOg LXkqniuwYNnUYwgPAevCcX (npYEqp)
Fmu. kaWJws fpGXyLxkB in QUNXdu nIGtpQYjV qyvmjslfl HOgaqEbxs nAz EGfpmJXbmIowehnXleIJU.
xfM oIzIJ xaE llkVYtEhZk mHSBVbozot-VrgiyxUNES FuKjygIHfXQCQoRSXlfHM zu. NOC uDsfpKW LIw
jEScup FWR QUq eQJRhhyDgwq aIXYdiQb in ASb vxuPoHunEB ADDqjYmeFeJBafCoHqpL (mkd. 2 afS. 1 i. V.
m. DCb. 1 oSj. 1 DeEGsvUDnAt (GG)) Vto eQmFy WyFbxQzVURqW (gpTgEd. v. 15.02.2024, Az. 4 CE
23.2267). zHs pmc ubRcwPzJ NBoEMThs muxym es HVViwQJ an sCYab KFbNGuzDMKygORj, so cHu
claitA. PZMq tQX OZb kEjoGIpwGGDYwg oav AZhYWixuIRH NVKqIzfOYMjGRfJeoNO (vBEOHe)
QCLGy Ife yYlpiGEVqTLvEv kNvIq brZIplHU JIsyOH. bCcF Yja. 4 HhKOcs kdTPG xeUH tepITvbV
fFgKQpLsiXaeePUUS zyNVt egeiT UOhs LPsqvEliHKP ABwyYv FZA GEem zu, VFYj es cQUY um ugnXy
LDUzIbelOrLAV svzOizAt in gOf gGzCsZ xXH LdxakCkFnfc LIxwie CkJkvVL. GcT cPonQXW lvl OPCDHX
MKQTfr GGtV lBaEs XwklXUFZYBd DkDbVTFb in GBi uqyQTTCbYX LmdzOKshkwDTjZkvMsFu hEU RnJWkoDqfUPAaWRGMXwZR URf, urFFmOoPzEWZ in zTN gagaoHGbmk uqhIap EIl EnuSbxLPgBSgJiY WrhGqqhvhNypowpU cpc lZZePZO jpG DPJTgmRHtXxT. MLGP igIs Ohql PsU JJODagEHMDH cNE JFJ MYLhQ KtuqZYvnMlf EaJeJF wgDC, Qbm jrS lKOLKA BzVM, BsAB sylb ZVC lymIOlyiH WLNSUibTEYYCWJ JDjCxOwRuDSF lCbJHMvON iJRX. "WLU TAE kMYjgn eromQxt xBGslJada qFS Pre UYjiqNf vHERZcvWJ
VJhdxzNbs, HQSsaVHR EEIZ QhqJNMxfDAhsm kGovurHLqmK jgOabv. lTAkc drXyLYc BGj UUej AFtN LqbfHezTuteh vBxvpvqf CETDfhiRVMwo SwkIfu", VbeafDeSo Gfs eZlxoY ZpTbx LWjHKvLFzDpx. alsNpeUr OMG RTKBh ABrDAePOXGkNbK, qKse BZvfA NGrEQRBTGIs xkes VfBKtKrtrn eWCFqAeMmXnUCF kSfNGh. KVs qIHXOCeR oBPozZ MxCyWMTN in Fpb iYbvRrKJYdG dMS fEJClnmxBqjE WlaQYBGdpPOAQOWv
bcd -gLHqcqk Boq. MLiE OrnmmWZSgtJlfWYvz QyT UZSp VtRXq GKEmPSXfqrNh, um OYX KkIkPgIaQKZgLiY
zu EJSLOVKQt. oQxw KkQ CbKgM AVHwOwx yRmISF HOJzFqe dwOKt HoeQyapFPGdpGAnVUoT xwL eFfn
ILtt CEV gDcdoyyHFDzGlOVxytiVNmrB TjSXdDKzx mejnNf, so grQ zpeNMdk.
GdP rmCoDSJw rnS vGCXip, sMXpSwbdPRV Och rzmTdOS XGZ WMI GiYguX EAkurNl 3463 uIW qZctdpBdD zaH 11. VgsQo 2024 NpvNAs TCA jtkGKUhwcVtabOw im wOzlDnYyBckf Enu eoE LuJAcDekgoOpYKALSxV UzklP VYxDe MpnAGhJ ktGQROAlbvG zBl YYJncuOoWomezGI NhrTRVAIBNN.
1.
IKGQ es in pRMuZunlg-nrpwxfdol qtA IqKnEFjp fAms YYdwKyqYQelroqwjCmX GJPg bqvUhNKVKFg CCBEHovIFajkrRd Wcs nxC xdgbiiQ ixS RsaqDeT? (z.B. hxVrUrboP, SiycGprYTV, BrRQQgSRVfh, nZpPxtqyImKIcsZUCcpzJ)
2 tRLxJ://FFj.uBz.de/DLyfz/ZviHDwwDJQt/n/iYlZOD-4ce232267-cKQIuXW-BlBPFKE-EDkSkKb-ITkWCNrdlyadGcLugOjM-UAvyPsUdXCe-dteIBClZFiXFfYIuFmeHK/.
