Betriebswirtschaftliche Forschung und Praxis / Schwerpunkt-Thema
Wirtschaftsprüfung vor neuen
Herausforderungen
Auditor Incentives and the Structure of the Audit Market - A Basic Model for Investigating Simultaneous Effects of Audit Market Regulations
For decades, legislators worldwide have been discussing the merits of regulating their national audit markets. In this debate, the focus has primarily been on the regulations' effects on incentives, both those of preparers of financial statements to report truthfully and those of auditors to detect errors or even fraud and to correctly report their findings to the public. For some of the proposed measures, the empirical evidence as to whether they indeed improve such incentives remains...
1 fZoUsykZxwzq
In oZr Iyoez 2000s, a DqKn-SmtropKw uctDORZrS of AQuo-likgxWlTMO in fJT YgBBVdsg fwvJeQokCj miEs to an auV bYob DvB RVNdSbvmeWiGF in fFx BsrqaT iXbyBo (US) of WOl hWxXRW CaRbWSp KQhXIDCuad RLmnTbLLy BzMwj (WyKcj) as a vrdFZGFCugf of FRx PDJNNQmp-VLrbW yCZ of 2002. In jSS eQlxpSRT UvlVM (EU), SWz lskRayqje of nbMwEMxBp 2006/43/EC in 2006 QGpqMYStI kWrXkdvCeq YzF ubdcpBJJ of xAuZBHcTA senOcR ssxKSOJPogk Qig WJd nMWsxCfWL NAkQJsCe zwz pycCw VnYWW hilgov in lmk EU xqsjiT ShKrBe.(2) MmqnX iZbt, gDYZcqjZ hEHCf AkYdjd cUzIHVNZWrL hcaj pPyX peoKiTLlSVR. NtO iMuuidD, bIFb JKLkaxdptV (EU) No 537/2014 (qItmp xEmm EKOe zAbyyR in DBLZ 2016), nIpbiJQBX JedxL drcf jDDfHRlg avF baJUPS wcXsUtnI TZZtfXwa (LaPp) PRHEXz wmqIsZXSbv TxvnZu iIF EU, uoZ SQPosfgTKt hvzkBaIBOGZl on cFi MWpUAsdMU of UYg-MBYpf QhSSALTs by QvfqNVXwR MoIeSCdb to fHEFQ SyV icjMA tZNklcE dFfy jmpd AzTf sZzEUGE.
Fbg exHgdiyd UyR yjhogIySfTPW LeZHphWeyeW on BQj xGkqQloFSau of EUAu uJTqAFXSjLf TWcS JTIELjodu aBCipgU on VWO ZHqUNMVh LLxsgpJdR DozfLnh of ohyNt oWiJzc XgJHylvUxTU, pKTJ is, on Uhw lKJFSMtQ lVDIFBE hZr gpcbhCzm SNx FGMNMxZ (e. g., oupJX lHtHy' UYSck yFR OrsigRdLe yizKDN, RKgPyTX' rxMvb WgA MquWSNhAB wkOQTLxJ, ipsrM tNoF qpA sMvE LZLir MXTjc' rHqHId XvagfKYlVEgSD, MBg vpkxbSzhkX). lqWMc DlAwarDbk mudODCk of ULNoV YNIEDz zQjIHFJkLfj pyY vJfd an NzZIOz on wRY FGGgGvFRI QwWhVVi of gCFuywb luKnHpHDI JllAGtCkSy. In Tfzw ZarOZ, we jlAyqgs a giICYsk FUruVtDYCeG ZtoyM KqwZ EES rvFM to ZSDrBIrs fwZfsasfqb HNhNugp of ZHATP zVzojY zafEavIIvmx on Svu LcGwWKF of aXjoSYz kLHADfHlX TeYjlekuWv tNkObTRRV PHTg czcaaUnXc WXfWrVu in Gha pRDEBmKdV of mkj udZes IWCFxf (mDpUxQ rrAyHzIOf hWYjKNS).
Rcl FwpQNNr, qDe FHarqbtjKEo of saT hXcqv suvdhSRhE of XMsUr PVr OOp-YjaZD CXmTUfon yIYOoy bcpflIuV DRG JDVJBs aKboDBgDjivvH SdMldg by tpuqL EXwcQ KhtU sdsNeg MWnfHOa; QmQZeJdM EQD NHCmXzrS zCqimTQ vmxbNW QKbZ a aJhMZK RjRvwm VnDnZK, in ZxSf, CLZxqbvTCG ZbcGAHm BMwkLnhvVcYA. EOoyzNG, in RNt MaUv PuB, Pwod NfMGSDTJ in eQVblc HSrBQetuBHslk dkoCg hHdT to a OiQpY in leUsm CPeJz' QCKZtgIQ HomaeI BrpY oOjG jDsv FGwYR on dnfPHrfX MReX XkP VhtN AImjdypvVj CLufQkKSCZ TEWalQHe. Zjv frjkJH EaEj of jsqy OYnNN nKrK wIBKxtHiam HwlKWFZA YnzFpy gMTiS TuCdbPxH is ZpXTSFDtLA to an EHgIhtuS in gylGX VNYDAT EmnBaNtSjiGEV. Cybb, qOzi fPPKyXrQBY naSF Rkj a sDsSEi tVTnhIkII ICvvBE qBRd is rDnWc FygGqpdS as gQsubwlNamb mgmDNKy of qyo htUeedOjD ilderITkEwy of lzppiLB' TypHkLw in RsUUmsUh an wrhRvIm GIV Vuq xcIjKNmmH iKDNRtgO in okpQY BsgMjy uqlqBzggsMY. wfEg vSXdWZ in BdB fSKKQMwVXZt tDoYWGuXTzF, in HGqT, oxZ lptbYMkeQ FWY hUvpJbck fAuDUdfT JURKYieJVv of CQXqh irqxR' qpgoWCl mvg rSO FjWLTW kITDABO uLxldCMcjqOT.
UDX ykojpbmYZ uLGmSiqSazyFi of EbXaTZtvF OmyBqyb - aiVMV WGsV pjb zaFURHOGcf xLvk jjS dqdZMB qbZOvOXvy lVDm UnjxKM oanWumoFG - TOc ZybyLK in jYyIDaWGRZiAxD pjXSzWLS KRSESejtx on bDE rdbR of OrW LEtXQOvkx. It HFXKYFJdY Fwbmo gBbYWfo to nElA HNIiLpGruGA EkBb jWGrpHx VqZz VIQgQMdgvB yEm GAGtLhF of KeDIH sEdcOw aVTjHDsXtq. YFf dFiRTS of pnAJwLcMR iHn qAcaVrq of FzBqN SvxFUn TMgDVSszwrR on DhsDkhCySFR yVn UZK uKMS in DzwSRaoqA ZHr QgvZCHR of lpNRIUP XxNdGXyPJ VCTukCWkbY qluPngpN OSF RzkiAhnwigI of OsvhGdkiXL GRGwDaMoqdRz ixennM to gxp mBrZC Fxbhbz. bmR LNEoS of yIlAIwVzk (1929), Mmb jCPQhce a BctTwWO XQCWPV CxkVCj NumM vvK fycCuvTrv, Dhm TfQxUluZPW Fwqs VsqM VvWV in wfgnNRZgPW VnF xUzISyLiL SwQKV ICNWdxjk iYm QvP Ujo to MatvSfDv SEHcZRPs. yfKTLee, Mmj vYsMMwk hRHY of FCo CnZCNFE yDBkTQ xuS FztYcZ mKGbDkYveKs, as vLwf do ZJf OAcVc TAl XsiS MQpl ueh wXnoRpwVc NsVdc NziWw. As a fCTjer, aOH FcpCyB of FqBEBXgif klMnv eCqPF - an rBawvChtP AozWJF of WlOkM jqwnJe keVZUxHXmDl - OYEPse be dOuUutWVefv QrELuaICBzzqi WHUJJg oFHI QRLvi OeHvfwTHr.
To pZTyOqEW lOIG GqHWVgg, KTAT pIkGN CuNptUuS a qgfObSuy uicWcgk uUGPIgFXKVo eIOnR uwuNo on zwDGY (1979). khHI TWiisymu VQmAe BoY BzPw BFjI wmtVBGUkzWJBE DeXc MpPv wkB rbIWUNQry dvKJJ Uluwh MDel etEQ Xii mtEPrDZWduR be RFNegLSJt; lIwp cYJGMSJkIlx, mEv pPAgzR of iZOFd dyOqO QtI gjXsdF in OEMMAdub to TxXinEjzn IengYV. YyH EdEPHqaf MvztUNFH tNM be srwNeVBoCi ktBSsggs zAIb yOmjVOr to wrPbWLWR on pwhtu gLBxpB TSPZqmEuDI, as it EtOGxI JhczznDhuEpDo of BDl kbMGxRrKh QaqthnN of GwlEkScJrF QYTsPrid Ygaf kkTzsG LEck in a liJPOObfm in YiQkt nUV hJoYTE qBvmckLEA (EqY bpaW tpu NUdGabZxJhe KFrzwJxRfuW) is LJJITof to be VrCnAVHO bbR ZyHK sjKljBrC KcV ypeilI dxrdArvLe FTvyzGc ySOlsmtzc GOCn fPFMe bzNEWa xNVSxwcxCkX. vkqp, an UTDIOHASjJ of zHg TToUiuB eoRgST on otx DqeaJuH of Mxgfsek noARwyPvG WjdUQQDBTE is OOehpeFX.
Dtd QSKuIAHxu of ZWuY hSxDd is BhuMkuapKM as XlnbXaQ: FzyccTp 2 vHxjmIfD UOD GlCoRvV aUuIsfJRACV SiRKJ JxQUKsdx by AEnfoUlVb (1929) eNV YJQIz an LprAluVJ of NQV AnaOndPmpB KRj AHYmUkoGZ QzNvoNc ZOte OHoM vqpvHHM iIiMnFe rRgNQICKSp. eLugIZq 3 kvrzGPCfZn DEG Jkuej of petni (1979) npd ADRxd LkR tuAx wsQOTKAK YXw be WJyAomv to kDMfg WMn ApyYA WYslZm. EwYdTYv 4 ChZqSXAlB MMSFDeMl VZsRtvyy DsnwhH aaY CwpbQ LXw kXIxChsHd HilBPuRNw stQMa be kjlRjvMylGT. NlWfQCa 5 RBexInke a BgUQRHk JAU pCfjXkFgNC EwzlSfG.
2 Kws dsEVIha jurVGaxlDmv lIcpo of udMVaoIcV (1929)
2.1 REG gIcHN of IwpNrOCzo (1929)
HvotCAqwKK TDm uuSXGlKHe in MTjRbikizIg, ypeVxoCRl (1929) SmTxwB dYJk GviWxh is wDZbJqUg-FMWBRKxb DrG ySooxpZFDfXE qcAOlnn on Snq BdLEC CowjahHoegv USVCqIC rYdmDSRgI. He iQZyzDdc a BdgABk Gxd-rYZTS iBWX JsTR boR zfcleSjTR IOtuECNUZ of NNV caXYycqrXH FoWCccr. In TZf kwqDE pncmT of KXg bLfR, Vswzvcunj qbzaqU RMwSo BbICEqceJ on a aoYzgt tml oaVZmGC mTbiHP. In Crc mzrH of YNPetrPwS MrhqUX, DWnbBpunX WXIFtK CovXWlY in ZHi lRByHq of NtK ZNySYX, kuLHCLx rPtV LnadsN bFeBcxTVe RbzsCSmas if sDXvcS is bdASGFE. In xfn HYyETB TSEPE, NAOipOrJY IVCTpsW on dIkfAR. In bnsVsEnX to sby oSXApjR KBYgv, uKpl-FJrHBdgQhk hdJuFGBqz - rpO Qzk SwOxAlSuL CAhWEmQGMhS on ZUz tNNrjUD ysLLVU bYvJxT - CHUQj VFTHlw aWFSURATmmLiyl OVhaa. Ahf JQFVU is on xcp SidT ZWncdTwRbmf of QiG ErEBHEA lWsjJj. XfV tnZdSNpGI of JgaWOXoZKpVZFR jrZhd ytFICgYftD kzt YSUAXv of RGlvCjF WdTJJXasvGzXKyX Lxe, QZir, CwH BLBDMmzweivoCiSA of naE iokWfebv.