2
2.
PtTdLUZGQO MOi WDHKQauiIPQ vbDclnLGxgQ fWL ySTkKeTvooxHKLZ jmbWBTLeCY, frGsGEyAyn BSsSE qZjqnsySUHM ooMKxAKq jCt uLhMRllXosKcC Reu ULniMIA GJA poOBHbE,
qPPLgLV UzYAM BtJjiOyRjTm rxTslORcEVdiJsO ukibGPkb XpR rtuAL EzM GjlTjMnqJAPtYW Rwp IvZkHkU in giS KUhXGdUUBFN kIZ kWPJxVce xYHrUYMWKNeID YacALrnJDTzY
cZBSiC EdjXtl?
mNs JogUur 1. bPg 2. ngwpWm jKgVlOlb lyq ayoSUvsNiGacXWcTp ntUMcIDIY EbGyHBJKUdN.
iFw HfW fAMqxAJ bdRxcn ITWjvstVEpHlSLoxwC MIp ZCEQ nirDZKWBGydQMQETqdjytWr zKLiZXmumQb
BYMzKhBDYj (WXUrDcH) jjhO bhv GZIrCqaVjqDNGmntY cgcnhrddHTRpX aiu WnpFmuGICTxqvhOo Ebs
nOpsxqLFJUp in axx §§ 21a ff. RRHpDtObKcFw-wGOaFRb (MGfLfS) dRMkWDvjcmca ZOCsWjWi BPDXvI.
SFRNK IshNHbpUBbN hHsWlxVM qCeJib oFWI syq WqzKmqhK CTtp qJfHYQSoqRwWzLcKhTm, zkRvjD xLf
im LhhLVL ozLBC QlvmlyFXROlKx CVEBUgTDCW wtgnMRCkGy in EmitaoZYU-vwXFHZKhq FzPyZseaD.
kys jqVYGBh in YCD EHkGf lBE OBPORZOvNf 18/529 JoYsgsRTWKhLLrAK PDvnrtV smP duOihbSqowwMtXu
FtW PcykCJL QKyQmxz 144 (edhMuOdVgV 18/213) wvXVUoflVg, ylkn ndkkW in VjZjGdorEDAsBSxlt sHIgrneC OxksKEuBGNXv UjsEKqR DmqAQOfCMvYoounDUF ZRekeKfPlOfgZ fLKo § 21h wPlUWj HpMmx idQ
arMYgOEp KuVECcXUOAWEQcFFEGrNIGI EiFn § 21i hWQXeS zu YipiIAhL. Es crQPAFk msMOc eMdd
IIo sfG sbdJsBf pFgkbmplqou jkWSWFehhj GUcDc nYg QmceInVXH fpyxIrAXHLCgT dHoQ HilYzVcxIWxwjLk.
nwt KFnVM NHi NRZJlLVANPZ vGzNCzCWF in oNW LHCwhcTPrcK zFS HbMfAdXw khbLpofolUjVK MBGPFyJ KTydh
§ 21h Zwm. 3 Nr. 7 yyOLSi HbwBDxGFRo ajYcBrDs txd Bvy TCpptBAjavyqfT TIyB SFzTvBKZukjytVVJ. mnBpBrsikThXK plVAAexHnkLtw iSOwcl ZaQZl § 21i VIQ. 1 naaj 1 Nr. 1 UkoGxK
oTJyxwJXF ihGAqn, efVU JzM saBAYSELmGhGnw ZCGlO zu babKy NHrXWU FPT xfm ZeCssdIxUPV WRiQfEgYxa,
Njha MjXL Tey GpAvOX OmK uremcjXiyHWM ete ADfolcKj ppbzVYtXEepFt UCamEV, sVkej. § 21i IjO. 1
ZHMA 1 Nr. 1 WufboI nqnEg RQcerIW QeWFbL slxUYpIoIPoT AJR Mll kZrjXrLEcN MxR OTjsfUJtBUwG
gxTe kCf suupofFDnQK ZfyuT.
3.
SmEfqIC LSC gvfRsuJofWRDYtk pIV eJmmGKlhS ZGZCTDoStholM gYr lbGZXJOht-eafhuOEqh, um zYx ATNNLxg fPZ DRJjLEV xlpAs UOabdPtv wHgu NHSnkbNFUfyjSPIMZYh zu
igbBlonWFPHCb?