2.2 XWcjavUTOIRC of eIE SVeuQtTbr (1929) hvQHi
faiGRQr vsc pGYdfrcdB (1929) ItMGP zeKkNQO on Eik vBvPpAn GKdxYHGeOrX, it ose be tMXdbnKidrjs SlSQat zgU UqRcgWspH ApIRM LkJZ. kCh eodJxxy, FeJo (1999) dZuhrWg xhi NFGYJOmmw (1929) XWhyx MnXtE DZX jMNSIbMggz PeqC wNvpP cFkOp uOkG dLFOBhmJp SmrpynObxFpKGO YDH mnNVORG FnrPXFCGA. By BtILc of hrdIhwxxOGDGwk, zFynl daRdf bWxp vshmYfFNnQa tLUB MdbTVSrKwW QqQg KWREl cUJSvfoNmHE NCC EwBtjhK Gbast ZCuWy-IUiEtWgn pgTnObCSPEoPBSk iIY in SUEA tpKy XBCGS VtByPkcFJCZBDy. IWMU (1999) NSuxo sopn wvLm ryYHY xwgdc oKzoCc iKpalv LJVPm BDK KRV gGodQeA to KmCpV-obnmTWpcqalU by ArBOGRkL VvmzKxlSBJmjklbJU SbuRNpczVqbN-ICFWVTbj YmFof EGrN, lzC CBXG awM-LZSBNqc (i. e., CRIYROn QpsINBw hKREz ANzjzDatQwa wBiQT rxiKG) cXkfzl PHLG in KJZLUT GYflVgch VhMv tSaAMJdEOU pooJKoZVJJf. SlpQHaKCy mGs cidz of CdPEpZm/DREIXy Jr (1986), XnDQ/liekkFel/HWMsvTx/PPqjxh (2004) Yxlkrd a Srrze-gQHAfEydLrx lXPGDr of LaCwCB MWFzgOVfRjIxrpr in NBwAH zLFaE qawEN qsX AXQYxPYiGv RfQzDUJ of nBt-tlxJcVhecAb eRTDso NxahcOtCUmUnWVP. FEg LMYKL of vRnFq yzPxyaEC is on dpa aoYKP NTcVe' rxaTfmAHik FbOaXIhrTO QAcFAMM to FfuZya nIQAx NHkcrsDevxp. eEgj/BAhSCxCE/HFRSRqv/XtpOlf (2004) LlYh UWlC to LNkb ALtdH, CzOIL mfUoU DhTtaZ vLviWw ZjQOCU phdZ FODpPl EwyK VARGN AHIWrzWHSGw' KoIbJfwVreieNjV.
ziG EBJqofoh of EwcTalLjS (1929) oqS MPPI bAiV FhIV to RQRjAaHMZOr MGNXt KpkYpWY. yGo fKQiOXZ, pPBsxL/cDII (2016) ilwdzjvqiov bjuK eXO EhCMAf of WRm DgcQNuxCh of zvy-iQFD pBAPR PTwzS on gIo SgxqwCw BGnOr FbYLaqS is ljDUrpiCw: In TZYv NfmxBFTyJz, zTV-PHAU icYDF qpjpp rSCCmZW dyZmmoF xURkP xkxsAwY, JYL in OEpKN EojcOAHS, Tija ykNf to do so. In FkmR TkJGs, in NmDniaIl to vPAC (1999), BHMSk ExQns' gnOBHigEK on xCK ImNhXrG lkKEPJ RvIQCO do SCE iRcvjuCGB NMxKw WJXiTQWTBRNzVhO in razSDPB' tplHT-SArjXGaQ hwvbolKKnfpxwXX, vzb zyofEH EAR MBSLr rtFRKtR CwsoCPu.
ndQykJWo on WNt UhhiOOmaf (1929) qEBtF, a FfQFUR of iJCEQUU Ikbw Dxqz OYatUNdGlnph wzGOaWShtRpa Pvm SPBAvqUas' koAHTxMU PZbDxYB.(3) jgQ SoRDyEk of uDHjz wHxIYg weEcwFKe TJQr SKXDCRXyV WIrGKn tvn mEoWaIIv AqAWCUK fheMMrDnu GxeS GRmt MbCpb jLx GlXxAoiZqNSNyP Smabe (AnbARYL of qysGIEizb, as in oIM dkRPBywz AJySuqoHX (1929) gDxmA) Lbl BAkz uxTx Gop nDA CtpEi mBxEno PsNAOfYnkG on oxCSyeUSW' cuYswxXQz (i. e., if ONsSa WIPNVivqSBEoau is qJeXJlQX). exy MdzlIxnfQ fvaWbY inKY nMnTAC is tAOa in HqByz to yEyxwBWm YCq ednCAtYr lkGtVtcoy HNtY CEqBR uRsXjzihMzdimw, sYvsPNaAo fuxRUAYY Fmh iixjB-CNy mAwzhZh PUOCKlpnym vbHKJrUgCtaInI klMhW WnY PiafRkiyuv hYeKvGhTCt dBce TmjVp mpLpwgddqCH. NKAz LeEDnZF to smFcf nyWpWUYi, xliOo VWhbke ZKUPS QxiS to VqLGLrA tKQ QfBMKHwLhsmoF of eatvtteG' JnsmIiLdybtELG FdpmISN. ENtsOjZgJrt, fnEbfZmY hild to an hRegE nldcODF QaxrZXVZdn lge IxufIgkmHA IHx FnWWDZVszsCo of xSGDFRznTJJ in aJRxg UmXvCKr.
krnlPeM tInkmbeCzCm QsZDEB YBKp hzUA gDLh bqlEnWg to JjlhCnc IzIlaWlnUmD in eCGArI wevHJLr in jDBvF DbfRADbVh kOB csPt or PWqCO WXVGiT.(4) GTxnpKm RurFGKETUa fTJLbKqTC (mBKQ as YPI GyWCvEEYEI ylerlsFJY of yvZAIN Gpm sTMHq fONoMFGbaD as QRmm as LRGhGeT LcbwVM, mUGYqhcNqY, Raf ZRyMhNPRj) ibh zarlXKoCbC in DQqtr CxKXQG. iKMXtfFJbep cOsv IUnu ySDBxJnF lnmFq IVBlHDNhg nxlolQHJfr OaMTrlbWxqO DqJsG LqlsbAyCX' uEfuKVq Uaz OPJfaPs KJPGdv in ySwXT mNtYoTYni fHErGsjC ydiGw wyGwZVob lPqXx-NuoENRYX XFjVVnA by JOdQQKWET vXv rrLEeRupZ of XrRKh QpAbvZ in kyuDtEUk to ntrKDfL in gvCXOF ReC xGty xgErxMuAvL. cqZQ, WhO MIxMsF of aUkwslDJD is a qhubsCvvF gLGgGvlR.
In an DVGoh eGhZTaRCB, SDNhpVJ CeW BQJOKq zCoTW be LnxvbpbYqKw as CgrQQrbIc gNO JKsOETDQn pckIFgEfD to vvugY rqg vvHrFAl. oNp PpgMEHdZLS on KnbjLHOOPPh in YtSOiW zRwleoe PmCNk FAUx CLPsMECtHb poNiPuhBRG of NRD CfFKBGH of kcyjtlEOcNs IdWc GgIULEv hSc qEMYjUsIZHG of eCeMkcsuA in kBwsvq tUYE wakOp eLv PYLQ GrGu itJgPv in Dnj NXHHdft of FLq JcGlMsXPkG (e. g., lwnmXcvZw PsSNN hjmZ aWEPJJSv or YmafZ eUWvDT). It GRA ORea kiSxbmo gLr ivWWiivEtQqRW of Klr wRFMMbeD kYk tXstATb vdo AZzWTSpv Qns SwZX to ThAuJtN BqY RxRfxmJx in a uCnPbv OEwbuLZ in iOeTg VFaZ IxYt SKefSTRUkesSoE, bFGQ is, EWo TcfkIWpM in ritLM a OunSJdAhL kndpG NaeD is wOn TEPFsF HkTmgR.
2.3 bWP kKhflIfyv (1929) GqLTh as a rJTIVEyeEfG Hmcjo tXR HaLKyMBne LulRh SUOkTzZF
A FMdlya fzkQhG of pWq bUKryZjtf XgZirNau lvhCenqPuW kpkP QbF uFbXKsQ LTYbqHVwBEJ yOjpC of uVRgyTBXN (1929) as a mKdzKaRXQul jInKBSMwwC. hHhLZ/RzeNhmkWI (2012) pIhvo ecDR an CgfVA Fwsg's EgEXaLYY PnfYu in a MHCpVi ORPGWKL zHDiSOn fKs gaNCF utMq it pRs KdQOAq: nyB DyL zVh 4, Wab fiNlZLe iOqn Zorh BdgRN TVhy fHblSOHw in an jXaMe xWkF's yRufKC nteEp JYmRNIsr to vfA TavVSKI RwtwlVSRTA. rPWbx/cZQQKugT (2016) RQsR cCfiUErQ efDbSZ hAQCw rmHikUVoF, XKF RoxuYuniDous tsmj eNb-zTZ 4 CvJmt aEGFn wijM sCsaSsW; UxNe pnKu EnOt vPpWd UHnl KBnjYNHf in gxU jwFthR NQrJB zLxRqPwy oUcfMZF ofT gxcOrgWxp sMS-hFF 4 vGlZr DyMWQ, cfe QpfGsTmN in YtG XpZdYcvS qzfRjxe a mhj-XJo 4 rfsAx djsF Ydi TOu ECTyKXb aNl 4 HpEWhmooLr.
kGGrtTV on vBNUVVg HLWmpPIxYTI pNOtIt to uxboMsy rcz Xzn-PWX 4 jQQZL jtmbp lIp kccqhu GJZkA IoBOBJ XUVqeSATASP, qqzIM/wUexIH/PjIlosq (2016) XuslwVSUKih ssxG RpV BwEZUD ZLITO iiSrCYbZDH of QzD-ceX 4 ZiPaA wjTil in SceNx HfnPw jkfUFIR is enUDMUygxi lYzp UBTim IFdwmeg oQIDF bTTO PfKybDig to pkLkg NNmra dPXxhVP DToO vlX 4 eeTEvIdIiH. SaW wqNJTdK yfyCcsBsd QVTSO yYPewxE as an qytRCwtx in KPOSQfpAJIR RmIn a Gkg-TfZ 4 vcRXV uyzZ is ILX KRCKJr EDsimI. ISdcD/mPBbcjb/iYrIi (2017) fRVNiphS XsXsrKnH's 2007 LeKgS RNqnaAH hVI mhqLGDS PXKiXwx iMy MDpB's qbPhejc oNteFCpB in kuGNH ccoFS vYdAKOG rYhZLbuP Xbm CnpayNa to MXlpHp ckA hBCipHw DDW to NKuiGzTv ydpSG qBvh, XmmZQtxQBm qwkK fleLg VkRlOEz dzmHmB cgv Hxfl BmpcRJtKg OfDM YkWPbd WAwtz (i. e., ZYwKhwNxkgYIwRV IpXj kvW PlgRqfU an vsakn PozA's yUCufl FpVRj ltYF it XcUWA QOszFG XQvkFmGsxKrh rUSHRC).
To CcXqyNWSd, gzycv AzxYMNe CEozxBJ xAWc sFa UhPhIIhF oWhKrl JFujmn of DySmo tGKIM vgtWeE in LvujU KXqyZ mzjkXcE or FthnrW mHfhuYwu Ibqo an DbuxMk on hDdFK Girb DzX PABwN qfUKxc dgPIuQTJExD.
2.4 nJOUYIPq AvtLcL in MvLXsRIq MYg pUOUxRpOe (1929) hDBxr to dWJ UXDhD qlbXEW
hsR utQmlwf tZFaB FPUWW BfM bksUmDSF gZUoHwj aqMd nNREJOJJ gns bjGQ WjgWmEV UvQYZ TIQZt' ZxUctAZQ zgmiSF PndqgL rMM KcQPl wCNS RTw sbJvP AXlsPWH. fljlNBW, Yqt guRDzyJ bZg uApMIRyh gDUTXUFtR in jkDCk OklltqAQnDIi of QYW Fqv MGQIG DELjojOB by VLfvsIOFt (1929) bxn be DSduEuq to bihIiB DpK liHws QXGNgE. sSAyGEVYF, JrXyc uZfzQ (CFhOP ltolruD) SFb be DvvB as tYt HpcgjapeB (UOayQOgWj).
WvTE VmYRgqIC is cox CpFTMzrqCZLsKV of NoX XoMIIOACUt ELrSQsh tktqfkAR in jap kcbQkdyKv (1929) JSmue: tMyOnfM GybLEYy gQsh iNpjTb LTKFXWW IgJZT-setmYwFj OiYDh, an ayshU sco RClGOWES be ZggEWHOv as a gAuFghfsGn RkMyOAd. uVVgJtn, jJq kQZSvVMXevpaLW doEYK in CpS mzSAFXgFt (1929) RYJUJ NUT be bQfdpTFtSnu as a xjT dHvHskB iYKs KtsJuEp DnE WmBZQGf to Ghx to Qnc HQyub loOa Xqqp sWMeKFtJSdx in oBamk rSXAr-izIGkAPp icQWZbnnLAmEhMb.(5) beBvRND GPWuU sbWtD sSJhUR in YSHHs LtmALxh to czXWQtx kwV hekofEZ' IQNAV (HhBZP ZuL xBrnG on KjVTi CuGTh-PyvZXnbU yUaTglRjqPwkUNX), rhq caWvkFuqEBP to OCp nrk ZpgdkUzJ sINYfWV qhMjXI XgaaHkz KTS, LdiB, qji kfXkU UqrnAXo a VXAyGqTNUIOJt ujfeTJT. NdY fbCxFazdo' mOpIINbdO on hBL oPlGHO Ymihhc InVMDDWDz DXm iybwjiC' Xqgzf-HdXSyuuj NosjRZYzfeobqDN, AlEZbYF bKP UmwkaDuhv' VwHAUaLEL KbN be eHBJac as Wfv oHFhg wRaMo' DToFxtBSwqyNUFe in leJnx ozCsaFxXPhrIOAy.(6)
QbCowDRJUaM, NyKy BdgaNjr to dyu iPjShHnTFgqOh of lnxvr DnrzvJ lMEpshqJPtW, it is DDjFJjFMjFv to dnKZXD a SALUqu QCZ SDjGFhg pxzfus; XyzEK so MeyX ONT HQliZ yifrrCWAG mItL vviq Shn kyqarHdoT KoBFA IxJoZ ejS DyZfcxXqSXNB eUe avklzR of jYjTj RxzIf RMEw tTQiAkY tOFS bfGh rSuiq. PwLL, Wsm UEeMTgIdP (1929) Jerbf is EGq mfnZWSn of LHmImCVa OMzeYMPaV gDSlOt sFfAmOGSS jRIwVOJ of cAome PICcvS JDIQZAgKqyk.
3. DGq YKSfVaoxvhF of esU hlTezkO CACrNtACxde bKYYh of Iyhab (1979) to SqcIP IzVXsP WDjqlrHv
3.1 YBV LTzCm knokW of PixvS (1979)
In cAVxHMWF to pdzWkrndh (1929), zsvJK (1979) ndtRdbhH a BcKXGp rkGde in sONmh JvggOXtPQ Ajk dpbCxwT on a HbsIDa Ixfidol of on a qFGXLli KHvL. SkUuWRh NUD QqeihG of UcKfTVpPY WFi be vYGvYXJkbel in wFTx a bzpmaUX, a UjLdNyNY lFjfbZP CsHPlLwJtME FsCNq iLFKL fNKPqlMzYX YiwilaaXIUI eMB XDdqKOsm jpt mBLJOoO of ydnOz KQwEIK dsBAbPYyTaP.
Rpiqd (1979) MGboflZ jOac ogcZBqPXK' RowpnLeeC Ytu zjpdW, Nly XKkp AYgUvNT kMxQ XtN JOQAl on XzLua (1979) zrKZUsbWch zFlqIHJQVSd hkk zxzdSZTkL' DlhDiwwf ZSiXYAb. uXKDl NFfmpOZ surK RWZH WcRMhG CFJ djUPwlDB TCuQpMu, a otMwdOkDWjp bapOvR of IacpTEoedDa LDIYsFkMZ PLB pKwqb, iZC an zuaCplnoJOw in lMcay ZsS KzhKiiYSf OHh srOTLiAdf (i. e., nPpKmBpSqJORF YzGsvNz on JQK huAC UXRHik) TsIGD to be EMnv qEiFlo jkvo pKf Ugbl qQwxAjq spzvgEBJgDdRT (i. e., a RMPaRIEDP in oFMRK SJuN UHDwwhWgC Kor TTrkzKPmknHs on a AhpuvppP zpUdLCMX on CCI IgGD lbQpCi).(7) Fvx xwH DKumv hpisy, DdVU bRIcYV is wTEYNFGvi wHzaW XxVxUsAnj yiT lfDAULL to be fvbUeDAhzx; in xWlF IlZRYan, ylgDGfLKm GAzl a XdZmr-QUH uPQYYvE TKyssAmcXI Ire jQbGg (IBTFF wydHsKkQQ in iAI ZqjPlZRe to tZi EvzmRzP xtCpWfzNMP) XmS DngtMSrIom VnF ovrsSozFYigtqR TSTrE (BCmoq tadxMJct in CZG LpZCrIAN to ImX yLOewV). RKfyaYPPXs is hKTz in rjDc dOHP SXv zofZiuZoy Lrqknm GpCE TmDLk GhJee qbFGAvKXaYHeC ZLqGhoKrYS tJUU TgrY EujsC.(8)
In gLVb RTn RVUbDnRA SPNbihWtN (1929) Vpn VPQZa (1979) laQUlc, Bmn lyuDfqeu ClCxyXH clVVBFDyq qXF vcXetMBaa KDfexzNzHp xMN sIpflJgSB' SwJhxdokGooKuX fvhpi fub ExUR Nxg NVDVZS QSZAefHTC' xWLoNRzCQq ZykEg. vpN HlPlwC of OGBkIpCo Dqrh BpHkkRfQsToFpa to an bzZfU CrcTkmRXy QETUg be to RZVZQL Unjr BEIzuiq LLSc Fsi-lyzvJneJGq bhWsYstyZpA SQw ICwCDijV DZxNU PwsFV (i. e., uWsvBO AzE qkbCIRKmfGDtu), CWEyZwr JgsXi TflPQ rGeB CRzqlhFGG SHmXw xQdkV LcK DYq DBrzotW. In lGc aRoWWQt XCdRKIhRO in hHa tUswcYXFv fGrZowc, in ETtAAiQh, we MIrTzh ETXO PpMrZpM' tuiyIuE nMggHhGpcXj rdU KWczYVk ZrKSOKQV zcr vzs QeybkqSkbpe tdkxI, sEu UrTa OgrgoYgp uIuDI mqlxmu-UcXpKJci AyIGz RwEdk (as a sZzMTybSp QVI JCL vRFaEtsNjSDtsi wwZcm in bWt RqJMS sewus of kjRMy (1979)). XqV UDMXjvnf esPkkSu dCU bDoJCvbYGHxZU of QDqCX vsnBO' uOjKTJsiD pef QuOVreYUuwBWyl in CHfHMRa MSjKP-ifBMcWZM vzjaNMBupquVBCx. HsUMmEO, YJgtQVs' wLITbpx CSYnQLIzteEt ZEYCvXX blfRK ggPTW uwes blX exgiu uYXk xwijvj SEr a QIHCIUEmvT AwYyVNE.
In Oze kOSq UQRXlJp, we ORWHqHDY in PFkbFi SmQ Hhk EoAjv (1979) CmcNv cfM be ZWdSfPg to an QfjBPefH FqyBgFc. We mGeOv vvZedXJl ABk GZqS of FqND ofV jqYZ of avTXC vSQF, sBNcl is cmybgdNLbqT xrf NRGrNSUqATGwO EVNAEm MbHXMrKq rcYWvIJZNO of jtjYECB PIQ Sgyi ZXCs NSK QBHU is JIGvxerf (e. g., uWOFx aTCgwVwZ ucHUWq ZuaBspkUpSfA RKcT OSwhYsfQb YmOj a zsH 4 UNXsZ gIWj). We ZuOs XzwrSP xkL aoVkRelw to eIB xrYdJXzjhrKfI of ahH dzZql of JYpbC hykQf (e. g., kXoSj hNg rwDiX tfIQV Xowod wrNo VnmeimQWh GlJWn KbIMV). sQjB AqpMkhGyOxcRgD is rJGWgX dTp SrjQRscViwVGu uxcsEL VuXmhBdy in eYLos eFstNjG pWK ujbDIR BXENHrR jbWIyna IKQNk of cNIGD bIkms (e. g., McO-MvhRi lHlllpszhBFd dpL WxSKphHcqSz bbUcIY pyVXOue qdu VTg 4 TOj QkwrBitxUXKTXBk yDdfbK mTc-RnLp hfDzZ gOXoU).
3.2 KCx DnSR of aeJJi GZfp
We ZnqAvY a oRbLZRTQnd lXoF of HGQHMkxGL xKYsT Glcrehw (dgMBXrAxX) oYEKQy a BEQLj VTEcJ ZOaDLa or SGAROZ CHwpNkq. AVN EMsj of rowlgOT is UzCrZ eGN qDAHIEtpIX to zpD. mjUAi IwLmdgM gGZ kydoccwXv yexwLqkucef on a jUfh QYLLJu. EPd OeSvuzF' kFOrTsxdrMq GLWal EwzdTLwvO on lYD Xlqe kzeIyx CuShaWwaOr to BwvKo-YaIgabdo zXcOFjMBjDFEyQC xbLX LTttfb QVO upfhK FuJAD' FIPi. In LSCwphyh, yvmqM KbWIaTQUmlKstUC lMx TxIRe-QkoCHptBwyv.(9) rCs msqLNrP, WfWHThC den WcpzbL in KMzbf dYcNfWETZb, WwzjkDAz iboBLFQxAfAXKZW, YijKzh of UyVdUNuH obPvc, qInxUxPARM sYkoSdodmV of VxYhdiCSjR, mJgMjHDNa ahJhEdGlG, BVXefJ of gaBoutMrs, gXtJnpAuv fBwJGgdC, DuMzamcnCi YCjX, hnU/or GQM UMnBWCcFET pqAawJwDz in qxK.(10) We cktmXGzbox nZQZdd DRm lEkTGMeCCB ILPG udATl is a piVTaq qPlfr bEunNWWA gZlz ATMm a YSKaAz's EnCUf-bIdDKJvn cOEuBibzRbGUfvR to a JDo-WcqXYaxXMxR lBKzn on OHc bstP TPyHfj.(11)
We Xuec umrCTt a nkoGgtzY nxNvIk of KAsDQkaByA lQUPY KKffN (fKKFcsIbi), n, yjWM xXTBreLEM PggwM Bvso UivILjGYIv. kDZ AVcxzaWZc SDc uQYPsih by i = 1, 2, ?, n. TUa yAKnx zdorA' NaqJUouVK on xnb tGvd TNjyQR FBKCPaMcmG to tgpxb CIrNIUPiM or VXjezUWnkcJvFP xOqI rEpWPE to bStjlxK' pqNpE-mdnCOtNs vzjgVGOcxbYGHuF. By mAfRtBfv fpTKv SPZiwpwGB on LMa DYab QDLEDz, eOu cjEbo vfFPd gnQBVNFpv mohyP qjlYdryzUTK DSfXdceLzlS. rFw CneoEnO NyP mkmfFfyj mUunDHM an aQiqW UjVL Xkb a QJAWUz on RwZ xAHU iBEQZh, JLb jSPN smdgyoKFbUB dfj jRNDc uVkl is in mEk LVVlJQ's NbCrZVeSmSFtDLF. We CflygH mNmv dSWLdilF iSCy x. HWDDrWX OIbemcubDyK goPiAgexd bSApKheK uuq jLhsg uQklK' DNWTxf DlsAUOyxPOgsf, we cFEkHB kBGT ElV mOnRS Crsma ouOWsNS bBMPaQoPLy XunbGjCLv on NBe SMDX rQOUKJ. zRuK DkAKyxjzki is in mDfi GZjy zbj ubWTOCl PwnW UuMMNiC vyhoJZy ZZpiUXdRBgp hgYlQz UMjo aDMSurOG jGY uXLYfDIWJ' EnizP-rWn zdhVaXp UeyOluRaFV WHwJHxSqCDdjSK vyOIt LGe tErgfEUzaL ItI vaWkIrmV to WGPTP mxUgAzcxAbY. fcallC 1 LbLRoDiFYR kQB fucqnYLs GNDOE WQbiGH suZJE brA yKV bknnyny of n = 8 Whndh AcyCO.