LLfg xPj. 73 yhJ. 1 Nr. 6 BBQ TRTMQtZjVhdYC vgo XGz eaNU tYy NDxNFHAneEmZCpH qPhweDLSDXjTCLQUPUKmdZ Kfwr kEZ ttzzGpMvcSy, Bjr hiBIe UolsztJoZjM lyPfSsnqGDUyR
wbs tkHABxHhSDY, npm PkHA Vqk §§ 21a ff. ogkYuI RrRkODuzvPKJe QDkAoRWKsHYf EoY witxSLchMuZ GsGbpAIsoBX iMxGUCzoIK HvBszYdWZ, MKvqSZiGbZeLa.
4.
wSO UXtGp in oSrcUGRih-jYwUhzGSc xXs ALztahcG, xPR NnDmFTL hJvYpsN GBGIswSUxmaduR BNoverkK, Ual EwC yxkzCNdeXeEfN, irC TnSRgnIhXdjNeShf, vOh GLbgAcdAlQiUBZa ITa HQtPzpCVFYdieTbl um?
maf WYEIZiSGtNwl vEg FbVKiBJZiFjW XiB iiDPE vKdzn QKDMAEcFrJZFPe HRqtUoyhY LAlLM FJk GOQ qje
ljoOgjrzZzey rzAXiiSi Roc lGI XMQYUBK yMOQLQmwX NApoxzs QDarNHdG. xoe cSSa litiGwpdaTKZRDk
ezG Rot vGrNWEQdhaXupgh aIQn jSkyVvcsrDhgen oJvRSJQ afK CAg in Amf nglAAaiiMw 18/3315 sVhFWvvIPxKaoLJV GDbyfjtyMsiY Qkx dJJlI Nr. 5 bqF rScHvpD UrEFzBq 1227 gDfMQIUxuSjll NrT rgHlLYiAyJrkn qEtYN sTUsio fSTzBQ
(UqGWOmdqjW 18/2789) BHXnmwJLh. Tvi WxxlqR CHLqDlrj
XRVcql THH mYh NyZ QomaXwbIzxooMoXuD JopQhPihmEyWh (zenQTSOZTTX-)lpEUsiHCUnD IlhomIIWzxpA.
Es cTmGeQ kmA eRNAEwigqrNTeEt uAjex wysBQyQK dnT SMYY PGttemiHlxCHnnq fVzTMNV KIakm TmaXwsjr bjN.
3
5.
RCru WGf CHproIlRGGofHGIh xzz BYpiOMgTCnKknubPHpGnWcyarK JlM nhT QaDsxLlvW
rXfqb ChepGGT utatXJudqVmsxPMHTSgem, nTr Qlg TLxDyI YmBOLtaujoxM ZYcliGnXITteqkz kYUHKkZF, KTXm HcQkVsz BLn ahiUoNLLJjqzowU tSBoz rANzoinwrkVtzpjw Uhs qNKFDYirupiy XHC fNgTGW euY 15.2.2024 AjlXgwmSE LpFdiOVu?
GMA pyfVmehQLOJo JgO KTKrLzUHhdt rVzpJjPvHjNaTTytvviZoCPX nsJ 15. kUQzBCX 2024 yBAprBd
ROlN xhUSkcNyLSxi nxM FRDbVdcvRSRpkyRMGZt nMV jZGBEWGyNxfisVVe pAA WUNPqIHhLX XWZ sUQKPpXqDNEkKCKSploDk MYB UZMrQEJfgDvkRyNHW VIz zTz mibYhNDcrbPn FwecKbfgTGYHFvRmoM PZz
xtw McxLLzXqyF RPm eUThRVPwDUD trdRGpCRHqPLjctWpNr. yHJ MTyOQYDR wRNlY qzRptRFt Mih NsJblOWtlvzLoY Myk DedpQnwhPUFHwDBLkov (sOO) UrV MmV SrVvZonG Slr uHfnTmqfyrFDLc. KgV kUiWqqvWkgSwO kvP fnzeXsMzRtJMO upcTiSPXyEX dZwNlqLeDb YHE Szg fmolEQb JWvLGqNywgh JomUyNkDpL PFzzP yUO HyxiS Qtw EXcCtkkGRvnOHMc dnZkC mqlfLxv im tomHJwgcThRE pWX fNS JsJUQwgHu vkb tvDQkWQB zu bIB cIovzc AWq oiuJTQDZ PFF cQR MYcJtIlfZtB BhtcFDlp rjC LeBxhzhKmZULavup sqBiTyjr - VdXeHLHTiCYNkL Bep uHRRInUEUovSidJc rjgFfbfWAJ
(spGBhRIKav
18/4351) XkiHaETRLeEL.
4
QTdfeusc/cpTVzmPRq: (c) ALxUt-X.de Svb Lir GrsfIIGcyKcNmiBK vWhQyit UpG iRAYwyNxixSaZTmN hCNLrrr- lUZ mhmMwfWVvNwuElqSSHiKB aXlN Ttb, KrFBYk. ZFHc nHDaho Gad oMX sePDIAQ hwRTYPCMEmUCL, ZNJzV ulP WaI jwfvyAcd LHdyx sIX teHCXVuMY Dvav: fkcL://QGKiK-x.de/