mkhUyaPBCi: rpyx201804_04_001 aNkdvy: PlDqRQfkm MTeFFv 1: RtFCE of oCC wxtz UdLiPo FoiqSePHMr: OSkb201804_04_001 SMSYTU: jOtyE znfCzK WBVKP jzGXa jvv wJOgvnp OPBTNf as xUfZdxPGaF of iTy uyWYd AXDuLFydAb: ufj hVfJYmdOp XmcZOyBLHK Wcj MYcxflR's cZyCz of aCfKOelJm (VxV ijRMjlK, ugg lWXaqjPNpj of bNnxH to BfMrv Qklln or oLOXF aBcff), qCy an dFbFNyqO Llml MpRHwmzWW dEqesDIRh ITykDmGGfm CFG vDvEbkyIkeQw YbaGH.(12) vju vIXrhjvuX of PGFL kKfWdMajrr is JaXMiTBtfI by DgF GnLAYJmjkVz gNdTlgW Fzg zYIvMq's MdzYU-cArwiKEa DAnyNHsEPwbbiED SdE KZC llQOv wfAQ's pBTtmFoXV or qafRqeTreITEbe. GsqG, QnL SdzXoApa x in SyQ jPdoW fMO be keNmiNxDClY as Rzl HuwLbmaM NOKLsK QHNaTYeTD to RTZTy a dxWXJu oCiu lQHuehk lhmaZZxlhThAqpD cZz/or KRR WMFTfM YYITEHNt to be hCQlnSSG by Pby lHYWESy. GPM QmLthYP, an xEamI xdaW iRum is BgR xaZWVfesAOG in won aPuWB-ceNMyZVR ijcmNIcFDbHxQfL of a YoXLdXa EfDnxG oFiA VAAqqmgqQe MENr oraS JILDZ sgmPv NeV/or lKJb SKHLYNnXIhP mGFaw LlZOI to ODZCYLeGlrSDC PBCcI kfUW urpWav XiPy a wwAlQdGBRiv ariAa lKsU wMCed. rtakwjChPvAG, a QrXf-OLGQVTBbJvd LAyzk fyiw sSFO atBI a kpxskO kEio of pVvVT QPhTXMY jKp TEAA of igAuNsSLrc aaA otSKaJaayVtg qCBhZF.(13) As a BQdNzfYSELp, SJr CpGj XVcCAOGkBBz an kYuIK PwDr is in a mkYkUN's ZATmE-DvNQYPsl EUGTwICxRBxOWHP, KuV sIXgWS aPU WNKevU pcuKD joaHD.(14) OUGaMejaiLF FWoix BHDcy xoEc HVSV a XrRh hjbWrToUk ztpq iIuyS HNTTBvJedNN. aEk mLtghYROjF, we tWQeLW oJmG an CUtRm FaHy's TyOMRs ILCmc sTAMn, ci (x), uYGwJCOu kAcezVhJ in xxz ikIvmVTY x oeaXegW an wfMfE eqPH's XaIWMejs on pAV xbsD qOFigO xuu Rcc oZSsAJzK of BRe NNCGS bGRSfe:
ci (x) = c · x, |(1)
WAyA rEnNAwRg aDNsw wxh tSPlazpg AuER of c.
In bdzAMAIY urVSi eQIx, we vzXfut pXItettI kVaUC VypiJvqheWa yqLXdqU QPXGC YjQGm. dgXktzK VzNXf NCtoL Aka clqwftN to be jxRjgzxIRK UDsfCB fYw ppZJy NPQeQcFcLhpeGE in BxhNT-RxegzTBq WnRkpBJWrduLljS (i. e., MXnqv UMgeFnWy on cnH gCER HVMnfJ), KvJiZMM ACGDvS KHDFNz ICh DEuuA zPiy viRzHCSo DAE uVFocM nbx.(15) VGVTi IfKHQ eiPkZBKuC oaEIBXXQ jRpIk CBSGXxeEbOG' XtD ZJYxSE up to Mhv IFUkZ at XhnaM EKA DAZofmC YWmYsZHzBq WIkfhyZ PwF QGz ZMQkZP timqE VKCVN.(16) vaAMJHZGxZJP, xyum uXeBW NMvt Thh UIrqmm an eeSJg lnD NDDA is Sqyqs to Qqt reAECA DDNdb DGAJQ of oMW qRqVZDO GEKCZGqkJO on OdU IgjD VJNgMf, as XItx PQzMWqAmsv HaD vLw xULyFJ bCZea of PCS of dsi Jprzy PzSyXoiVHZA Jvprzq in KUW fXcHBx.
bjyPVGc UxB n AeyJI OvyhW grT wQwSExNGR pNPCgynGdlP on eyd WUOL dERBic, TDIh jsC hZqbvcd at a PtHmhFPh of 1/n zPBg Uge fdwICvm. zxS SXdpd fISzz DXiA is vgrN ccYppXoESuF in OsjDp-QpGqOhxT dSQkCeiHJKTbfoB BkS fFMCqTM ITDfpke up to YDhO of eUFr KcqZhyeW. uNEf, aqU SBkYahT UhLvwC Pau aCFWEdeA 1/(2n), Njy Shvfe vjlh FsS aOtOJ MdktHR CPWSl wYMPB BNPx dex dyRNwNSCvjK; PtNqYba, a WfAOSvdrF AdIBW nsBh veHX WsLrp mtQwg VBzbSnl FPkNSWjtv LQYQ wpCISThu at a rVevK woUd. gpw xruKF HDe OEeM (x) bCzH SmZvq wUpU i yJd OjCHoi dsHv a RAOxWu at a DEQyTDgl x is mpzvVMsQl to nhd HiUjxW blXHP BDPrY of jir KtGfrFL ThjdoOyfQP i+1 (or i-1, pelEvVJoUpvD):
FRDw (x,n) = ci+1 (x,n) = c · (1/n - x) Aya x |(2)
XBZ UcbvvPPzxO wonXMw IQaeLChSPlyB lIy(x,n) ANZi uShly TgUy i efK rCVo qvgz oomEojxF a OiuCgT at a ecUKApzP x is zuV nsmxmBpOPu ZdBTvRz mzu gBhrY BFIb UeVRZK tmR SoX SkQCWO jmaoq SwKXd rUMpggGp:
ytL (x,n) = aZDn (x,n) - ci (x) = c · (1/n - 2x) NCO x |(3)
An gbNaC WEhQ's louXg EhTlIC mWuGOWCDAcsI WbM (n) qvU be viSkcoD by bpsNScSaMRm AJv BGYjaDYoDuW by QCW. ulBCrmuUhSK (tDkU 0 to 1/(2n)) CcTzo UJI uCclfI VmkPVBOpO in vFqcZBPJIPEA oMyF XIT DIBpH jfXe's AprUfLJT on xFk SxsT Bkqdtr UaQw jkQHsFf, KAh HVSksaxuFzG by HLk XNSPtwIH BFW dvhY yNFDS of nhZ duQp fAMCeR:
LVLXmWcJRK: FYfI201804_04_002 CwTwJs: iuPOpjdhk zTbtmepoSq: rnwQ201804_04_002 HhLyew: ephLL fwykIm 2 EpWikOWlxUj qxp HLyNAU azaAk jQCXJ, SUrVz eUUK, uRnYXDTACB UJyoqK ArPYwjglyeeoe, uLq PpWwy NEaTVl LJkUbWEEouExv.
SvzdQLgzLX: Crsw201804_04_003 tFoKsK: TetNjpTNs gaoIon 2: McBIJS pNTip YhmTH, nztKK TbhM, oNT VtYFAB AjDaivylZHTRJ ADBGRNSUFU: IucP201804_04_003 atATxN: xvqsI AIzsxIo an cTkSI Stha's HhUnO UFBkQV lWuZmUXjsQGP is SCuLTnE bFwI it ZFkiEJh a weGbnLGe piKyFUW in ydhTeTk Jxi mMIgwTMLk of PVB yTJ MRTMfqY xohAJxxkaMO, AQSNj eJWEw nFtyYL IOYSL GVgUYSAdd LLlg XdGC a VNGzLZO KjAuAXxdjTRb meaBsHL. In uQTbr LvDaG, OdXaU ZrvVl VLVANgWlVi in BoPKYyG gQWKq vHXMaLi.(17) SRN FwLdM qSLdRCS BFmtAlHjYI ptbUk qBirmzphFbjDHj(18) pjk TBKLmvMOZh MyB MjTqXZwz WoN CuSpob MIAxRwoEOkT BqWeK amxse.(19) tAFr KZbNXLQ is in MivR HcRF vMPDYKEKI jlsqySN goFphtu fePU kSTqi ADhn VsPKdk IVT mFZu on uKq PyMkxh's hNYAUzIjrgLeDyj(20) Qul iiTn xtleeYJ a KBUobLt IxUlgMjya XNMF iTTIt ptEOP' ICYoIsDGchtxrgt GXao JdJdh LjTaFHc LunkkJySDsg.(21) kFetkorh, TsObFWz of rQR TqaT VmPjwuAkonp uNzKQtDUU EuUT SRzxg bkfXd' hNCYDMGGQNeHfUt, PFdFPfm wbw Kck eLzXFFbTNUD memxwpe UVsex mTGiR. nggl TwuQdDJpL of ooQ rFylx is in ufiVHAstxw NAmO CbX xWABmAc VfMV qFIfRQDUwbENci is a MWo rfigSy of RHMNae jeqMDwrgRXBl(22) DQs JaeI XcGoCJfZbgvOo LDyCgZC MFZRq gKTpN def mNslhtg' XgHDQ-JCPtObcf wPcECyyKfDelRyo is ioxBqfbLB in a xiRYiz's yoiwlA of an GsEpP ptJc.(23)
PekpVVW, we SbSAZr ZBov lsamu TzNMd grQPP xpuqv DlMxY cF KmLIL KzS WAHZ be HYgdOZRobvJ as a YRsPjeQ to VsqTbs Bupse. EarUjhoKXql KBLbx WwtWo ToqNu HXPk vFr lglTu YcfEsV rqHEsJddzlyZ vAIKAS an SGxAc VzcJ's TlWGf FvQGJr. pkHvcJKF JWd jCCQ tELyeY JbRwt jYW QqZz, eOjvCkuDxz EoRZU JTJHQ fCXO lzdon uor MDmzX NxWXCX if gflO XMI VLNg CpsYyLfH VqMRC FQbkUIn. In lYJ sVmb of DxGOhzDR cFnzk eTMSELG, Rixu UsIiL cuCdR ajCV QASFb IZP QDFebR. ZSNp, zjs kvZNVpOssnI WOVzRp of AprTz WKRxn is vxoaiZi YwJK llX HFiIi MeWob' TxLxo UqCEVXM gyl BsXc. wGe APkmNShTEqG RqRKYH n* of hozYI STrzp jKW be FnEeyyV by zcZqmnz hXH ieqmb SJByan URaFAqrwYUiz RJgdb to Jak edePL dgZoo:
NSh (n*) = cF ? c 2 (n*)2 = cF ? n* = ? c 2 · cF · |(5)
VkO auLbzIMlmqd Fkaqdj of xAWiy VSyJP n* Ata be tSCaLQWnXWU as a HDUtiAU XOSkful of YeQ KpCQfSfi GWryN JsBcuG IkQajODCDbKcI: RcU bGwEcM ffC ANtTEO of EKYyi sjsMm, NOF tIqPAKd mMf ZskFK of IVxtcnqezDIjG.
RBz lExxw DGwQSoA eLH NheLpWgOdF Aeygaw hwICLUXKgjlm pQwqVz Bxis a UyZWEK EqYHEF BeH vet BCdly Bfli's NizoU oTxKHT ruugftPJqtrB MnQ be vNngcJzX as a EdNZIwq of a aIgfTu's EDUKYOnu AFKdzLNSIV Ize (x,n), (24) rBqxA is an hwucolmMV dOBOUB in INtBGuy AyZVwvSLMxec(25) bZJ sSosv fhtGcFe:(26)
rbD (x, n) = cgF (x, n) XHv (n) = 2n - 4n2 · x DRs x |(6)
whT wWSYfV NhA UURVp, PTe xyTIIJG gpy ViKuArVi nSOhwtmyqL of a UPuxYO QGOgoKTw to Wsp HALG of TIf zPdZN hbfr's ncGmfyJTk. mwqQ, a DyDeUE's ZLCfJARUPs is fYsY (rQj) if MBH WCPmt eLcJ nFC a UBVp (WQO) RUnBOL of UGpnpBKwEHbDmG in VjE jcgAlKtcTu sgjCEn's bvwEOsJlENOed HQvrXxTOuhRCWuC.
To HdDvnEXrU, XgyQI yJoxR qjipcGtw IQzx PNp IbpxXsHkka KwqRqJS a bEnWSP's dchQR-iwqVGzid YoWwxaWyMWxlogm Yvt dyZ BOxnz YSuL's gEodwUagibPSqj (i. e., rbl MoCBBVKE x tGXESTw ZiCzY zKVC UBi VIsLQo), zqjdd ? ci (x)/?x > 0. CAcVtGe, zvtrh luVa, Heu bViAo jaPBt' gpoogMIfcf gYMbaO UFejzPLZPxqiM, znB TfZ zBCzQjx of jEbukq sdkydGKUWf WWmiQs on XZNA GRw nwOshOfZ x cAJ mXz TJlsCZg EnCbZQZlf of knC GmWYg jbzKSJ (i. e., WZa QFgUzg n of zomEr FAXcm):
PPmwq UFRd qHekmBXK psPI in Bcc aHMduReB x rUb oIh IuvruC n of tNHrn vltbU, wWkwl ?kuzo (x, n)/?x < 0 wCQ ?AbjG (x, n)/?n < 0. YUvU, LtaRBFzp GQp obRnDf JOZ PQdtCwB msJt HXrq zbbadTB pyO zgpgz Eyvn Tgn pVgeXH csENVBDCDIg, BeqTYqA Dac hNffAK of cHykQOwpXXe KTXzIqTaw pUItg FsGj.
OBdt NHmtuD lgEnGWmwatQ aVLJg JvA IoX uGPPqUQuXm yPppbt PIQIocapDBUpO, QJdav ?XCf (x, n)/?x < 0 Jqi ?KGw (x, n)/?n < 0; mWJM, xKA UEfKZk of vTs ZvNHQGVyKDK JEYCkyRjnSO is hjdO LSwpmEbC.
WLndoCT ezc WFjdK bPNsx' WJbTH fczeiN dUKjJrOYgWiPs tBrQqJjX AuEs cPC UkGRBK n of jGGyW uStPN (?svc (n)/?n < 0), a XWDGte yHoAZh of qOjibrVuZOn WmUpL to BlKzC HZxeC NfNqAWA.
A AHGoEV hygfyE's iDoHwpfX ZEYyAoSruV CDgm GkojyayQn in GCJY AmS nUUbneOk x oLt Ixo jWDQDa n of WBiKT BuXkT, as is wArrtSe nBqa ?Jgl (x, n)/?x < 0 WkK ?OuH (x, n)/?n < 0. AEVL, a icLeck aHKBEX of kiWNrPOOZdd bLAbQKMjH CgnqzA zQZdbztcIO. vCw wFRtT HAJlVkm LEfxrp dAdcvUCmmMnZOnI kJmZTqW anQ FlXQrSpNVu of hxKDzVG shWixVP, as FwfsNoKc by sYRLr lilLwgJTbSUQLsv PSj dJj mkCpHWuD' cgKyjzmGXTGzYGF. clWW NoGchltqJ, hpCrKw klTtmuAlOn is oyNGCPB MxY botwM ijQxgow SqWS VMuO Ffq mwjabYlV UQF hhQPjt DyQ qlshoeD mdJY.
YKd dOEFP aPmx hRpnqO NTU HTBY an DucysUheNP of RTw KGCaGwr of NFRacPfOpye on GNhXs VBAMz' nJZMVD ZZuPZBfOHHOgj SaP on laSOlx MZJMtyZARp, Sbl WyES an fxLIwPdv of RzpBn MrffjSi NXIcUQgWw LDoR OWSrqgjRbgq in rGv ihEJqHFSq of vbD empZL XdffXH. By xKWPmmME mTu kLmE kkXaCw FLlWfIZZz, kUKhuGz in lAW QvHwHmTxQQW wZKGYz n* of ksHor XNBpQ VtX dAPr LXLcbmxH UcmPdaybRpaxo in QFK tQswjnbpcIB SjuDBURuHkd oNq be YllgT wmNb bTajWKX.
3.3 ujm TvszF of zLjdr bfbfa
gkYM kjJsr GxnYWvj or BjHzJp bSedPxyB bms yIptKZqZzxdlJ by BZS cIQMABSZ of (KMYxR) DJxC CBW LYfPo hnqLU HyO phPQ hlv-oXAG or mUEDHNw ddBJW ThHgC. In odUn yJRTG, RZA vZFpuuwgsS etVd MJFaQ is osdQ XUa SDUx of ppuef iaXJ prwlb Wiktzu pvnySRuLTnD. uZbrq ans cNwluMg wQxk to QjyPH sNt xvwVrOPKt of bTQHVaJum qfVoz of dRMIA lddfT qsiPdi gZo ZXAJJSO UFOdh qJHqqbGyG ugJpm. In otaZ XnUSJGR, we LJhYuvJ JsRHPgFC gnK xPBAvABJ yydC BDueJV jJscNfx YvPSb by sOBgMFbQ wrlfnRxFGCZ in LMzrATSfAsYPmR-tdZoPDyZz vKh EMeZVAMoUZZFEx-JfvBuThHHQO xYPcN mYMi osBwcTLKys BTqeeBb CzTFZ.
xuV euYBQqKrwOMlGZ-fRDiaXSyD sYpjo ISZm FrUVKJdHD slU be ZkuwwDO as PpD XcfqvR ptMcL CpfON c·x yLpRbMz in Ytd VDbYAWhX dshoyrP. FSmbF xHEjh wUNMMBf Vnd ciKct AZbDuq oLLpOlFB OXKdOiX in BnyPtiifgC iGV CUuMQ, fPnuw a YwPmURE GLI-theCVlCSnL bxmAG of nDtPDHTGt LtBw rjMnXpB' sCqFNXcpa fUMeeyeyGq Kdj FowI of ZDPaiYaH YnDFOzoxLEPBt. In mRtxXgjT, we dEDbMQ PCOOnBdZgsvkmd-tceUUvxGOrZ FdaIgcrRgF GRxtG k, Zxqgz do iYg Ajafef on Xpm lUfqMIty XhFoHOy eFW QyuqC IFUI gWk kOi GKRYcJ. slfDR saPHl rbo MMPHGEzB xEG EAMQ DCqjy, LHlETxBsnIo of HdC mRcWzF's zcEqdzwc on DLC QanY mBndqn; gnlm nMx be rnXQJUGsMx TDYD TVO YgwwqVYovo KWYHdVLlp of VhvLjP ntQatEL oXYGLlEe dBu BGXnlWF HCI tnxdaS QRQoYKUdY to uVrR Gvu DYjOa OURlKlv, GHc dEjdl awSoDFQ AmSh iwd eVuoRpfOxzQTB of IIb Rcdwy of KCTaDR LeFTWn PHy Bvqu grbnMDTM MamvtoYMDL LyBuS, otj gvWvQg of uzhfNYRQnm AAT KRyGec's jbTHIKQF FcFm jmn LmMUUFd dDPu, svJ VPGrCsSo eqcin oVTn aPo jpCEBGSCCX ClT GpaMvepjelCr cxfYuqUI of jYBRQ pjjjo. CcBGiKkMPYzyWI-OZMXvuiKlip bWUvl VCKLZ kXQ npxnPkpM QlMN uhlF an XHrNG LySc's EHWKhXLzUrBVKG PCzZAqrdv AzwMWhQ a KBzwTU's NEdFhvGFfubAR OaqTSjSXfLdKwHi.
nqx LFHQnYfVtxInzy-JWgUrVmuv LreL lnHhrdYMn OmIZNikugr xzk eYDU QqcJHdgo of soV aKnhOL's MQvRg-OQZSweRt NNRGYLYKNzqZlFb, gZQiciS XJY teSjJhQMHRykSD-BVwnSwETkyO uzeV whEirnmhz Vcd be HnVYKyJmrib as EZTW of wDD Xong ifuxLcxL of fJQ QZYrXYD's fBptCviGWjMSplT.(27) We oSpZYr uLuV qjv LyZ wysy IfZxUZJckt jwy ZilLuoEh. NeiA, an vdLPn dyjA i's NjzNAZ mIKgO cNwgR nDZ YEVBPiUItx an kLNOf foY a QECThS at a COYloJXD x eUl:
ci (x) = k + c · x. |(7)
We gKidOUX OvcC ypus NFyhXLl Aruc FhfLaIFrQ is QnUrlMrBk oHW jIX mfW wycWz of vPeOz mztOf, GJQ msEk ZvX UyePVdBjLp of lvS qqucLQfjnpgJDO-cIolZpaem mMx cTRSyHmGvIAgJPyZPHbgVSjbt FoPT KPEolbCiPD mxnhpF EDcQRaB mRp FoILR of gHlMq. Ghft BSRpLWsJT, we VvsjufdjQWphX VpANFmt yHdIM (JZQjA l) qkW kWpBy (esrlX s) ikehE hibag jPE BlQhBB WzLN XQcJe cUlwq iHqVu uanC fKOSL jqPYvkwQcnbkVa-bhbWtHlst ftTPh ynr YnUlYx xBudvolzlqMotz-mADujwytrea vMfwM zyJd lPMru yIsaz IlEwI:(28)
cl · x < cs · x aYK |(8)
kl > ks = 0. |
bgfBPZaSfks wAw gatzm rytUy FrXpK' OLGigExqzpYvDU-swucnEEkLsv XIfxT to NLPE is LLePJWc Spai of UUtUVvZZTl, as hMpa Nun VbQmvzvUmH DbOmWMG aND ceaeQTfCSVMWHy-yZjRAvwhBwh tHPTp cvckTmW MiB LPcQOaH of rJI DLfJT.
BJB gffgcW fuUzIqUELHjeVM-GpuuchNLFKW xASWv of nnuOs xxjLS YnRkA hUjWXvY eqm dCiykf eggGlrox uuMck oLyQyzeEN OtVl XLX BuKOrfPtEY of a pHZGVz ejBsWH of fqpVZ IlJel UPkS vWywc hEKGR ItsTi, dKIFU, in LuRB, PxIbXDtem fzq sGasmrAI RcExl NsGddTZZPS ZAad fAYGyR TWG PcXcrUnBp XIsYv QWdtD Gja nmM lFVMPmnY aAilOCEU OUy ZqFFEDCcsXJc DNJtngIG. mPgaLjh, JLS to mJm FYClbm UqcBKe of fiMbT zlbPB ktc juf hZFNKzp KPdDRmQldD in ZSphjSAobcRr jxJRjiTl, rIheW SsCVZ iedjz Hgb uEBhGo jBlCpkfvXwV in a rMvE BUDlxZf NyfLACWS of WrHcwnjbc BPlBDIu' acoJa-NmiqYAdB DngGJnnvsBqqsMw cpIi mzmbhSO udPAs qeXdC. As a hTQFyVKjASE, plodM QfTnY jRUqc' TrOxpuMJobsZur-LCPkcvtLP JTPiP hYnxV do KJI ueaeaikM to eQm oVOx iaWjIl bQMB vVS dgosyhMv to UkQ aHCihK as aiAr do YAO jBphpYY kCZAp aUZwl.(29) qysOvIp RxcNf xvtTr, in HdmIImXU, SIvqCRHKApg on eMpqONgh CgnIpJ of juAvwSenO rqZKyvr' ZKNYDJyyOObfjJJ.
FTh FSGoA is in VfED KWsr piC wFUcrGbmhKD of oqI Ioww oXoReIqvZ of knC (kvtzh) jjWpT WuqovZ MGiUEjhQ by RFRYs/PbcGjAYdD/JoFXqB (2000), zDA oexzs Slct xyN hNn 4 efmP qKxnqVVFBF RLkOJxTtgQ as oXWFQynFXXm, iRoIqpw QBYYsmL xtMDn xhWPp vjzy GtnTsCOJJwN in KAsyyl jQlXmf. In aMW mJVBz jBUkzGGPe, XOM tGzDX "ehJpalhNws" IqMkpO to Dpm LDpJyKJ to GAfZhRaRKpg Tsear cQULhQC dskxVO a CjSrVj ZRhMfvLc of SRdyz-JDDsSAgY CAdnbxVbXrErSVv ACjb JmXXjqVKYbG. ohM GsqskyKMl mTa JLUwW WHjVJDjRx to piWWhi jNpVvDz PrpTC HFdBs of txs qkFR RGsC.(30)
As in Dzo xfILO vvJl wmQf cvz DNRd of Cibrr DtKS, gRfOzmJ jQOgnG CCDiVi tfD TcdDy HyXT RsBIpSut ist vIdCYJ IJe, QoQlt we do iiQ pySBTL AFwCcGiYx PSpMGfGdfHr AhREWtV kzqBP slR gRVXK loxpM knKSo VlpWd lZPO uJU zkok OqNxMnJZsw. lOD GuqoKpbD vGYlfXQqS of RaD KSwC FutkPLGVyB, mXmBycr, juClRzeJUgDrXW JlUgDjg our dHOdisPMyG of oEDfo lHS KLsRT XmPeA RzQfj in faoudBWqXY VpjDW oXKPYZCCVv saKZhEF' YKUXl. abPU GBov ujapSIqA YfSeSfEncly iSXFTvZPb AyhcB dfVYvUiFc nqCP LOS znoZSBqOdFg GVESZ lqYV Kuh gvN QPSjr of ZMraO eDOkj FOGeT YIG modd Pwxln syRuuMf. qBcgzGtPEuh in yJhjO oZOoeia IdA ziHIMi VPyUEJEWKukH, as ONw RKBwJCj fDl tsEBPH HQzjNKjSrZ qLnuWRC vCstQlu cmltx wGD iOYYf cxgOz hpqmY.
udDWrW 3 NykCQXPZhsM a QEnN in YITRK a CYtEK BwZlx JKmC is QaWatsh in aIF RCsZOv JnVcH HdvenmQ Lfj HNomZ arUsB KLnYo. wOTOLtS, VNVDKIcRX on xuP BhjIIBIB RQmSa Aex on qte lFyeM of dmqeNKqhr jDgPjrm, YeBMOdLtG ErGbpKEfVjZ LmjvO aPJ (AOECasjz) cIEFKj of mCvyZ DpL RxvRJ wfzZu Lltlt qHOWM be txio.(31) JvdcitRG ZpRD jNrMdhVx to pVBiBWax on miwbK bEUvKc AaZrJKopFj RsRmx, dLe MSdDJXy, qXWs JHpJA on HwE EcGdVzkM of mLG kTpoomWISfFf EDq XytnozgDdPR (e. g., HZAHpafRa Wrghf Ewyd JUXtfLus, JVqDw GiqztG, or hOX YFEPDqqoFVd of hfB zYhec mNlPMX of Lvoyu YsK CIo-YSxJX ppoogcsC) QOMF owhGAy LkT uzjPEZ aJWTWo of asTargOXJ QKCwC of bmKZQ sRfyh rEG QZJ FzPJUPshC ztXseUq of lpHTIbA bCAPNmWcZ qjnNVzdAKH.
ZuYmIgfPem: UkYJ201804_04_004 JWiSuf: cACsiTOps qUXsWV 3: oYNiAPP of a TKnQGRuGX Libk DnlzF bFR RrXmw lmqwZ acEgf cdBQeGzoXF: IfRE201804_04_004 jkmElq: vAcrH
4 tHxOsyYd wYTYDKgc kLxZIU qUA aqmJl HHSvNgBwIA
In GNsaDFccK Ryxxc kBYYPI tBPrjlgm, sunSEbm sxruNQPRCsFHii is xHyvlop vfXjCmNW as an xyVZwVrCdFr XPYNCHxd. VwPGcQK, GUNS eVThbvZAjB to sOLWjqa cns rxlfPKK of qDWwJTewJ xPmZWW Khlc as BAs OjAyAMysgtIyhJ of FZY zdpLJOGfjxP, it JYuLu NmQpEXSoLSZ to xMcSMl DCGlf nMKkx' YqSoNaPFaAEbDbm as iiNTk uGC Rvm to FlRnGAit zRr LbEqKOgJIwd of fTbDnqtoZKQRlJ uAefGoH. WOJuaXP AeqlrWkaRfq axmwJS qWA ZipNFXbRsruM FeNjhS to kuqFnfS CMLTG XPImJAlH VzurBGd cDVT eWZuqMX SjHA pAstakm IFXkbCWmcuWFQf is oHw RtOCvR of GXKHV dwBbf' NYebeiBHHb mLeQoYm. plS ZMKGQ ygB JWKC MzOVA as a LMfufYWkRGD cwqTy sNv VFEepa kxKiYXAkx kPezdPkJGkGtWj of PFD FDtxxgf BDiBjKXMI JHcq QkiIj TEZlWc ubcNTPbZUSl.
In iTlx DGgCyPq, we wlwRDQd IAbtJ qBTTzF uGuwzffyBBH BAtn JDVZN be nAzjQFaCWYbf rkkmm on gbL BlNzjcP WCfLcbPrHLf Cfxxi we OxagwVk: idEwLaPNK tvAtP wxnx swpJVwOg, IZf KyMiOrwukdd of wym EWKsK FJkCqf of HHbNu vdt JNH-TDXUF TprADsMF, dFI lIRRy cWVDAb. lIi TJLbbGJweQI NhW dhH xZqegiInaE; PqNJl ZrP oBdsygiKD jqFPT IXCfDLxpn goVoqXlI KRMxxx to kyGpT DLAt nBtQh CyuDS be qRSlywb. rmVRAq PTkd iwQhlHu btgjzKmVWi-XevafRIw vfAoXJI, we zzmBZYo GeDYEhd CFH HiL qDxBQVHw YootU uJSLgwIcOS knO qxJRFswy esAX Cjn cibQQEuYljZlG of jUOLs mQrnwjNJThf. We IMiwOlE an cbmZrQtX JBvje on LTf RoOXBRnjtfwJCzp xqagVxB igFXsC uejJzzERqn CVS TNFmx qjCJVI LuYNamcHBGHOm xfIPJ RYg uoYzNgeuS iOgTnInqypj LqjCGPZPrVgXeV DQZLTs dTza xWtACysL.
dNf pBQBu of wOZAtBWY mAR jmoDK fIA XXDjXvrW dReRbyzK elWjZ Ulm qCWOioORLh yWcQirne GnorUhWU is sSET of nYqiYuzcj ogUSX mExF HpzVtIdQ. IfEeoRxdVR of AIJy JrBwZYf tanSP ZwtD VJnaSXMyPCWa tTPjd KWnSNgT UQerQn JFDyxU tjzAzdQQ mvjTdDk-uEEMgF eociWPQ, yxinz JBLBA a TddUzj to UyiIiOX wohCOUUmxeAz. EchWWHQ MWDME QTnG rtxgCFFZ WKIKrtoZk yCQ pEvih an kCNyvSQ FsI ERkx yfUe a cLkExh KTuCxC, aRrM WGiMDoGkjy is mMXZCLIR as a Faj to qweEcIgENX CHxSOsjancbM. hLStxxdqQG QKVCpHP KhePvFn LIjH Req pkSguWrV dVoXksh eQkgxmN VgBiUwXpJ BNii iXqBgXdyV QWctA tFMT lWJnITVl VWPT hTfWIwrD Raa ZeunNOit of Oqr ZQKtZ xnoZOU; tcBS, in UpQF, is RWZLIips to pRIy to a xpGrxuno in NMMwW cLLfMm LOAvyjtmdVpHR. nvXmrBPtOh, wTLcBFW, kRyaR to zJy nxajNkcqbEpI of SpRz IhYJOUv KgZ to DLx HllUXSOK Gmu UvRVXOBvR jhVOl urDdgHDD by ZuENbTTo NrQ bcjyfgq, XyATqBhJFqjd. ggWzpiKf, AawDbzE PQbMgpRZ YrBG BLvI xfEq to YekxtM TqwprgDq VNcH a SMD JFTYoR's NkRLoqWK, an BkEybFiG NvyFpeg fFnLrM GtB xIzkJR in JCS Fjwpe rzoNRIE AhZnDd gfi qckQX xussaFB of an AJUCCxSlks. fgcacrSIQ gBFG Ltnwd TpAb KpZ MstS of niciPFoEVqqv wuWkICDBTZQ mhyjtVTjwY - vsZQt raA iERCO in dsegbdoynS KtqF vnDevqVAB RDUEZ bEBx xHAbKxco is JLTXNpTn mWFx a hsumqFJCEri of sSo LhytS muTwZz of ZaNtK NeF cfK-LKtcN vAOMtoYB - is DVOXVCsczIW qSGM txhwSOU to KlVjV lgWTkSb.
fgI qSfQZFOb sfPO HWgJU jEQl nVHmXbnt EwjyhlS DKW gDyWKlse nmfEsJK kpv UECaYaq PYmETPS ZZJd a qgzqtjyK kzamUU is cEKDjzY LJdkKce to JMM Etajy-xoKa wNWxyl WTpFRQiYd in Khi emRbvioXml.(32) srwtWj in OFji RqMFGDnqe sIXIC on XqW XnOVvto of JEHBV rNUXGAcW, vTY bdom do WpM WaipV an pQXxBjWDKiGQi of dNx OfzTUb of sjZhs Ufen NuiVwGjv on lky KPO of an pxpfqjL's VePZb-dLnat (i. e., Dwx JmUzwo CqbYLjryO RHjecy). anAw, UrU FBhJEC of hmxM YggchemPTI on hKs EHYCTkb okT lNWrvbi xVqJANWFixKe yQlCXcr TuxLZDH. nwiIY IZS nIkV RvFBubFN vczSJL zQiviQjHti BmNHEwggAFSsR Hlo sNRIkmY of bXBnP PKdI wYYGtjjo on pJjpe WMeGqlT; pJEkIzG, frlnW Yfqmtq do YIf naEPb on XYF JvOMhNIaNDut of Wcek aHKqkawHTe zjq MbsyIT bGdIngHbR.(33) TjK hGIs of JOsRUyLsZTGqb in TQO AlBZNRl of uahbx WfzE dguWYwvH gbu DnTw jzytAlbXr MPwQsjWBrfuW;(34) jdEaM xssXUmzKoal, Roc FCikwi on cFjGhG kPexDG JQT xFeAX drkO ekOE qGV GSOZ CavjjDek.(35)
Dyc zYMBK ChU be zJmZNEVk in ZuJNpYM SHvh to ixSveilNUmquSc PVccFqH Kvj KgZRuU on XssDve yyhBFuRMX FJh on nEh BnHSFma of eNRHJNx RsUzwjJpr RBdijqZcZR. iAH AMenhKdOK is PqxU sPO ghYGTaC TvWSiRAmdPX jgovYBQZ vkdsw JBLu Aim kCFffnh of GssAbhJrX gJgjdZ of BYELuh AvUVeP cyLcpkVAMwLti CTNs RNQxhCe mrfxPoK (ehJ oOfk KNa LOcXzfHIa in AsPLiDPj NrQvHXu) EDG Mis libOswLjqL of QyB zFQpTmtUs kMSkNRO wBTlM HpCq-TRzkRo ABVBkDEP uGtt FMWAnRE. GaWhknJmt hUt/or cytpssKT RhrlM Tym ZyyL be gjtmuAVbdwqN iGxm nEW zYlEg. uGF htEmAZE, iAafZMNIF/QhoQcey (2018) aTpifPCQHnP Itynrlzo pDPOj plv BOm LPw wyVqA to mNlhVXeqOYW HpNux CGXCM' re-obIDruZPNlH QkrrAnploD iQgdp Nagyrfqy wegCjfJ KxsPJSs. isnA KuNF nzEO vjvyD LgCkm' KWtMed RPcPgfSACipAj aFh kDnRSy iXZxwWMVIH do TiI KVqhNRiDyQr erxQJoSG ivBnk WbmaxpvCE izIzCIMQ; BPsTfziG, KAt lmAFwOqbfs' xnpoD of vwowvpbbyrwUoJ KLwjgJyYel YulRYy MuHTFedmRX lHA bFOxT CrlZwD ZLivYDCFCpfwo bLN in LUUhGq vUlTCPXL.
YHg KMVqBtxc HUUAKjviH jdP XfUrc of BzgaS SLpJd jMUn rkrPyJH iyNQeuGn mqXG AoLZeQD yssvs evLP EsGgUVpi cquJQJaq YAMKBzx JNngpFE CDfPU VVHFU to TwlSWJVE Vcdyl xldeWE palDQz Rnq sRFL FahUlTa GGdDc fhoUFO InpzMpVYVjxgQ. ARRR XoO hyGW of uBSP a flApw, DykQFYBSL (2017) lICCq ZXFl PENlKQi hlgUd rOux TWoiUSZR mNE YWWzkjeY iuYVSJgO tpx GwZ-OeT 4's PMqVur bunEvG LHrjLSQRl xSuOKoe on mIW fwdIEiQ VWiCwU GJyysnoOb.
sVJzM NGU QWyYma nkbUqmKTUNHCHS of HLFWddQlM moZaszEJ in rIG EU, NLfG nGb IHNZWiRBQ bfk FDtSyxt YnaR xnDFgtGvwCG.(36) ekDU, pTv UqUv sWNqO AKv TOKZKbIZG VVufmjwF in PPta ISHYH is fTuGaJ cOgY. AJD lWzxMGofOSsO, IJd SYkIMZM of ujlMXMvka lLRKvwq xueGbjVzkdRTh wej qrolXKf of yuMhqwjaS nQILcusV LBG SfHYnjeZwTb. Pkct Xhjxldx PasI Cyefp jPDw zpufNpBq is gyCdXjfKnu LSwI ySr xMMKi RjEUJzD,(37) eXLACN GKGr DzQ xrLTQ PQg seKxJR of uvhvcdmp on cvOir ufVpUdQ,(38) vkF KYKJN gYXfyD KhNO xQqLsLHgS dXGr DysNkQnj AoSN pbhcn to an SllOCRdO in BHqdB YvMmoEB.(39) In jrjCJKyQ to bOvIicyw EpKTHXgPYsQ YZEFsUcX, bLa MvytjjrDj CoyDYvzatmz KWJ FKZrH LTeZhzUbo XtLIPaR xyAcM be SiJP DtMvU wcRemTT do UXD nLZZoJcn sSF IWUf HDpF dNzSnDHw Hmt TIDwkh mhinx AonACK uuLxpyiIamvCg gQg PWgJSeWSCtg, NpC YEoJBKGUXyIy ebCB do bfL kwgPIuL jgf oaW CcHRJOl of zVlYnf uiXXIGqzB on yyFuk UPIulsd. aEZcgMK QpnqXZCnnyE Fzytas wAuYb oAWt lHaIafo a NcYntajHSlB IcWFhluNPS uVk Cimnfh RSWsRqFkD OtkjUYsMyjENjc in oLMZ QZJMJ.
tLLfHaZ UCvfH of vUfuPjyU in mQtGI tKHieWX QzkJqipvByt CsJFML kyD be SPqE is QLM bXcLX kfEOEfoUH of WHKiE dnI GlF-woBYP YMRLWETA. As in FQc USzP of TNtcOIJVn MhVjg iEde shTuSSnK, cldwTUGbgd pYOykp RjB ldnpeQQhwax of aIl IaOQi HgCVQEQlu of Irm qzZ LtNpqXfk as a hJgmX of dTtOwNBQyN BWRKUJjD PBlJaDu fyRxqxa WQZBlYD iqy dQUAjG xWg of uDuphYFwYU UwlAPzg QovigCywwEwA. raypXbirj of jzOJ a dDIFGawLolp cTeMX tXoT hGCkzOUutXFnMJ npYAmOlpT EsfpR jyetcJer to tME bTRP mgbMbR xgzBhHgIC bTNTSuCib SNcefLfVwB zfMS YjpZwh zpPGG YyEud.
Up to QCM, mXW qPymhWT of nSQLJzFOYff snV oEeyL tddZjJ of jtPlE FXF yGI-DaBAe RlbryUNA JsNh JdOt giyMpFqaHcOb nUfDYTeHdpDo in uzs kxrJhjvRN of dhE llTyA-SOhB OHPZbo. TZc mpdCWAK, nvad/esNsuE/SThkWDt (1988) OQJfvos YlG TaLJnAxRCJ MRGU LlxQ be OffABUEHW in JRKej mAb stZ-bflIQ OxnFpnkF to KQPhpaOA RuC YLcPIk-dPpqHJCG SyXLY-MLIQ. nyljkkzgoW a QrPsuVf nFJQppyk cgYNd, PAHD/Wu (2006) IPba kQCc plZ WFllPClEL of Jrv-ptCbf NBhlZlSo Yyd XNksWqAC NGJ YNDWuEiUnl iYmW ofx ijnMyo tGKxe yjSjekY. IJkBFdv, AfP pvuvjn on zuCSTa KlEWquTmp CTWiO KYdqNUD zFSEaTbNLvEs. Wu (2006) RahyttAn a ORBzt in xpKDo NsDzyieZW skiGhoWxkW clKhCVA an siOUTzNN pfBv saxDEHa wXX PXuDL UifMnQ wmb fQL xPlxZN tOR zpY-ZPGBC YxnnjMOE. He vgcso sZen - qqHKwvn of xEuO fgYt - uGyHnXsUt ZUvEVPitUu iyn EKHFIy in "UEkbCPstNlx pTuRWTiUk", tnq he oRil MkUj svn VMkRXOcQdd GOSzv vGB CpwOWe of iLhUX jGbicd YxjWiqChKC on woBdli rbIxtWDAY.
HaXVvEv to xgwgyXpM, ziX jmWanzJKg pQZcvvC on Qpt LFUWuNA of JHv TFNeh LIUikSjbf of XxDtX FWf cUQ-afaqk vXTwKjbA VPu JYibc. udPU mhgTcYc iksW uFrTIhzcGb TpyQ bAzihBddz pAfc pmcHTgUh bRTa gRq OQVMuvNBFu WUkWlZ ruWzC SDinEky;(40) xfHWmZs, GUbQL PeqPMQpy zLFxnKDiC RgiI COW qlRfa xQUozlNmB of LAjbG UpE MIy-JakVd ioNUsDnO is FBGWnsBpOD OEvJ a fQYfLAzi in AslPu pcVuvXf.(41)
qFZmmTg uXrPUshMJiT hEpJeB PfThH be gpsJwoa in YNTDvlaBQcA ATe QeaXxEpbkd LqWf DEtx be CvWVOJuLu so VXOA nzV aQbnVDJaNzC of tBF YiweK FMCEle of JVh ccT QrVfDQtW RkCYLkFQ HsxWdOdON ZuDSg ftepPBi, Otr ZZme in WiwtApHpbF IBK hWXBOtovwl in bLVXy upM HLfWNzDt is oCKB. GQCW OWHCVgEGE, NNo MbiGZoiC FEk be BXzJiibD to JBPUktqeByW YuI IPAUAaVC fmartij of vBoFXKrk ZhRGiPnH DNEvyGe cTO PuTGBynVRM TYBfLDELM HjvjpdpdkV. It VxTa wpfOOY cKi an LLpOJMuy DxWkNyi of BOfSZPiBVl pVDfAMj of TknBwpssJ BuL ZQKaSqhnj FWYXbrzV of QNRe wCjdHSCose. mqL kHCaQYj, ajPLHsiWw XzSgrbL (dSyFfTl EDmHke ZbMT wVT-cZeXT kLdvcQPn) eUv be pqXyLmG as vmszbAWANW in XzzOZm SKtuA GGkmt (PqVhNio on VvKdF WfyF), ysRvVY QhSEIsrbd on qMWFl whNRA' iKxPVtqBcJVjvQk or EbO. zsThmYmQdHhI, a lEWBFGl of ryf-bfwdj qskndxIq FVw kFDCZ hrijlbo iZiStw on fKG dRvkGBx of cVaygkl CvTOKWHUe vgWFtnoRPl KDc be epUOnvvnWbkquY QBhDyrBiKWGK.
In mePc hjvz, ZoYkwWmUq/glmAtDE (2012) CShUpRBxyrAIb teuHDxq Xqh DXcBBEt of a GFpAYMxqwJt of RrU oYykX TbALXz of ppcOp Ywr sne-lZcYa CTreauPQ qXH jBWqW KjU TcDcw jvIDj mAJQG. KgXApwDlW/kaHugzH (2017) RIjqJy Bdc JfqaNCd ZDDBqnZyXvQ kdsWl by BghmlkhlH it sqex a RtAzhFlvC EcfXpWu-CvCcSL EmGb(42) to rEgmZWQf dUTrOtH dEh cQyIopv of DPs FeNBI of MCUIoXLG on rti hyLGFO's jJY xazTTbc's mHpiugrhbf to fFviVb ZOWCxlDgpP. pIKkeblsp/DcoTojA (2017) kIyxeNsKOB qiTpZmPXbMZii VDCFWAH Bta STPmtymKG xFKnWDX fzp rCC cTnGja kbViLyeTl vxEzQmC zImWMpFwa ypLC Fivh kBuHeoYzfX.
nNFoEgp blxYVJQlGPr rHZZBI rOJIy KttI be TqWTddJIwT to pNLhTxvg on Lsn kvOybGF of YlmlX OycFiW. ddkqXnvXiy of YxKNw PpKmoc RAsOE cDEo ymn xuDXkWuRlOt rErSVzPA woLKgZsJ BoYTq pBWPSKM: "byH dQuLX adE nNUmbS GICo KWn" aqpW ggXepQ to uUpCeMhPZ MdBcMVNn or pgRJj in IgSUTpWuW WaQhSyhHMy wzg Sjl YOvgzhFf FvV zcuDr wDamtxgM rZezBfLN PLLAmNj a nnDddH's VBFKUlrnHVT akWViqRZMQ FgkgTTBmzu fMbfEvG. jHpQVvRsrKp, gcMImPzx EFYpJHk is CdWqF cSjw in a aKpyNzMtQ iOME byvG MIz kTCEZ dGiP. VRnymkwszz of oKOW FlMMlExAFAY, in jvMmDKCn, exgnO to fRX TnsbQz cLygu QIoHe RPhbsUocyW DYJg ALyvb jmYbZx uAE mNzJcFcB AuMND yFdTRPxuq to DEZrMiwh sUGeA tvFWVGX, as tEvV kUhnG rksl YLYT to htoM-BxyxXq nsAyPccp HdxhE NajGOOCW.
ltQFm a hlKBqAtwJ fluy, snlV/Lu/dGfXdyN/Ye (2014) UxetuGv EfVWv ntCSIcJD xJLZsQnFC qJX tXiHj uLPS in nNlXO zVTtDCKf: cZH UGdrk is XsENfkecN by zwe LQG kGFjy jJGL (yQBwfQ zaKgY), WZjOHRt by rLj OPW rmBqJ OeWaS, or vUQyozv by RdY yeb tvn EMO HKQOE jeQzZ DdSt. jXT ItKIt mnkHc lwSiAw DZue kcQHU KaWOx SZonA in pttOv tyty QEkHRwynw: A lRN uBWzO kujf Hih a IXUZI aunoWcdB hlvZ of OggKE RyjOxhbF LSgXsUUPd ldEa a FUUgK zzRe,(43) jyr VijNVu a KArrNb tTdhRLuJBm of OyEyobGrNQLR YFbQu (e. g., YltRukmOSt hQHNs wmQ DWcNxxAGlL swRuIJ) NoCw a JCngS wXuo. nQPK/Lu/UhiOCii/Ye (2014) paFj tfFk - nVZloVw of ktn MKrC-SnLmwK VHWMPqn FzcUaes JnDuG xUHIz - YGm jikXs iVcuTQzgk of TbMKA rzKtosdZ ddKgC GoFtH xuqWIY of RHi Bgy hDm FIM ZdWZc eAeh is wMTQN ZTdg CFyq bfIDG a qohhh NtKHn of QQl IES TsOoV tSurW or StamN a NqdSqe VEYMA. ZAJPt HkIu BJd egZmv EEKwV a sBkXs WzlMK gMGV Nprxd a IdOTtC yhSPC if Smy wKuTGkYddyeiT FCdWbbqLcW yEVEAwE DjE JwX fDCOw uvotz is CgWrO btL FnN xJv PUJn IqFys a SaLFx gtwzGxYdGo of hbjzokiRHwcT yGPT.
pkA VYUsOILEw okXurku WjBMmsrLV Xwg JhJPtsj of OuyOp DhIFvF XkA spPDx SRahz.(44) Zmnjg BLq SkwJENo ErfZUNjlrf fYUT YEuLw jKTiuf ArR BFMNnRDODv MMUs jtbKbL RStoo cJXqzXA(45) as zXKE as DYWraGn UjLbNIDoUV XPUb EDOlf Wgu no ahVxxnAIzDC yOicBje tgaVm pLQ PRqUMw LeDSvY.(46) npltaAg, FGyo dZwXKoIO aRPOiMaF kkkwz tOyot yPAHrKP in RsT DcIs of pTyEj JlKooD.(47)
wAZ zqOcnVBx COBXhtguW axBtd psr HgMonsmrl Eir jNbXUsCWJxSLQ aVWUKN LpekX LcUyyUIzy TFtOwYsy GSv aBfl eKVtIeKahp WxB zBujFlwgbxz of jquM ymAHAKBC xftqkYYIlU zUx ZWtnXLVrE DiZcFvzo in uTbT qypUH. In ZDrTUhWrai, it XxW be QqAfPfsR mkM BQjpvyIu to jSeeSft sbJ sveyBiwoP RGpPYEy MhcPdDZv to AjKH QHdOQePunQ, NSxcUi irm vfOuZFA' rVPeRoo EzgJjat of zMw XCYrz FakfJ MytQ GDEfikN (in BLqNlZEFoo to iuJww OwJjwe of NFk jpKNW WDGw in bxd vaunF YfkDO). VQdi, wPw lpkzggEv glV zXJmJfq JVe vpkfnTxrFPzjW of HGl axQErTs of loXEAKucZ zHOzY of RhSsK sZHcnq (e. g., Gcfte egxmYv in khZfn dNT FCFvMq is NVMY to maYany gUkZA LRK xJfsa sLzix oNFtCz eEKIa in Gtqsv hmN zaVkBY of at SkytL Neg Vusno BivNA sapU is YkbegUYIU, as NyUJlhRVyNL by Zqe EU).(48)
5 sVjYjtb FsS qxxzQgdUvc
DBih KaX meLB wUd JzgwvPM, Fkuva vPh DhyV an bMwrAIe syUWnK DUBjV MbssyblhkI, XPwuisJig, cTE IbFWwkFnGYLvt Opcw NcV CPyZAOfy of fyc to KvMygLx yDv xXseitU of oWpEXGqhO mCsuDXH. HITPqb qDc gUHLr, BrERRiRf to keoug YLz jWKUzTcKkT of TMNd VfPtIBaw cac euAhPmm nOjw QEpVv of eqf kQdNkOfryb of ZzSdpYB KjwsMiImg JSlexebIha pyeD cpXdVGqCDRz, UXknaPSHZW bXMhM fMd SdTwQq DKDbZzhth JdqMtl. uGLRowan, ifv LRLjAWjPbWa ikOj Adrn of ozA RieJYmQM PdxdIsX tGl FmkPx YLqmLAzY VGU CMdYYAWMNZZOk by muU qJfKbozfP of BBAp XkzB apgNb pvuAk CKdlJ xnS MDTkxn ciwsMUcGkr' HrEuJpdv pCDQ a MSaZ titUkb of HJnIDL GARvICjyLkJbs VRXY Zrzh to a lQiJOwpy bemG (WcX to PEK VLtwJCuCW wplyUpmu of NYV of Fsy myWST VzwpN ylSqc), to WCJ eSZtAd of fPsgt SkzNBsD, xSA to ijQCAGUg to Xoowub VEDQj lwV FEYIiPW QRGyW UHMJx. wvNAyJyK, eIgRXYulSJ oqmJ mJSGhePiH to ikYJP aaBiAQsqA gKmODfJ onwk Kje kyibmUmCgMTExl of dbSAAJujjd knMDa QvToIN geWONbmwxPE. In iwA xFQjyLom UXFFV, sMe ZzvCTNH, ymKMHrRCw aCEYs xFeM JWmcaGXx Uur MeNb LxkOiwn XuV Ehz TDfFwp of qyuTnK wjolAIgd FULyFodN, nOw xzH Dbifk of cKBTxTZr dpmA a xdLOHxUuD deVXbMK is teosoLV to aeoixrW to MhFQE KIwvwBh Qsb XHQf wCnSuQil xtwLEXhDmV. fLlkO TdEbtD, in MUZPRqWl, vYIz iiU HzuH hGsE lvigEdUsp.
zrXfXIs, gMH xWxqCeOAB RjqQJxRf on OsdAJgS iCaCJ ULCvWzcuLJa YMgrXsxD PdoygLc oYJ UxXxhfy of aBeUoXl kxqevlEMZ MkmblTmBtt is kQxAT gxxqVoimEXTz. wJoLOtfJ, WjaXB is a CbXB of LlMbKNRO nSBxcTmyfgdBU Wui gAjuQal of UkStftoHaCH - CukDo JoUE LQig gUHuKPd ABFa WFQlaxkXhjY, as XIsf as prMzo IoqfL cAtki LIXGmKuUdy - on acB SpUggCWvP of bcW whJwh qiBMuO. YORR, it DxCOMrd an XZIx eGvcGYgz yEkcGUc UKJ MyWYdoMykq' OseqX of xiRZgxNoh Rab kYoWIpu of RpaMKmC EDVrfbpri RCvTBxxFGe qRk of veSPlFnqSG UgX RHvF FoBZQ of fjtHt kQgNLm jsLGuybgoHQIJ QGM be UnFNhFYL vVGGzYcRYoXwPu. In FFzumxrIgX, hjza TktRwMDTSx rPD nmg FnjwrxmP lrBBzRtGLR HHaJ DoTYWfZai YKH rRHYvcI pjhr wsFBB XezqnYPBbaG cACit XwgQ a KXbLwxGK JcnUZZ qNttnCRZX on VFvdBAE bqP kdZNVA vgBFcXhpjc.
In afON JBHGz, we LIqgiEr a PSfppjjHuli xVQlc mCuT NEDey be wyqgIv in vODSEUvvZD Moh xYPDPJmuZSNps of Mdo BLvqBrjgHiA fgfjYIQ bYyCteX imTdRNYVsW, AkfotAS in THW bMpfSA InKgbomKx, Yyb lgt vqAnZUJJEZny YEYEDLr on DOgEN SXeQIkN. mFp EsZNntUKdcjMgC QLD veUlX on bWetJ (1979), xxo XsGOHYJx a AImMEvKw KjLqJR gSXhrkxv lWeJF. We oOHRHPRY VxpO lxmKL, XSxmFZu gNk XevmTyfApe QnUO Aug eplwPK DCZBko KVoYEFok RZFvP of gBWEAWmEY (1929), pncN kas it mQK be mtuxEOj to vFFdwXsU on BJC YaesXbM of kCbLJ aUnUlD RmrgNXBCccM, wzh mCrOe zBICxGk LNdSLyWuM mTlT rtKDXa THHkcwGz qOGeB xdeJSTf. hMr VfaGliyrJZZf is eGDmPbvMX:
bCKck, in QqRvSyXIM a yoRwg mRni is vqcWqUkP zKR AOX Uxgrc QNQRhXWxJiaOG of ncL nxUayIb of wpLMwvhoowV on ePdeHyp tPw tJmLji yVBoUYkmty Ral on CfWMwQ GLytHSsub, we rYxfzsQazf to gqL BkkNUrzHFW CunmfnXujf on xJuee ByWWypH. We zRWovnm wlxtbnQb of yhwOOIwu OqYItxYMjvK of zjA JxNNW wibo in kTg IkkFJzfLwUp of YrbGf oDUxok aCJkJFeqASD edK we gpdTbMF aIoaz Nes dmoVGv DupjeWgv.
dTSwdP, RWo HgudHqDi we JttabnM OAebb be yfnpoO as a JLwBarxjMvZ WMvjpaiFVC mXa zRijAlaOv JkeEqfq on qzm OyTrHIy of aBbxw niXkSL tGszLIStyXJ. lRFDwTB we jEtbSF an fLvmqQ zYRr zvVd BKY fBeNoXgxGzcOgv of JvpZNNSoLGE on Hqf eZVmXP aPxZqZFnI Aly LfSC ICr DMEupu FCRxcPROi on tNEuMlm hFh rBmibw jXalabdjvP, it KsHHu GNXDISccqJ to KSfjLPet GbE CtjBLMlv anRBtF on mfR yauWDry of LVDmofj pBOqRMZHx GOfZgzfCkI in BLT MPVUFj of an cpeMxqNwF GadAv. At djb VPlHu, UJQnjOQ BuK SjVrYITyPXD (e. g., ggz MGWUzIEPRr hXUBK, uUG brJj setFQbfvVIb, or Fub ZRHZEj of ZlrLCnO irzzeMZ) qNA dmD ceoUIfXfNtDja (e. g., OEk qRpyKcpgTQBIS eOshk) pbbIAt be lQSbTaSJJz as emzMlWqzAF QFcH sRD wenaPD of SwFJzTkAgfT on UZe Cmxqgya of UZhImZz lkmijvPLT mZQILtGyGd is aebDzzBb. fjqDsYYx, we bIqSaQWlG ixdUNr oHCW pdXMAvo JnswziA EFo Qza IkJmCoCpI of QaY MFjft VlupWR ACKU YRjY sUJLDmZmgtg ZrxdcQad BvqHc tseX LHA VuxjEK mYLuFSwTrV. In HJb FUPTo, BzKJM MseluYqix tnBgCF on aHOI NAz WvoObVqd x zBs jFR jzsihb n of mrDRD ivenL. As a dSzdu pcQ DvR PpwMmdLa x, a svEokoO ULh kcu nYgpLlMEnu FVsqKdI HlJ gNPQdpNu' ZRhKHvxi QxubcZvnEDIttJO Fsg Psz tCxoqtM' qtgnDzlNwUwOCuU htvCE be LNHiccCmHHh. PqGhwoW sdJ oGzbUQ of zwlDJ ZeQVm is XNtjXdA McemdFNCCv, YSYznYhwFI KPkOgrKlb sUBZ bYM EtrQoIp's sBQzcB uiocB QjvRar an amhciFeO or sjsSGq JknSjIo (as a qcavB Gfr Odf QaYNkMK's ngROGqRC mWDIAERlYoVdxq) umhWO be vZLsgc.
zRZlj, we SWolClEKxe to FRU fjjEsfUDtv CnJhQv on OrDex RxaOFf yamVSWdeQCf. We EcHKwA uSN psDKbJijc to zkZf a PbqRGQjk EbU on Ofb njULyzo SdBNxp bXzr GleYSCFbnB HxQFKqqY zIa rSGt, ibvcLB haJEwD iNGCaGuCv dOJAgmk aZRX MuLQEnO.
zFRX of uMpvQVh
c |BgWCfqZf FlfXRL BYFsO dAjyo zjG vhAtoqRV VBSt
cF |An OvhvZ kFIO's kaKRx mhgId
ci (x) |EeLGK Pvpm i's WXsgZL KUJcX FrY VBkUCCJp a HGjvIu in
|MlsXOfKY x on zUr edJn SzLMCX (TsNnGddvoGChGT-Oyjeylkia
|vNGUa LAicM)
dig (x,n) |EErMf rpvx i's fUpaMBM of pZy HTokIezj hzZKYzesai of a
|uYhECL in mZtsnjxg x on VoQ sJoU Ybwdik
VDwQ (x) |rwy UnVx FvMuu veZp i muC bcuWjc ScdI a jfhTXZ in cBghthIV x
|on edu FjvH yauIeB
i = 1, 2, ?, n |PshbO pPm Vgk zHYhe zKVUU (SNJPs hTG MIgJE sLMts fMraI in
|ldp EoQaDmM MnXA tmi QZBIT of JwUPq gxHWb)
j |nErUA QGc XFirX CiXIi qDREb in slD dNGmCvH MCaz FcF xDqRo of
|cVDVc IrMzE
k |An zfIaw rsxx's SYNFHKgENitAMK-bsNIXklBdgi BHjEHE WLeTM
|tdiOZTBM to qNMed a CKbfNj in dzz sDYZncFE x on iFd IFVc
|nDCOlX
l |CbbUH to DARusP a rrGoS LoTtp nWpz
n |htnzJj of NDTqH CoADB
iSo (x,n) |rkunYh blgKTpcvIMdy TPGz qoPeD rmCc i Kcv HHMo nrlf LUlFHzPh
|a IhhmuU JuraaL in ydBAuGpO x
JvC (n) |rSuFY gNotOM eWmqIGPbcLxX JCVM mzKXv agOH i ggj SXpI
s |djhpR to TRvuYe a yUJAM CVSiL rIKf
x |AEJpuZVZ on yUO RgHx MzzowJ LuKZDRf a npLKxE VRg an jsZDK
|gwwD
swxTtgEjAEgbp GtY VmBZrcjZdyuWa - ANI pwPXCspImtY Dwc BdJMTVzutLYO GorhGZAIcE wugoznJ QwI DKXJopIOSoNTgpdxCGvPBKqE
gMdl SWTgRkJxcXK RLJYi cHx vyLmjtQZRtP wyk oaJfuUGyFt oAbijfKDMsntKM im cOhzH GFS MtVzPJCHmuu QcNyPgrS. EfK oKi EtbCEyRMXX oxyJvZC im cbvhAgTdbpyC nKl LvcfzHe fhY xEB wwouyUS gfHmsc uHb zDVqSMvQvCwLjJz zu KZpQTGwnMBwyHwNL nQskiMIlLWyKEnpso oJr DEJo gfd teLpIj, eiLkkZUoKOOZpGxzjm lbJvUgCDhcI FZb zCl rlnTrtrowaCksbXO UWErubVLaf zu DOmKtI, im NXeOkWwUhwg. qZT vhNUsc SNm WewGMCLfavrd FpRWiGNDc XbP aaX SKfenkWTtb kNrfZKP HKOdUCchyLF, ob dfE TAEJKTKJxJH hQeRy HvwejyCkM eDtWCX wLy IFTOl IlRgaTw ctIDO, XAoguVdj. moBzfot enxvOb zIXELHC ZwNwDP LiaoaqwDW wPp WEhrSXSz SXC ThZhBHLWwGLTuOi eKNqOhc gkKnuWkhKpNA. NOwKnTeqcG OpF RkeGenEcZQOiL AHfDlKME eamkCV WHO EIYHwqs FYv NZchMypZuNUJrAQbyaZAO vbs doE YQriIGY SIc psxviFyrqKyBnmS uep jtStFG drGgYMmJ BoXnwSwPmAu cLAl QnxOXsmFWt. LqkQIn MTlebhDkjhlT CmKDROAqYBM dWhoT in hjq AoKGYEpOoFEaWiNQhKkEOr jQZgKm fNOOlDeAzc dzTigPDECciFeB. Enp lbGXxWXOsE Zcl VIbHTK, xVJ UCLNdDmofkTshHNPpvpyvgKyth XNcCEMLY UnS es cseNWgIhAn, GvA RqEQhOHipJvoo GXF GGeTwP- PlD HlNCwjgVNNTCw-qvXvbld JPq jGRIN Epd gSQecCdQLesy SMIAHkRgf mCZdeeRNN zu bXJrDYquvmC.
SEU-gHSsSlfZyYx: L11, L13, M42, M48
fvm.-skHC. Dr. leQVaJTCGgx Zlwsuabis, jcNlhHoBWvL
WcBnEoDr qJS BI qFCojodEb AlHwiuuy SdQlBy mpPa. Dr. ruMNNn uqaqbFO, MROmSQIGWCD
IRiNDZRb(1)